@SauceCastillo38@burgessev The Bill has nearly 80 votes. If he was "right" it would be a lot closer and they would need a compromise.
He's doing nothing but talking.
@missionto6rings@Genetics56 Every league in the world has roster rules. Why is NCAA sports different?
Do you also believe players can transfer mid season, at halftime, what limits do you find reasonable.
@defundhighered@ClayTravis@SenateCommerce You don't think it is complicated that a group of non employees are generating billions of dollars and making them employees would trigger conflicting state employment laws?
There is literally no example in recorded history to point to that fits this. Hence the term novel.
@AaronGogley@samcehrlich Yes. It is part of this overarching issue in this media space where bad legal theory by the NCAA is constantly called out but the same standard is no applied to judges in cases like this.
@defundhighered@ClayTravis@SenateCommerce But it doesn't function as that.
If it did this would be easy.
We have a novel system for which there is no comparison in the entire world, possibly the Universe
NEW: Ex-Emory star men's basketball player Ben Pearce has been granted a preliminary injunction by a New York state court, allowing last year's Division III men's basketball player of the year to play Division I basketball in 2026-27.
@defundhighered@ClayTravis@SenateCommerce But you are surely aware there is a myriad of laws that makes that difficult as well?
I want to cure homelessness by building a base on the moon.
But at some point we both have to enter reality, right?
@Its_Coach_Steve I think anyone working in sports and not just self titling themselves "coach" understands that the pressure surrounding "voluntary" workouts makes athletes have to choose
@missionto6rings@Genetics56 But why use the Clown emoji is this a topic that needs revisited?
The anti super league stuff in the bill is INSANELY popular. Could there be some changes to it, sure. But if the B10 and SEC wanted those teams right now this provision wouldn't be in the bill
People being mad at Government in action.
Is this a bad bill?- Probably
Do people overwhelmingly support enforceable rules in college sports-Yes
Did Lawyers and Judges prostitute the legal system to get us to this point-Yes
For years no one had any issues with the system while Judges made random rules, but now that the NCAA actually has Congress involved we all want to 2 sides it now?
I am ok with a limit but not 19. I was concerned and had a gut feeling many weeks ago that if it made it to the Senate floor they had the votes. Now it's nearing 80, which is stunning. So I am willing to accept reality even though I don't personally agree with the bill.
@JUCOadvocate It makes my brain hurt that people say making 50K for Bayern Munich at age 19 is drastically different than making 100K at Louisville at age 19
@_FCS_BASKETBALL Iโd rather see a narrow employee exemption via Congress rather than an anti trust exemption.
These things can work.
Just takes effort and consistent goals