@Leafar_P1@FournesMaxime@PauseAI The comments are certainly a cesspool. A very few thoughtful critics, but most are snipes from folk who didn't actually read anything. That's protests X twitter for you I guess.
@ShawheenAzizi@FournesMaxime@PauseAI No. I'm a member who more than ten thousand hours reading, researching and writing AI.
Find a different reason not to think about AI killing everybody.
@TomasMann1878@FournesMaxime@PauseAI I was too. Quit the job to spread the word.
The website isn't a terrible way in. The book "If Anyone Builds It Everyone Dies" is nerdier than MIRI want it to be, but that won't intimidate you.
@sandwichpartys@FournesMaxime@PauseAI It is cathartic, energising, good for networking; but mostly for awareness. We would like the public to know
* superintelligence quite likely kills us
* it is normal to be upset about that
I wish I was bored. I quit my AI research and dev job to put thought into activism.
@_georgebaran@FournesMaxime@PauseAI Not the plan. Authority is a widely acknowledged concern. Read actual writing.
The way we currently build AI no human robustly decides how the technology works or what it does. We squint & nudge. Won't work for superintelligence.
> what could possibly go wrong
Everybody dies.
@NgaQ15@FournesMaxime@PauseAI Ironically, it's the people who favour racing who have normalcy bias and think the status is quo.
(Or their bots.)
AI is not normal technology.
@stabiltstabil@FournesMaxime@PauseAI We are not stupid. Many members use contemporary AI for research, coding and brainstorming.
We are worried about future superintelligence that kills everyone.
(Mileage may vary.)
@Mercurion5d@FournesMaxime@PauseAI The movement is dense with AI nerds. (If anything, too dense. We used to put footnotes on banners.)
That reason to ignore fails, alas.
@_Mark_Fox__@PauseAI This is the UK voice in a global chorus. We want enforceable international agreements to ban superintelligence. Just acting locally here.
The thing we want to avoid is *every human in the world* dying. You, your friends and family, your nation, everybody.
@rsorourke@MichaelTrazzi@JosephMiller_ Sure. Marches are good for networking and feels inside the movement and for awareness / media outside.
The thing is, lots of the decision makers also *don't want to die*.
Public backing gives them courage to act in unusual ways.
@Mercurion5d@PauseAI_UK I think this failure was partly implementation? The planned exit via nuclear didn't work and then Russian gas dependence hurt.
The renewables subsidies did cut all costs. China is now the largest solar deployer. (And supplier, alas for DE.)
</tangent>
Debate on coordination?
@Mercurion5d@PauseAI_UK I should comment on the particular example you raised of German carbon.
You gave a tragedy of commons flavor argument.
Unilateral restraint, diffuse benefit, free-riders win - true.
As above, that's not what we are endorsing but I'll scratch a bit anyway...
@ThinkBertram@PauseAI_UK Reductive and wrong.
I'll happily take life extension assisted by AI research.
But you don't get that if superintelligence kills everybody. And the odds of that in the near future are higher!
Btw https://t.co/1kZ25B157H -
"How AI Can, and Can't, Cure Cancer" - is interesting.
@CharTNChang@PauseAI_UK That's quite hard to chant!
It fits well with what the movement actually "demands": enforceable international agreements to not race towards superintelligence while there is some likelihood it has terrible consequences including killing everybody.