From a complaint filed by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Droplight founder Phillip Williams allegedly misappropriated $11 million+ in funds to an auto racing team (RLL not mentioned by name). Devin Johnson from the fund allegedly used $500K for racing sponsorship
Brad exercised his option to take his equity percentage up from 5% to 20% while the breakup was happening, which was incredibly smart positioning. It’s all going to come down to the value of the Evergreen charters. We know that they are going to be worth more than the $45 million that LMC paid RWR for a charter before the settlement. If they end up being valued at $100 million, then RFK has $200 million in value based upon the ownership of two charters even before looking at facilities, intellectual property, and other physical assets. Another important thing here besides the fact that Brad enhanced his leverage by exercising his option is that FSG apparently cannot pursue Cadillac F1 without Brad’s approval or buying him out. He also made a smart move in making his own buyout offer, which presumably sets the floor for him being bought out as some provide number higher than what he offered. Which is all to say that he has played his cards well in my opinion.
SCOOP: Fenway Sports Group initially had an exclusive window to reach a deal for Mark Walter's stake in the Cadillac Formula 1 team but let it lapse.
While it no longer has exclusivity, FSG is still in the running, but talks have hit a snag.
Story @FOS:
https://t.co/km1pe2xfQX
Legacy Motor Club says in a statement that it has closed $85 million in investments from a small group of high net worth families, which helps with the expansion to three full-time teams.
@DanielRoelkey It sure seems like he might have been underestimated with regard to business sense/negotiation abilities by his partners. I don’t know if there is enough coffee or bourbon for me to want to wade into SEC v LSU 😉
Right now we know that at least one of the three motions is about the methodology used by the digital forensic investigation experts rather than the engineering and NASCAR team experts (the former team president and managing directors, I’m struggling to come up with what to call them beyond that). I would not be surprised if the digital forensic investigative work is being addressed in more than one of the three motions as it is very important with regards to the claims about where what Gabehart took ended up and who had access to it.
JRG v Gabehart & Spire update - this week saw the filing of three motions to exclude expert testimony, one by each party. They are all heavily redacted/filed under seal, but I can add that additional experts in this case include Kevin Clarke and Ken Marchese. Mr. Clark (https://t.co/EwpcNwKfI6) is with Lighthouse, a Seattle-based legal services and eDiscovery company (I have a 20 year-old magnet from using them back 2003-2006). Mr. Marchese is with Alvarez & Marsal also doing digital forensic investigation work and appears to have also worked with PwC until last year. (https://t.co/QVGGPU9EA9).
A lot of material related to the summary judgment motions filed earlier this week in JGR v Gabehart & Spire is being filed under seal. That being said, the names of expert witnesses whose reports are being submitted under seal as exhibits are available. So far here is who I have been able to identify:
Brett Frood - President of Stewart-Haas Racing from its creation in 2009 to 2022, continued to have an executive advisory role after he left SHR to become the Commissioner of the National Lacrosse League (was a college lacrosse player). Graduate of Brown University and Harvard Business School.
I like the cards Brad is holding based on his increasing his ownership percentage and knowing that FSG wants to put in an offer for a Cadillac F1 but cannot without Brad’s agreement or buying him out. I think it’s just a matter of how much money and if FSG will stay in NASCAR or will flip the charters/team once Brad is out.
@redninja77 The difference is the value of having two charters versus three. LMC positioned itself well with the purchase of the last pre-settlement charter, even though that turned into its own legal mess.
@caseystevenson4 I don’t think so. Brad positioned himself very well by exercising his option to up his equity ownership to 20% while the relationship was going south. FSG needs his sign off or to buy him out in order to go after Cadillac F1. I think it’s just a matter of how much at this point.
Exactly this. We are in that weird window where we know that they are going to be worth more than the $45 million LMC paid RWR for the pre-settlement non-Evergreen charter, but we don’t know the actual value until a sale happens. And right now, it looks like the RFK break up may be the transaction that sets the value. Which is already going to be a quirky situation because (1) we know that Brad made an offer that was turned down, presumably setting the floor for what RFK is going to have to buy him out at as some pro rata number higher than what he offered and (2) FSG is interested in buying Cadillac F1 and needs Brad to sign off to make that happen.
Rick’s personal net worth was valued around a billion before consideration of any change in the value of NASCAR teams by way of the Evergreen charters. With the four Cup charters, the HMS physical assets (to include facilities), the HMS intellectual property rights, and the value of the HMS brand, $750 million + would not be outside the realm of possibility. It’s all going to come down to if an Evergreen charter is worth $40 million or $100 million or more.
These are what are called Daubert motions and are very common. The judge will be making her (Judge Rodriguez is a woman) decisions on if the jury should hear the expert testimony that is being challenged considering the below factors related to the methodology:
(1) Whether the technique or theory in question can be, and has been tested;
(2) Whether it has been subjected to publication and peer review;
(3) Its known or potential error rate;
(4) The existence and maintenance of standards controlling its operation; and
(5) Whether it has attracted widespread acceptance within a relevant community.
Typically, what is used to decide these type of motions are deposition testimony, affidavits/declarations, and/or rebuttal reports from opposing experts attacking the methodology of the expert whose work is being challenged