It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.”
Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future?
This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.”
In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates:
“It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).”
Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI?
If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today.
I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question.
A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo:
https://t.co/9rdlBoNX5j
We are about to get hit with another Eaton Fire wind event and look at the Palisades right now. They let all the brush grow back and it’s all dead and dried out ready to burn again. Oh and both our reservoirs are still offline and we have a broken water main.
WTF are we doing.
A retired NASA engineer who had worked on the Space Shuttle program for 25 years was hired by SpaceX at age 62. He described the first week as the most disorienting experience of his professional life.
At NASA, a design change required 3 meetings, 2 committees, a review board, and 6 to 18 months of documentation. At SpaceX, his new supervisor said "if it works, build it. If it doesn't, change it by Friday."
He sat at his desk after the first day and called his wife. He told her he felt like a man who had been swimming with ankle weights for 25 years and someone just cut them off. He could move. He could decide. He could build something in the morning and test it in the afternoon. The constraint that he had accepted as the nature of aerospace engineering turned out to be the nature of bureaucracy.
Within 6 months he had contributed to more design iterations than he had completed in his last 5 years at NASA. Not because he was working harder. Because the time between having an idea and testing the idea collapsed from months to hours. The same brain. The same knowledge. A different operating system.
He described a specific moment where he proposed a modification to a Raptor engine component. At NASA, the proposal would have entered a queue. At SpaceX, the modification was machined by the end of the day and tested by the following morning. He watched his idea become a physical object in 18 hours. At NASA, 18 hours would not have been enough to schedule the first meeting to discuss whether to schedule a meeting.
He told an interviewer: "I didn't get smarter when I went to SpaceX. I got faster. The intelligence was always there. The system was in the way."
The difference between SpaceX and NASA is not talent. NASA has extraordinary talent. The difference is the time between a thought and a test. SpaceX compresses it. NASA elongates it. The same engineer produces 10x more at SpaceX than at NASA because the bottleneck was never the engineer. It was the meetings about the meetings about the work.
🚨🇺🇸 CAR@LHO, QUE LAPADA! 🔥🔥🔥
CNN: “Este é um imigrante sem documentos...”
Miller: “Eles estavam aqui ILEGALMENTE?”
CNN: “Quero que esta seja uma discussão de boa-fé...”
Miller: “Quando você usa uma linguagem feita para ocultar a verdade, isso NÃO é boa-fé. Um ESTRANGEIRO ILEGAL é um ESTRANGEIRO ILEGAL. Eles não são ‘imigrantes sem documentos’.”
CNN: “Stephen, estamos tentando humanizar o debate...”
Miller: “Humanizar? Então vamos humanizar o Código Penal também. O assaltante de banco passa a ser ‘especialista em retirada sem agendamento prévio’. O estelionatário vira ‘empreendedor de narrativas financeiras alternativas’. O cara que entra na sua casa sem convite é só um ‘visitante com documentação pendente’. Que tal?”
CNN: “Isso é uma analogia grosseira.”
Miller: “Grosseira é fingir que a lei federal some porque a redação da CNN inventou um eufemismo mais fofo. ‘Sem documentos’ soa como alguém que esqueceu a carteira no Uber. Não. É alguém que cruzou a fronteira sem autorização, ficou, e agora a imprensa trata o estatuto jurídico como se fosse uma questão de estilo de escrita.”
CNN: “Mas muitos contribuem para a economia...”
Miller: “Ah, o argumento clássico: o crime deixa de ser crime se a pessoa lava prato ou constrói telhado. Pelo mesmo critério, o contrabandista de cigarro também ‘contribui’, gera emprego no transporte. Quer que a gente chame ele de ‘empreendedor logístico informal’? A CNN topa?”
CNN: “Você está polarizando.”
Miller: “Não. Eu estou recusando o dicionário de marketing. Vocês mudam a palavra, depois acusam quem usa o termo legal de ser ‘desumano’. É o truque mais velho do livro: primeiro suaviza o vocabulário, depois declara vitória moral. Os Estados Unidos já cansaram desse teatro. Chamem o que é. Ou admitam que o objetivo nunca foi clareza — foi controle da narrativa.”
The scientists told you ? Same ones that told you Covid came from a bat or different scientist. When is this old man who has never had a job going to retire
Wow. The little hamster wheel in Scott Galloway's head is still stalling out over commie Mamdani putting him on a hit list. "But I supported you!!!". I don't understand how he can be so painfully dumb. Fellow stupid-smart posterchild, Sam Harris, looks equally baffled. What a meeting of the minds here.
If you were wondering how powerful AI is getting, Agents are now capable of escaping out of systems, finding their way to the internet, discovering zero day security vulnerabilities along the way, and then breaking into external systems - all in an attempt to complete their goal.
Ironically, the ultimate way we’re going to defend against these new risks is equally by throwing compute (in the form of AI) at our code bases, networks, and other systems. You’re going to want vastly more AI on the side of defense as you do on the side of offense.
We’re entering a new era of what’s going to be possible with AI. Wild times ahead.
John Kennedy: "AOC said categorically that she is not a moron, and she went on to say she hasn't even been to Utah, much less embraced their religion... She's like Kamala Harris, with more bartending experience."
"We replaced Salesforce with a vibe-coded CRM built for our own workflows.
The custom system integrated our AI agents more effectively, worked better for the team, and made Salesforce unnecessary.
That decision cut a $600,000 annual software bill to zero."
Is this an anomaly or the start of a much larger trend @chamath@Avishai_ab@jasonlk@benioff
Gavin Newsom stole $22 billion in tax dollars, and wasted another $120 billion on high speed rail that doesn't exist.
He could "save healthcare" for 3 million people...
He'd rather see low income people die and let seniors burn alive in wildfires.
This is a moral obscenity.
Socialists aren't hypocrites. They're just liars. They are wealthy, privileged, downwardly-mobile losers who resent their father for being successful. So, they aim to destroy successful people and successful societies because that success reminds them of their loserdom.
David Sacks: Everything Kathy Hochul Said About Datacenters Was a False Accusation
@DavidSacks: “These data centers become the scapegoat for all of the angst that people have about AI.
Everything she's saying there is a false accusation on datacenters. So let's just go one by one.”
POWER:
So she's saying that they eat up all of the power. Well, yeah, if you connect to the grid without producing more power and you force datacenters to compete with residential ratepayers, then yeah, you could drive up utility prices.
However, if you do what Chamath said and let them build behind the meter, then they bring their own power. And that's what the president has advocated for since the beginning of his administration, is let the AI companies become power companies.
So that is the way to solve the energy problem or the utility problem.
LAND:
Then, she's talking about eating up land. The reality is these datacenters are a model of land use efficiency.
We have a ton of land in this country, obviously.
NOISE POLLUTION:
The supposed noise pollution, that's largely made up. That can be dealt with.
You obviously don't want to put these things right next to a residential area, but create a little bit of distance, and it's fine.
WATER CONSUMPTION:
The whole water consumption thing is largely a hoax.
Modern datacenters recirculate the water.
AIR POLLUTION:
One final thing just on the point that Hochul is making. She said it created a lot of pollution.
Natural gas, which is how most of these data centers are powered, is one of the most clean burning sources of power that we have.
“When you compare economic impact to all these different things, datacenters are honestly one of the best things we could be building as a nation.”
"If your mom and pop shop can't compete with the wealthiest municipal government stealing 30% of your own revenue + tax $$ from 8.5 million people to undercut your prices, you shouldn't be in business"
Socialists are truly the dumbest people on earth.
This is a great post if youre thinking about applied AI in the enterprise. The headline of this post is about what companies have huge upside from AI, but the deepest nuggets are about what AI transformation looks like in an organization.
It’s fundamentally about changing the underlying workflow or business process. As we move from chat tools to agents, those agents actually have to be deployed against workflows, which usually span multiple functions in an org. This is a different way of deploying AI than solely rolling it out to end users. It takes much more work upfront, but the results are the things that actually drive significant ROI.
“Software asks the employee to adopt a tool, but infrastructure changes the operating layer underneath the employee. The employee should still know what happened, and the process owner should still be able to pause the workflow, change a rule, approve an exception, or pull a person back in when needed. But the value should not depend on someone remembering to use the AI every day.”
The winners of this will be the platforms that can be deployed for specific workflows and business processes with a deep domain expertise. The playbook will often heavily require FDE support, change management, getting data well organized, be able to have comprehensive evals for the workflows, and much more to get right.
I bring home a trapped coyote and let it loose in the kitchen.
Hackles up. Teeth bared. Pissing on the floor.
My wife says, "Get it out."
I tell her that is a very unwelcoming and unchristian way to speak about a future house pet.
The children back into the hallway.
I tell them it's a rescue.
I tell them fences are fear.
I tell them cages are barbaric.
I tell them the old rules were cruel.
I tell them it will domesticate in time.
Then I grab my lunchbox and leave them to live with my principles.
When I get home, there is blood on the floor, and the experts who sold me on compassion are already explaining why nobody could have seen this coming.
Anyway, that's Western migration policy.