PIE homeland is likely around Armenian Highlands/Upper Mesopotamia region, ultimately originating from migrants from NW Zagros.
Check the latest blog on Indo-European migrations with all the evidence : https://t.co/mAq0SsDHyD
@RichardHanania Most Indian-born can't do startup (H1B tied) due to green card backlog. They become successful in CEO route, but despite that, they lead in entrepreneurship. Here are actual numbers. https://t.co/SO0Prkyqnv
@RichardHanania The U.S. has ~5M people of Indian origin:
1. 1.7M born in the US (median age <22)
2. 1.1M on temp visas (H-1B/F-1, heavily in tech), they cant do startups
3. 600k Green Card holders and 1.5M Naturalized Citizens (half of them are 45+ age and much less in Tech)
96 is a good no.
@Steve_Sailer@RichardHanania >0.7% as many people as India
That's a stupid way to compare. The eligible Indian-born pool is like 2M+ people in the U.S. It's not like all Indians can come here. And if you look at under 45 age and in tech, it's much less, under half million.
No doubt Israel is impressive
@RichardHanania The U.S. has ~5M people of Indian origin:
1. 1.7M born in the US (median age <22)
2. 1.1M on temp visas (H-1B/F-1, heavily in tech), they cant do startups
3. 600k Green Card holders and 1.5M Naturalized Citizens (half of them are 45+ age and much less in Tech)
96 is a good no.
@ibipataudi@AlecStapp Large section of India-born immigrants (1M+) are tied to H1B employers, you can discount them. Also, among GC holders and citizens, only about half are under 40-45 age group and much less in tech.
@Openatic That whole gimmick about “Elite Takeover” is not going to work for long. Steppe theory is only strong for Italo-Celtic-Germanic and Balto-Slavic branches. It doesn’t work for anything outside that https://t.co/bI9bgZVgpj
@SR1_aryan@IAsiatic90046@Ugrashravas Their major non-European logic is non-sensical elite garbage
Hittite Anatolia 10% CLV
BPgroup 10% EHG
Mycenaean Greek 10% Yamnaya like (female)
Swat 18% Female mediated
Ancient Iranian 0% Sintashta
Only Italo-Celtic-Germanic and Balto-Slavic is strong from genetics/Archaelogy
@Openatic Steppe doesnt work for Indo-Iranians/Greeks. Ancient Iranian samples have 0% Sintashta, Swat is 18% female mediated even after 1000BC. Greeks are 10% Steppe and mostly non-R1b. Griffin warrior is 0% Steppe
If core Sapt-Sindhu is not 40% steppe R1a by 1500BC, it's over for Steppe
@cbkwgl It's more like NW Zagros to SE Anatolia (both part of Upper Mesopotamia), from there to Caucasus and Steppes
Another route from NW Zagros to Baluchistan, then splits into IVC and Helmand (which births BMAC)
@cbkwgl Namazga IV onwards we see migration from Shahr-i-Shokta towards BMAC, solidifies in Namazga V. Gonur_BA1 is descended from Shah-i-Shokta_BA1, and that is base ancestry of all modern Iranic population (including ancient samples w/ no Sintashta). BA1 is always next to Harappans.
@FortressLugh@HammerandVajra Steppe doesnt work for Indo-Iranians/Greeks. Ancient Iranian samples have 0% Sintashta, Swat is 18% female mediated even after 1000BC. Greeks are 10% Steppe and mostly non-R1b. Griffin warrior is 0% Steppe
If core Sapt-Sindhu is not 40% steppe R1a by1500BC, it's over for Steppe.
@GamerEQ7 IVC source is likely to be something like that. This sample has 17% ANF, it comes from Upper Mesopotamia. It is also connected archaeologically with Upper Mesopotamia (skull deformation practice also matches).
IVC and Gol-Afshan might share common ancestor with CTW pottery.
@GamerEQ7 Y3+/Y40+ and its subclades could have come through Indo-Sakas when they mass migrated to India. Satraps ruled till Deccan when it was sparsely populated. Much easier to expand. Z2124+ is likely from Andronovo
No other external source mass migrated to India in last 5000 years.
@SR1_aryan@IAsiatic90046@Ugrashravas Their major non-European logic is non-sensical elite garbage
Hittite Anatolia 10% CLV
BPgroup 10% EHG
Mycenaean Greek 10% Yamnaya like (female)
Swat 18% Female mediated
Ancient Iranian 0% Sintashta
Only Italo-Celtic-Germanic and Balto-Slavic is strong from genetics/Archaelogy
@BmacIvc Also, Upper Mesopotamia (not lower) was established by migrants from Zagros (not CHG), both genetic and archaeological data supports that. These Upper Mesopotamias then mix with CHG to form Shomu-Shulaveri, Nalchik, Khvalynsk, which ultimately forms Yamnaya in Steppes
@Tammax2y1lj@SR1_aryan They enter India through two routes. This is actual mass migration rather than just elite level kingdom. Sistan province of Iran and parts of Afghanistan are named after this migration. They have mass migration claim with archaeological and likely genetic record.
@Tammax2y1lj@SR1_aryan You have to look for the examples of mass migration from Central Asia. The only example I can think of is satraps who mass migrated due to nomadic wars in Central Asia. They settled deep till Deccan