@DarinaMarty@rodrihgh Si no me equivoco, viene del griego Berenike, "la que trae Victoria".
Nike es la misma raíz que para Nicolás (Nikolaos, la "victoria del pueblo") o la propia marca Nike.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ The arguments are exactly the same for embryos. Killing embryos is not "commonly accepted as a bad act". And zygotes can be killed as well, for instance in IVF.
According to your own measuring stick, are you "ranking human lives"?
Regarding slavery & Nazism, precisely my point.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ Killing a person is widely seen as wrong. Killing a zygote isn’t.
Your logic fails due to an unnuanced use of labels as monolithic sources of truth. Constant petitio principii.
Flawed science interpretations caused horrors too. Science describes; it doesn’t assign moral status.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 You are, of course, choosing to completely ignore the word "identidades".
There was ideological identity birthed from the territory, among other things.
Just like today some people may identify as "Western", "European", or "African", despite belonging to different nations.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 That is not geography, that is a territory delimited by ideology. And Catholicism wasn't the single delimiter.
Why do you disregard the other sources? Portuguese talking about Spain in terms of "glory", "nobility", "love of the fatherland? Of all Spaniards as "our people"?
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 You are here to dishonestly disregard all the sources that do not suit your ideology and insult for lack of better arguments.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 Do you think the conceptual base for the idea of Portugal is the "Portuguese nation"?
Or simply the lands around the city of Portus Cale and and nobleman carving a chunk of León for himself?
One thing is the origin of the concept, and another the idea it develops into.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 Conceptual BASE.
Yes, the conceptual base for the idea of Spain is territorial.
If Catholicism is involved in the concept, then it´s not a geographic concept. You started claiming that it was simply the peninsula, now you are moving the goalpost.
You also disregard the rest.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ I have not said majority makes one right, do not deviate.
Precisely my point since the very beginning is that this matter is entirely subjective. You have your opinion, others have theirs.
Pretending that this debate has some sort of unique, mathematical answer is absurd.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ I do not understand what you mean here.
If you are asking why does a zygote not have the same status as a person, it's easy: because many people in your social-political context simply disagree with you.
You may find more like-minded people in countries in dark red or black.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ You "can", subjectively, people did historically, and still do today.
Some even did so using poorly reasoned interpretations of actual science, as you are doing.
But that is beside the point.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ Your whole argument is a mere label. It's an extremely poor foundation.
I repeat: widely accepted does not mean universal, unquestionable truth.
"It's punishable by law" is easily your worst argument yet: there are many different laws, and in many countries abortion is legal.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 This is not to say it was homogeneous, nor to deny that "Spain" would often be used geographically (it´s polysemic).
The transformation of the notions of "Spain" and "Portugal" was gradual and lasted centuries.
But there was clearly a non-geographic notion.
Granada =/= Spain?
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 It being poetry does not detract from it clearly reflecting an conception of Spain beyond the mere geographic.
Your own source is not poetic and does exactly the same.
There are prosaic sources depicting exactly the same idea. I showed you one in 13th c. Aragon.
In Portugal:
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 Lusitania here refers to Portugal, just like "Tarragona" (Tarraconensis) refers to the Crown of Aragon. Antonomasia.
Both where then equally considered to be part of their idea of "Spain".
Here you have a king of Aragon "honoring all of Spain"... in the 13th cent.
Not poetry.
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 And you do yourself no favours by twisting the words of your source:
"restituir A HESPANHA o senhorio que os Mouros LHE usurparam".
Restore TO SPAIN the lordship the Moors usurped FROM HER.
That simply makes no sense with a merely geographic understanding of "Spain".
@SclDionysius@Vicente65579904 Exactly.
The restitution of Camões' "noble Spain" of "extraordinary glory". An entity lost and brought back. An idea, not just geography.
Your own source goes even further: "restore TO Spain the dominion the Moors had usurped from her".
Clearly not referring to mere geography.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ People can and did, subjectively.
Most of us can also agree on subjective moral judgements, such as "killing people is bad", but that does not make it some sort of universal law of physics.
Your reasoning limitations come from your over-reliance on conventional language labels.
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ Morality is subjective, personal. Everyone can make moral judgements.
Determining moral value is not a "right" anyone grants.
You may be mixing up morality with law enactment and enforcement, which not everyone can do.
I did refer to your question.
https://t.co/2BHJuKrmxJ
@PhiloIchtus09@PROMAKOS_ There is no way to "prove" moral value.
Morality is ultimately subjective. Biology can inform the debate, not settle it.
As per the usual:
https://t.co/Ak8wVLpcGN
@Clint_Davey1 The US supported the creation of the EEC when there were Soviet tanks all the way to Thuringia.
They support some integration as long as Europe remains subordinate to them, especially militarily.
Whenever Europeans push for real autonomy, Washington shows its teeth.