Just Tim @TimMacc - Twitter Profile

Pinned Tweet

4 months ago

I needed something to redzone my Claude Code subscription, so I’m building an MMO. I’ve been looking for a project ambitious enough to truly stress-test my Claude Code Max subscription. As a longtime RPG fan with nostalgia for the old text-based MUD days, and with an itch to build a game, I decided to skip graphics entirely and focus purely on systems, mechanics, and world design that make a living world feel real. That’s what I’m doing now, and the design space we’ve reached is one of the most fascinating things I’ve ever worked on. Around the same time I started this, pure LLM-based generative games were getting buzz again. AI Dungeon had its explosion years ago, and now there’s a new wave of “AI game” startups. But every time I tried one, it felt loose—too much freedom, no grounding. Choices didn’t matter because nothing persisted underneath. The AI just vibed and generated something that sounded right but meant nothing. Characters forgot their names. The world forgot yesterday. It felt like a gimmick: impressive tech demo, not a game. That led to a better question: what would good game design look like if it actually integrated LLMs’ generative strengths with the deterministic, shared experience of a multiplayer world? Not AI doing everything, not AI as a bolted-on coat of paint, but an architecture built around what AI is genuinely good at and what it absolutely cannot do. That’s how The Unwritten began. What it is A text-based MMORPG. Persistent shared world. Permadeath. Dynasty system. A magic system grounded in theoretical physics. A frontier that literally doesn’t exist until players walk into it. The world exists in three layers: - Deterministic layer (bottom): The Athenaeum (think Oxford crossed with the Library of Alexandria) and the Seven Cities are hand-crafted and canonical. When I say “meet me at the Forum,” everyone knows exactly where that is. This gives shared reality, weight, and stakes. - Procedural layer (middle): Consistent, learnable rules and systems. The magic works the same way every time, can be taught, documented on a wiki, and remains fair and predictable. - Generative layer (top): The frontier. When you step beyond the known world, the AI generates terrain, ruins, creatures, NPCs, and mysteries—all shaped by lore and constrained by procedural rules. Crucially, once discovered, it crystallizes into the permanent world. Every player after you will find that ruin. Your name is etched as the discoverer. Forever. The unknown becomes the known. That’s the core loop. The magic system Reality is woven from the Threads of the Utterance—strings (as in string theory) still vibrating from the Creator’s First Word. Everything differs only in frequency. A stone wall and the air beside it are the same substance singing different songs. No spell slots, no mana, no cooldowns. Only knowledge—and the cost of being wrong. Four disciplines, each rooted in real physics/philosophy: - Sonaecraft (String Theory): Every material has a unique Tone. Transmutation requires walking harmonic bridges through stable intermediate tones (A* pathfinding on a tone graph). Wiki-documentable, tradable knowledge. Cost: Harmonic Contamination—your own Thread drifts toward the studied frequency. Masters become visibly marked: metallic skin, vibrating eyes, echoing voices. - Attestation (Quantum Mechanics): Before observation, things exist in Fieri (superposition). Practitioners can delay collapse and bias outcomes. More observers = heavier Gravitas (decoherence), so Attestors are stronger alone and weaker in crowds. Cost: Fieri Drift—prolonged superposition blurs identity until you fade into ambient background. - Codex Arts (Simulation Theory): Reality is information; practitioners read and edit the Codex (source code). Integrity checks make consistent edits cheaper and contradictory ones dangerous. Exploit path: Logic Bombs that trigger localized Excessus (buffer overflows) for impossible writes. Cost: Data Overflow—overexposure causes cognitive fugue; long-term users lose the ability to process normal input. - Nominatio (Logos Theology): True Names must be earned through personal experience and interaction (LLM-generated unique paths). Comprehension is 0–100% via Insights. At 100%: mutual understanding and co-creation. Effects are consistent and balanced across players. Cost: Name-Sickness—you gradually become the thing you deeply understand. Dynasty system (permadeath that matters) Characters can die permanently. At zero health you enter a ~5-minute Dying Light window where others can save you. If not, you’re gone. Survive long enough (100+ real days), build legacy, and hit thresholds → establish an heir. Heirs inherit 40% tendency (faster skill learning in mastered disciplines). NPCs remember bloodlines. Dynasties stack generational bonuses. One death without an heir ends the line completely. A Bloodline Registry tracks dynasties, ended lines, and player-written memorials. The emotional weight is real. World design Known world: canonical Athenaeum, Seven Cities (each with distinct identity), connecting roads. Unknown: eight biomes, wilderness up to 50 rooms from landmarks, dungeons 20 levels deep, generated settlements capped at 30 NPCs/15 buildings. Lore explanation: frontier exists in Fieri until observed and collapsed. NPC system Two-layer dialogue: canonical core (fixed, documentable) + expressive LLM variation through personality. Trust tracking, knowledge maps, action parsing. Challenges Balancing the tone graph, Gravitas edge cases, Codex integrity/exploit design, crystallization quality threshold, and dynasty emotional clarity. Why it matters Most AI-in-games answers are weak: full AI (meaningless after an hour) or AI as texture (same game, prettier wallpaper). The interesting path is architectural: deterministic foundations for trust and stakes, procedural rules for fairness and depth, generative AI for emergence and personalization—each doing what it’s best at. Discoveries persist. Choices ripple across players. Knowledge is literally power. We’re still building, but the design space is the most compelling I’ve touched in years. If you played MUDs back in the day and this resonates, that’s exactly the feeling we’re chasing. Looking for playtesters—comment or DM and I’ll send an invite.

TimMacc's tweet photo. I needed something to redzone my Claude Code subscription, so I’m building an MMO.

I’ve been looking for a project ambitious enough to truly stress-test my Claude Code Max subscription. As a longtime RPG fan with nostalgia for the old text-based MUD days, and with an itch to build a game, I decided to skip graphics entirely and focus purely on systems, mechanics, and world design that make a living world feel real.

That’s what I’m doing now, and the design space we’ve reached is one of the most fascinating things I’ve ever worked on.

Around the same time I started this, pure LLM-based generative games were getting buzz again. AI Dungeon had its explosion years ago, and now there’s a new wave of “AI game” startups. But every time I tried one, it felt loose—too much freedom, no grounding. Choices didn’t matter because nothing persisted underneath. The AI just vibed and generated something that sounded right but meant nothing. Characters forgot their names. The world forgot yesterday.

It felt like a gimmick: impressive tech demo, not a game.

That led to a better question: what would good game design look like if it actually integrated LLMs’ generative strengths with the deterministic, shared experience of a multiplayer world? Not AI doing everything, not AI as a bolted-on coat of paint, but an architecture built around what AI is genuinely good at and what it absolutely cannot do.

That’s how The Unwritten began.

What it is
A text-based MMORPG. Persistent shared world. Permadeath. Dynasty system. A magic system grounded in theoretical physics. A frontier that literally doesn’t exist until players walk into it.

The world exists in three layers:
- Deterministic layer (bottom): The Athenaeum (think Oxford crossed with the Library of Alexandria) and the Seven Cities are hand-crafted and canonical. When I say “meet me at the Forum,” everyone knows exactly where that is. This gives shared reality, weight, and stakes.
- Procedural layer (middle): Consistent, learnable rules and systems. The magic works the same way every time, can be taught, documented on a wiki, and remains fair and predictable.
- Generative layer (top): The frontier. When you step beyond the known world, the AI generates terrain, ruins, creatures, NPCs, and mysteries—all shaped by lore and constrained by procedural rules. Crucially, once discovered, it crystallizes into the permanent world. Every player after you will find that ruin. Your name is etched as the discoverer. Forever.

The unknown becomes the known. That’s the core loop.

The magic system
Reality is woven from the Threads of the Utterance—strings (as in string theory) still vibrating from the Creator’s First Word. Everything differs only in frequency. A stone wall and the air beside it are the same substance singing different songs.

No spell slots, no mana, no cooldowns. Only knowledge—and the cost of being wrong.

Four disciplines, each rooted in real physics/philosophy:
- Sonaecraft (String Theory): Every material has a unique Tone. Transmutation requires walking harmonic bridges through stable intermediate tones (A* pathfinding on a tone graph). Wiki-documentable, tradable knowledge. Cost: Harmonic Contamination—your own Thread drifts toward the studied frequency. Masters become visibly marked: metallic skin, vibrating eyes, echoing voices.
- Attestation (Quantum Mechanics): Before observation, things exist in Fieri (superposition). Practitioners can delay collapse and bias outcomes. More observers = heavier Gravitas (decoherence), so Attestors are stronger alone and weaker in crowds. Cost: Fieri Drift—prolonged superposition blurs identity until you fade into ambient background.
- Codex Arts (Simulation Theory): Reality is information; practitioners read and edit the Codex (source code). Integrity checks make consistent edits cheaper and contradictory ones dangerous. Exploit path: Logic Bombs that trigger localized Excessus (buffer overflows) for impossible writes. Cost: Data Overflow—overexposure causes cognitive fugue; long-term users lose the ability to process normal input.
- Nominatio (Logos Theology): True Names must be earned through personal experience and interaction (LLM-generated unique paths). Comprehension is 0–100% via Insights. At 100%: mutual understanding and co-creation. Effects are consistent and balanced across players. Cost: Name-Sickness—you gradually become the thing you deeply understand.

Dynasty system (permadeath that matters)
Characters can die permanently. At zero health you enter a ~5-minute Dying Light window where others can save you. If not, you’re gone.

Survive long enough (100+ real days), build legacy, and hit thresholds → establish an heir. Heirs inherit 40% tendency (faster skill learning in mastered disciplines). NPCs remember bloodlines. Dynasties stack generational bonuses. One death without an heir ends the line completely.

A Bloodline Registry tracks dynasties, ended lines, and player-written memorials. The emotional weight is real.

World design
Known world: canonical Athenaeum, Seven Cities (each with distinct identity), connecting roads.
Unknown: eight biomes, wilderness up to 50 rooms from landmarks, dungeons 20 levels deep, generated settlements capped at 30 NPCs/15 buildings. Lore explanation: frontier exists in Fieri until observed and collapsed.

NPC system
Two-layer dialogue: canonical core (fixed, documentable) + expressive LLM variation through personality. Trust tracking, knowledge maps, action parsing.

Challenges
Balancing the tone graph, Gravitas edge cases, Codex integrity/exploit design, crystallization quality threshold, and dynasty emotional clarity.

Why it matters
Most AI-in-games answers are weak: full AI (meaningless after an hour) or AI as texture (same game, prettier wallpaper).

The interesting path is architectural: deterministic foundations for trust and stakes, procedural rules for fairness and depth, generative AI for emergence and personalization—each doing what it’s best at.

Discoveries persist. Choices ripple across players. Knowledge is literally power.

We’re still building, but the design space is the most compelling I’ve touched in years.

If you played MUDs back in the day and this resonates, that’s exactly the feeling we’re chasing. Looking for playtesters—comment or DM and I’ll send an invite.

1

2

0

160

Just Tim

@TimMacc

Who to follow

Last Seen Users on Sotwe

Trends for you

Most Popular Users