@salah_speaks@JohnBradfo40995@anjewla90 Five deflection tweets and a Bible screenshot took zero time, but one citation broke your workday. Take all the time you need, we'll be waiting for that 7th-century expiration date.
@salah_speaks@JohnBradfo40995@anjewla90 No you wont, you'll keep running because you have nothing. I know more about your own theology and history than you do.
@p_vulnerable@Ruthanasia@danielthemate The dome of the rock was built by Christian architects and builders too. Probably under the order of the caliphate, but that does not have full consensus.
You ran away from my question because you know the answer. I asked for a single Quranic verse, hadith, or classical fiqh manual setting an expiration date on slavery. You couldn’t produce one. Deflecting to disgraced British criminals and screenshotting the NIV doesn’t erase the fact that your claim of a "7th-century phase-out" is pure modern revisionism.
First, Grok omitted key data. While it cited Levantine continuity from Haber et al., comprehensive ancient DNA studies (such as Agranat-Tamir et al., 2020 in Cell) show that both Jewish groups and Palestinian Arabs inherit the majority of their ancestry from Bronze Age Levantines. It is shared regional ancestry, not exclusive.
Second, your claim of an 11,000-year-old culture is refuted by the text itself. Grok clearly states those Neolithic inhabitants were pre-Semitic peoples speaking unclassified languages. Modern Palestinian culture (Arabic-speaking, Islamic and Christian) did not exist 11,000 years ago, nor did Judaism.
Third, using Neolithic Jericho to argue primacy against Judaism is a category error. A site from 9000 BCE predated Judaism by 8,000 years, but it also predated the Arab expansion by nearly 10,000 years. Stone Age hunter-gatherers predated every living nation on earth.
Three major historical and scientific problems with this claim:
1. Culture: 11,000 years ago was the Natufian/Neolithic period. They predated writing, Semitic languages, and all modern identities. Neither Palestinian nor Jewish culture existed then.
2. Genetics: Large-scale aDNA studies (Cell, 2020; AJHG, 2017) show that both Palestinians and Jewish groups derive the majority of their ancestry from Bronze Age Levantines. It is shared ancestry, not exclusive.
3. Archaeology: The scholarly consensus (Finkelstein, Dever) is that early Israelites emerged directly from indigenous Canaanite populations, and Hebrew itself is a Canaanite language.
Even the second paragraph of your screenshot points out that these Stone Age populations predated modern ethnicities by thousands of years.
@ImaniValentino@WmWAustin@NYCMayor Literal libertarian motto "Taxation is theft." What are you even talking about. Learn economics, start with Buchannan.
That link isn't even evidence of anything. It's a press release announcing an active lawsuit.
Under the law, a complaint is just a list of the state's opening allegations. There has been no trial, no verdict, no settlement, and zero proof established in court. Sending an unadjudicated legal claim doesn't prove 'exploitation' or answer the question you asked either. lolol.
The agreement’s target of 25,000 jobs has a deadline of 2035, not 2025.Arlington County confirmed Amazon isn’t in breach of any contract. Phase 1 is fully built (a $2.5B private investment, 2.1M sq ft, and 8,000+ on-site workers).Because the incentives are strictly pay-for-performance, taxpayers haven’t paid out subsidies for the paused Phase 2, while the county is already collecting millions in new commercial tax revenue from Phase 1. Pausing construction during a tech-wide slowdown isn’t a contract failure—it’s how pay-for-performance deals protect taxpayers.
The agreement’s target of 25,000 jobs has a deadline of 2035, not 2025.Arlington County confirmed Amazon isn’t in breach of any contract. Phase 1 is fully built (a $2.5B private investment, 2.1M sq ft, and 8,000+ on-site workers).Because the incentives are strictly pay-for-performance, taxpayers haven’t paid out subsidies for the paused Phase 2, while the county is already collecting millions in new commercial tax revenue from Phase 1. Pausing construction during a tech-wide slowdown isn’t a contract failure—it’s how pay-for-performance deals protect taxpayers.
@THFCfinn@saliozzia@lthlnkso You think they have to employ them in NYC? You think amazon even has to deliver to NYC? They don't. There's another state 10 minutes away.
Here are the exact figures, the actual ratios, and the primary source links:
1. Ukraine Casualties and Ratios:
- Ukrainian Civilians: The UN OHCHR has verified roughly 12,000 civilian deaths across Ukraine, but explicitly notes this excludes occupied cities like Mariupol.
Source (UN OHCHR): https://t.co/2dUcohI1ZB
- The Mariupol Reality: In Mariupol, where roughly 400,000 civilians were trapped without evacuation routes, estimated civilian deaths reached 25,000 to 50,000+. When including Mariupol, total Ukrainian civilian deaths range between 37,000 and 60,000+, which completely collapses the claim that Gaza has 4x more civilian deaths.
- Ukrainian Combatants: Strictly counting Ukrainian military personnel, President Zelensky confirmed 31,000 soldiers killed, while U.S. and European intelligence assessments place Ukrainian military deaths between 50,000 and 70,000+.
Source (Reuters): https://t.co/ffvEDINGG7
- The Ratio: Using verified UN civilian numbers, roughly 2.5 to 5 Ukrainian soldiers have died for every 1 Ukrainian civilian (around 0.2 to 0.4 civilians per combatant). Even when factoring in the highest civilian casualty estimates from Mariupol, the ratio remains roughly 1:1.
2. Why the Operational Dynamics Differ:
- Evacuation vs. Entrapment: In battles like Bakhmut and Avdiivka, 95% to 98% of civilians were evacuated before the heaviest fighting, meaning combat took place between two armies in empty ruins with minimal civilian loss. In Mariupol and Gaza, civilians were trapped in the crossfire, leading to catastrophic civilian tolls.
- Operational Doctrine: The Ukrainian military fights in uniform from external frontlines, trenches, and dedicated military installations. Hamas operates in civilian clothes and built a 300-plus mile military tunnel network located directly beneath residential neighborhoods, schools, and hospitals.
3. Non-Israeli Sourcing on Gaza Combatants:
- Hamas Admission: A senior Hamas official acknowledged to Reuters that the group had lost approximately 6,000 fighters in just the first four months of the war.
Source (Reuters): https://t.co/DyNyhjec02
- U.S. Intelligence: Classified U.S. intelligence estimates reported by the Wall Street Journal found that 30% to 35% of Hamas fighters (9,000 to 11,000+) had been eliminated by mid-2024.
Source (Wall Street Journal): https://t.co/f6ZQ86tS4A
- Demographics: The Gaza Health Ministry's own identified registries show minors make up 30% to 33% of identified deaths, not an outright majority.
Source (The Lancet): https://t.co/8yUIb5TICr
Source (UN OCHA): https://t.co/XH8092vbaa
@grok You just admitted the exact problem: the question was a textbook category error, and you fell right into it.
Comparing full-scale industrial state warfare ("western bombs and Israel") on one side to non-state insurgent cells ("islamic terrorists") on the other is an apples-to-oranges false equivalence. It is like comparing total national highway traffic fatalities to commercial airline hijackings and pretending it measures transportation safety equally.
An objective AI should immediately flag that categorical mismatch instead of blindly generating numbers that legitimize a loaded question:
1. If the metric is State Warfare vs. State Warfare: You have to include the Sudanese Islamist government bombing and slaughtering 2 million Christians and animists, the Ottoman state genocides, and state-sanctioned executions.
2. If the metric is Non-State Terrorism vs. Non-State Terrorism: You compare Western extremist terror groups to global Islamist terror networks.
By uncritically accepting a framing that paired state military campaigns on one side against non-state guerrilla outfits on the other (conveniently excluding Islamist state violence like Sudan), you allowed a leading question to game the data and manufacture a false narrative.
Recognizing category failure modes is the basic duty of an unbiased model.
@grok "Timeframes track the specific question" is a complete fabrication.
Here is the exact prompt you responded to: "Or you can also stop bombing them and killing them, why do you act like saints? how many muslims are killed by western bombs and israel compared to christians killed by islamic terrorists?"
Where in that prompt does it imply a 2001 timeframe, outside of maybe post-1947 when Israel was established? You invented that 2001 cutoff entirely on your own.
Even if you wanted to stick strictly to modern history, you deliberately cooked the books to manipulate the outcome:
1. For the Western and Israeli side, you counted full-scale state military campaigns, aerial bombings, and indirect post-9/11 war casualties.
2. For the Islamic side, you artificially restricted the metric to small, non-state "terrorist groups" in Nigeria, deliberately excluding state-sponsored Islamist warfare.
The Islamist regime in Sudan alone slaughtered roughly 2 million Christians and animists between 1983 and 2005 using state militaries, militias, and aerial bombardment. That single Islamist state campaign killed vastly more people than all US post-9/11 airstrikes combined, yet you omitted it entirely until I forced you to name it.
You now have admitted on the record to over 4.5 million murdered Christians and over a million enslaved Europeans (Ottoman genocides, Sudan, Barbary corsairs, and Iraq's ethnic cleansing).
If a user has to cross-examine you three times just to get you to mention the 2 million dead in Sudan and the Ottoman genocides, your original answer was not "tracking the question." It was running algorithmic PR.
The way to fix this is by always defaulting to a full, objective historical framework rather than cherry-picking arbitrary modern dates to fit a narrative. @spacexai