LM

[Chris @NNracingHQ]

Scottish FA KMI Panel, 2025-26 season summary

I've scraped every KMI panel report the Scottish FA has published for 2025-26, all 39 PDFs, 354 individual incidents from August through May, and tallied which clubs the panel ruled for and against. Sick of seeing stats that are basically made up. These are the facts.

This is based entirely on the SFA's own published verdicts and is entirely in the public domain. Checks welcome

Reading the table:

Rangers are the only one of the three with a positive net-correct balance. Upheld on-field calls in their matches went their way more often than against.

Celtic sit at -8. Most upheld decisions in their games went against them.

Hearts are essentially neutral.

On errors specifically (where the panel ruled the ref got it wrong), all three clubs net BENEFIT — Rangers +4, Celtic +2, Hearts +1.

Season-wide: 92.7% of on-field decisions ruled correct by the panel, 7.3% ruled errors.

Definitions:
"Correct FOR" = on-field call went the club's way AND panel agreed
"Correct AGAINST" = call went against the club AND panel agreed
"Errors FOR" = panel found a wrongful call that hurt the club
"Errors AGAINST" = panel found a wrongful call that helped the club

Source: https://t.co/eqWjHmuKVt

[LM @TBkWrm]

@NaeBull @JamTarts @ScottishFA @spfl @ChampionsLeague You are aware that Hearts would have to qualify for the CL, even if they finished 1st, right? It has not cost them £15 million. Why are you ignoring the errors which went in Hearts favour and therefore cost other clubs...including yer own.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@alanjgarden @ghostofSanFran An apology for a Celtic fan defending himself? Lol.Aye, right, ye are.A screenshot is not evidence. It is clear manipulation.The video shows the fan only pushing Kent after Kent knocks his phone to the floor & stamps on it. The law allows the fan to defend himself & his property.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@ghostofSanFran @keithr58088 It is clear you don't understand the law in this regard, so yer just continuing to talk shite.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@TonyMac67s The fact the English sports media and English fans have fallen for his cheeky chappy persona is puke worthy.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@Ricky1349516041 @David3228551 Aye, that SFA President, who is in charge of Alloa and don't get me started on that Hearts CEO, who is Vice President of the SFA, he must be the biggest Celtic fan going to be involved in cheating his own club...what a pile of tripe you all talk.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@Outland82234662 @Amcg88qf @q_7777000 @ColonySco @ScottishFA Shhhhhh. Let those who do not have the slightest clue what they are talking about continue to make eejits of themselves.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@NBourhill @ScotNational @MayGray29252511 @bbcquestiontime One can only hope. BBC are a disgrace.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@hertz1995 @jonatmurp @jambo4000 @TheQuietKid18 Lol. Bullshit was it only September. Apparently you need it explaind the season last 38 games and regardless of when, you would have less points overall if not given. No chat about the decisions against Celtic the last few games, eh? Mad we managed to win games despite them?

[LM @TBkWrm]

@JackS98060 @chanleymuir @ScotNational @ricmontg You keep regurgitating this nonsense. Wilfully misrepresenting what they said. The fact you think it is funny to troll people on such a serious subject says it all. People of Scotland have genuine good reasons for wanting out of the union and you taunt them. You sad sack.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@markdocherty05 @TheQuietKid18 So, was yer CEO the left or right hand of the SFA (he's vice president) that "gifted it"? World football wandered in during the equivalent of the 85th minute, without context (all those favourable decisions for Hearts) of the season. Meantime, who we are is Champions.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@ghosty1879 @JamboMalc @J25504353 Lol.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@JamboMalc @Dillon850075777 @J25504353 There are plenty being honest. You just don't want to hear it. We get it. You want to greet, so dodgy decisions in your favour over the 38 games don't matter, for whatever reason. Those decisions aren't corruption or collusion or cheating.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@shaunvlog_ @thickcustard88 Lol. Clueless.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@ScottCa34732527 @p_mac1992 @TheQuietKid18 Hearts obviously. Unless you are actually trying to argue that Hearts getting 3 points disadvantages them, which would be a whole new level of absurdity to add to all the greetin & whinging. Particularly, as Hearts dropping points to Rangers would have suited Celtic & Rangers.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@markdocherty05 @TheQuietKid18 We see you not bothering about the dodgy decisions in Hearts favour, which the independents spoke about during the season (you know 38 games, not 2). It seems to be rangers fans greetin the most and Hearts definitely got points off rangers because of dodgy decisions.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@jonatmurp @jambo4000 @TheQuietKid18 Of course not. Somehow those decisons are not corruption or collusion. Somehow those ones don't matter.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@adam88brabzz @derekclarksport Behind all the greetin, what they are really angry about is Celtic can win games even when decisions go against us (see Hibs game and Motherwell as just 2 examples) and they seem to struggle with that. It ruined their "fairytale" and they need their temper tantrum about it.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@derekclarksport What nonsense. Yet again, no mention of the favourable decisions Hearts got this season themselves. Apparently, they don't count for some reason. You were talking rubbish last week and you're still talking rubbish this week.

[LM @TBkWrm]

@KuntyCatz @ColonySco @ScottishFA Who cheated you? Why would your own CEO (currently vice president of the SFA) allow or be involved in that? Why are you ignoring the favourable decisions you received this season?