#FND left me housebound for many years, unable to walk or use my arms. The turning point came when I met Prof Mark Edwards & finally received diagnosis & treatment. It’s still a battle but I am starting to play again. I hope my story shows with the right treatment, there is hope.
No-one hates Functional Neurological Disorder more than the people who have to endure it. Most patients aren’t online arguing ideology. They are trying to survive disabling symptoms, stigma, uncertainty and fractured healthcare whilst being dragged into wider medical battles #FND
When Functional Neurological Disorder is reduced to belief, suggestibility or “faith-like” treatment, this is the reality being erased. I’ve lived it, doubted it, researched it, and spent years listening to thousands living with it. Don’t reduce our lives to your theory. #FND
Since @FndNope has me blocked I’ll respond here. Functional Neurological Disorder is not diagnosed by suggestibility. Hoover’s sign is not a suggestibility test. CBT is not a universal “gold standard”. Accepting an #FND diagnosis is not blind faith. Accuracy matters. 🧵
@KH118118@FndNope The article demonstrates ignorance of the basic principles of computational neuroscience/predictive processing- i.e how beliefs and expectations act as generative models/filters for our perceptual systems- despite this the author sets themselves up as some sort of expert?
@awaisaftab Psychiatry is one of the most ambiguous areas of medicine, because the brain/mental illness is so complex-many unknowns. I think people who struggle to deal with complexity and ambiguity are often drawn to conspiracy thinking because it can provide simple answers
A reminder for anyone who doubts Functional Neurological Disorder: People with #FND live with real symptoms, fear, uncertainty & real impact on their lives. Denying their dx, or using it as a weapon in arguments, only adds to stigma, isolation & harm. They are people, not labels.
@MTurner1996 Thats interesting, I don't have hyperphantasia but I've always thought the fact I have an unusually vivid imagination is a contributing factor to FND - I guess it's the downside of having a brain like this
@jonstoneneuro@carlorovelli Great article- also like his point about the subjectivity of science, everything I've learnt from neuroscience/FND/predictive brain model seems to confirm bias is built into our perceptual systems - so a purely 'objective' experience or explanation of reality is impossible
@purposeful_pd Much of the medical profession still operates like a closed mediaeval guild. Patient perspective is essential, greater doctor/patient collaboration is the logical way forward - but sadly the 'doctor knows best' patriarchal model is still deeply embedded in medical culture
Patients provide the material for observation and then have to pay in order to access that completed scientific observation which is purportedly produced for patient benefit! Just a sample of the disconnect…
@purposeful_pd Much of the medical profession still operates like a closed mediaeval guild. Patient perspective is essential, greater doctor/patient collaboration is the logical way forward - but sadly the 'doctor knows best' patriarchal model is still deeply embedded in medical culture
It’s bad enough a doctor describes throwing water on patients and dismisses seizures as not real, but engaging in a mocking conversation about it is not acceptable. This normalises harm and undermines patient dignity and trust. Patients with #FND deserve better @RCHTWeCare