if you read the nhj essay against the grain, a classic "education reformer" agenda emerges from it, teachers and administrators seem to face no real pressure to produce objective or testable results, the discipline system seems to structurally disadvantage well-behaved kids...
@Tyler_A_Harper It’s good she wrote it but I don’t think it was honest. The premise that these failures are traceable to actual underfunding is false. And NHJ consistently veers away from facing up to the role of the teachers’ unions’ in the multigenerational failures she describes.
@ahscarymunsters@dilanesper@EWess92 1. Which Chetty articles do you recommend?
2. Is there any evidence that Mississippi achieved its massive turnaround in low income/black student achievement by changing “segregation”?
@dilanesper@EWess92 Right. And, as one would expect, NHJ resolves the cognitive dissonance by … blaming “segregation,” racism, and (in the highest spending large school district in the US, and, I suspect, the world) underfunding.
@Tyler_A_Harper YMMV, but while both are bad, I think the Woke Racists have done far more damage over the last generation or two. The equity-speak racism, the public money and trust wasted on posturing ed-school fads, the opportunity costs imposed on so many kids … it’s just so dispiriting.
@anOrdoLiberal@cafreiman Any minimum amount to affected estates? Any maximum amounts kids can withdraw for first house or “marriage” (which I assume means more than a kick ass reception)?
@anOrdoLiberal@cafreiman If the argument is that people who didn’t personally create the wealth at issue are likely to put it to unproductive ends, would you have the same concern about handing that wealth over to govt bureaucrats who are even more disconnected from the wealth creation than heirs.
@rwlesq@dilanesper How might that play out in your view? This specific issue here is women’s prison. So putting aside inmate X’s ontological identity, but knowing that X went through male puberty, which prison should house inmate X and why?
@dilanesper As folks are pointing out, TWAW is false. More than that, the life of the law is experience, not logic, and experience shows that TWAW isn’t workable as a basis for government policies.