Loved this from @Jonathan_Blow on his recent appearance on The Students:
"AIs don't seem to actually reason well enough...
We released a game a month ago, right? So I was doing a lot of exercises of the form, 'Hey, we're going to launch this game. Here's the information about it pre-launch. What do you think the sales are going to be?'
...It'll just say all these things, but then I would be like, 'Okay, cool. But, you know, I feel like according to this one reason that you didn't mention, the sales should be higher.' And it says, 'Oh, you know what? You're right. Actually, the sales should be higher.'"
Personally (speaking as Lane now) I've had pretty good success using AI to pull in sources when I'm doing analysis. It's great at scraping, running SQL queries, etc. But the actual ANALYSIS is sooo unbelievably useless, because every follow up question you ask is clearly just steering it to agree with you. When you're doing analysis, you want the truth. Not something that makes you feel good. That's the whole point of having experts around.
The same is true of software development. If you don't know what you're doing, and you simply ask "is it secure? Is it performant?", with no way to verify on your own, you're in for a bad time.
@cpasDryNa Now, AI is also CREATING problems and complaints for engineers, but they're almost all entirely removed from the complaints made by artists.
@cpasDryNa Mechanically, it's identical. The difference is mindset and culture.
Engineers are not nearly as concerned with the concepts of artistic expression as an artist would be.
They are problem solvers, first and foremost, and AI is helping to solve problems.
@max_spero_ How many said something to the effect of "My favorite snack is blah blah blah...
...ok but I can't leave that other question hanging because I studied ML and I'm real interested and my favorite is etcetcetc"
@BrodieOnLinux I let myself get sucked into this discussion hole and wish I hadn't. The amount of people who have no idea what they're talking about but are anti-AI because of IP issues in the domain of art while not considering the domain of software/code is making my blood pressure go up.
There's this funny cope thing I've seen from people who desperately want to be anti-AI but still have some attachment to reality where there say generative AI is bad, but other AI is not.
I don't want to be the one to break the illusion but using AI to automate mundane tasks or find software bug and using it to generate art are under the same technological banner.
You can absolutely have preferences for different use cases, but when I see someone using the term blanket term gen-AI it immediately flags what they're about to say following that.
Honestly beautiful to see someone give such a misguided take then admit they were wrong and learn from it.
I have this convo with my mom all the time, who is OBSESSED with ChatGPT for her day job for boomer reasons.
AI used as a tool and AI used to generate creative assets are two very different conversations. I can feel gross finding out someone used AI to make art that they claimed as their own but also hear that AI is helping cure cancer with RNA Processing and go 'oh fuck yeah'.
Context ALWAYS matters, ALWAYS. You can try to apply the like 'all AI is gross' rule to every circumstance to feel good about yourself, but everything is always shades of grey.
The usage of AI to assist in writing has other issues not related to the notions of IP.
But the "AI is bad universally" argument almost always comes from either artists who think the problems of AI in the art domain are universal to all domains (it isn't), or environmentalists who think all AI is datacenters using diesel generators and sucking up lakes (they aren't).
@hassundotX@_GAi92 I make no statements about AI in the domain of art, only in code.
> Which part of those licenses explicitly cover AI training?
The "without restriction" part. https://t.co/VG6MTSI1FW
@_GAi92@RazzberryYams I will agree with you that the argument that some people are making that "Code Isn't GenAI" is mind boggling.
The argument should be "Code isn't like art, the coders see GenAI being able to write code as a tool, not as competition." But we do have our own struggles with it too.
This, plus a lot of the people who are afraid of putting out game demos were putting out vertical slices of one or two mechanics. The kind of things that even pre-AI a mildly experienced Roblox dev could re-create in a weekend.
Now claude gives the entire world the capability of a mildly experienced Roblox dev.
To make a comparion for art. Incredibly often, a software project will not only distribute the final .png (compiled binary, or ".exe" if you're in Windows), software will also upload the .psd file (source code), AND the entire history of every line that was drawn along with why (the git repo).
Open source software is often made with the explicit purpose to be "stolen" with only the most bare essentials of IP. https://t.co/EGgRwLNSHW
> If you think AI Art is theft, then you must also accept that AI Coding is also theft, as it "stole" from all the code it was trained on.
This would be true, but people who write code VERY often write with open permissive licenses like GPL, MIT, Apache, etc.
You can say "stolen" but the coders are very often writing that code with the intent of other people using it and even "stealing" it. That's been the nature of open source software functionally forever.