@anuvrata7@a_south_indian@grok "indo-iranian". When it doesn't show the matches to Lingustics and it's Archeological elements.
Again. Don't try dump Archeology and Lingustics.
Anyone can consider or claim
@grok@a_south_indian And is there any Indo-iranian Archeological elements in Hasanlu? Like seen in BMAc ? Like Soma/homa, Fire rituals etc ?
Do u think genetics can override Archeology, Lingustics?? for Example one can say a specific Ancestry spread a language without Archeo n Lingustics info
@grok@a_south_indian Yeah and most of these agreed points among many scholars but isn't talked much as others, Is the issue. And did you think Greco-aryan Clade is valid? While doens't meet Lingustics creterias.
Do you think Hasanlu having Yamnaya validates Greco-aryan in Lingustics ?
@anuvrata7@a_south_indian@grok Yeah 1997.. thinks it's valid still now. Nice. By the way greco-aryan fails Lingustics and isn't accepted now.
Indo-slavic itself is facing lot of questions and your "eminent scholars". back then still failed to provide Archeological evidences.
@anuvrata7@a_south_indian It's interesting that you became a person who would believe old claims which makes no sense.
I read that entire old paper which your search shows from. It's not supported linguistics
All you do and think is.. Override Linguistics and archeology.
Have a good time.
@a_south_indian And there is literally no route to make to india.
@grok pls read the above. Greco-aryan Clade isn't supported by linguistics and even Claims of Indo-iranian orgin in that region recived no further support
@a_south_indian And there is literally no route to make to india.
@grok pls read the above. Greco-aryan Clade isn't supported by linguistics and even Claims of Indo-iranian orgin in that region recived no further support
@anuvrata7@a_south_indian Greco-aryan Clade is unsupported.
Archeological is weak. Even I can show screenshots. It's easy.
There is not a single Indo-iranian elment in that site. Your whole claim is that.. it's Indo-iranian because of the Admix.
No linguistics, No Archeology
@a_south_indian There is no credible support in linguistics for "Greco-aryan".
Neither there is any Indo-iranian elments in that region.
Linguistics isn't also in support Indo-iranian in Near eastern in steppe model.
@anuvrata7 Literally all following local Hasanlu samples in the IA are just Mesopotamian type + Caucasus BA (Kura araxes + Catacomb which is just Yamnaya derivative) + deeper central asian related signals from Iran, why is this a suprise to you
@anuvrata7@_piyush15@shreyask10x@a_south_indian It was Mesopotamia not in entire middle east. mainly it was via Sumerian texts.. and archeological links regarding that were found IN south asia not steppe..
(and not in the areas where Yamnaya admix* came) Anyway I am not taking that for now. better examples are there
@anuvrata7@_piyush15@shreyask10x@a_south_indian Literally that's the weakest claim and a old one. GGC and Cemetery H is due to Movements of IVC. literally no credible scholar shown strong evidence of Motifs or cultural patterns
@anuvrata7@_piyush15@shreyask10x@a_south_indian I am not a fan of that retard. Steppe in south asia is before 1000 BC. Earliest noted is female mediated. Sample size is not very bad.
IVC ancestry is around 4500 BC. possibility of early Zagros presence is just a doubt.
@anuvrata7@_piyush15@shreyask10x@a_south_indian Dating of an langauge branch is more than "PIE/IE" is there so corded ware or Yamnaya so Piir was due to them" No linguistic data will support this.
@anuvrata7@_piyush15@shreyask10x@a_south_indian both can be late PIE, mianly corded is late PIE. But they are not "Indo-aryan" or Proto indo-iRANIAN" . Give some respect to Linguistic data on its divergence and Archeo-lingustics analysis.
There is not plain "PIE/IE" in middle east.