My favorite kind of competitions are about to start up. The "just bring your skills" kind.
It's the ones where, as a competitor, you have the fewest reasons to blame for poor performance.
Quake, UT, FGC.
Arenas $10,000 Cash Cups inbound! First $1,000 "Winner Stays" 1v1 Power Rankings competitions taking place in Brazil.
https://t.co/hWWzJ78N8G
One additional point that's important is the top percentile also act as a catalyst for higher quit rates, match abandonment, and lower general fun metric scoring for those lower skilled players as they run through them in lobbies.
They typically cause matches to end faster and can effectively ~1.1x -1.2x rate of matches (i.e. they win fast) so they're even more disruptive than whats indicated here.
Good post 👍🏾
There is this broad misconception that "open matchmaking" (complete removal of SBMM) would be OK because "good players are rare" and "lower skill players will likely end up in a lobby of other lower skill players."
But what happens when we actually run the math?
Let's look at it from the perspective of a lower 50% skill player in a pool of 100,000. Remember we are simply talking raw percentages. The top 10% of players would be the raw mathematical count of 10,000 players (for example).
Parameters:
100,000 matchmaking pool
2 Teams
5v5 Match
Let's pretend some lowly casual filth in the bottom 50% presses the matchmake button (no SBMM):
Probability there are ZERO Top 10% players in the other 9 slots?
.90 to the 9th power, or rather...
= 0.3874
about 39%
Put another way, there will be at least one top 10% player in 61% of the this low-skill player's matches.
Now, Let's just look at the raw statistics of a randomly generated lobby, and how often high skilled, and extremely high skill players would be selected. (Remove the one slot being filled by some low skill "casual"):
Top 10% - 65.1%
Top 5% - 40.1%
Top 1% - 9.6%
Top 0.1% - 1.0%
What's the conclusion here?
A randomly selected player will encounter a top-10% player frequently, but they will encounter a top-1% player relatively rarely.
HOWEVER, perception is critical. Your typical mid-level and lower skill player cannot distinguish, and does not care, if they are being railroaded by a top 10% player or a top 1% player. The distinction is meaningless.
This is just the basics, assuming a pool of 100,000 players that have some skill based MMR attached to them. But, as you can see in the math, most lobbies would contain at least one top 10% player, and it doesn't fall that far when we start talking top 5%.
And remember, the distinction between being exploded by a top 10% player versus a top 1% player is basically meaningless.
This is why most matchmaking systems run at least some form of SBMM (even if relatively loose). Even loose skill matchmaking is better than nothing at all.
We are able to pull certain combat rooms if we (or more specifically the community) feel like it's not competitively viable as well. So callouts like this are great.
The combat room you're talking about should weight toward the middle (which the algo is supposed to do), but you'd still have to travel on the exterior hall all the way around, which effectively is the same situation you're pointing out.
Likely need to pull that room.
@vollmaskiert@FNCompetitive Wait, is that drawing of the combat room that you're talking about, if so I think I know which one that is?
Will talk with one of our engineers about it specifically.
You mind calling out a few specific Combat Rooms? It's technically possible given the algo, but when we were testing with some Pro players before implementation, they called out the same thing so we did even more adjustments.
If you have videos (and names of Combat Rooms), it helps tremendously!
@ApoStructura Join the club! It's a campaign of hate and intimidation, not aimed at convincing anyone of the merits of their position, but to bully and scare advocates into silence. They're spamming spammed with 1000's of "why doesn't someone kill this guy" memes.
We've not changed it. And there are currently no plans as far as I'm aware to change or revert them and like you called out, it's been years at this point.
It doesn't mean we can't or won't, but I have what I work on spefically in my bio for a reason. Animations are not my forte.
My memory is long on how hostile Twitter is about the topic. That won't change
My point which is exactly how this conversation is already going is:
1) I have nothing to do with our animations.
2) As far as I've seen it's been a conversation that has way too much hostility and animosity over anims.
3) It was a topic that hit Doxxing and death threats. No I'm not entertaining it. It's not a topic for me.
@UGAGrad99@jynxzi Jynxzi is great, but it's just a coincidence he mentioned it and we released it shortly thereafter. We've been rolling out ranked changes the entire year.
This is a big change for Ranked. This addresses a number of frequent community issues, most notably are those that screenshot "Unreal in my Bronze, Silver, Gold lobby."
This comes with a tradeoff. Longer queue times. So you'll see an increase in screenshots of players that experience longer queue times. This is in an effort to take the extra time needed to find you quality matches in your rank tier.
What this means long-term (likely coming sooner rather than later) is that we have to go through and consolidate playlists that have always had too few players in the queue in Ranked.
@UGAGrad99@jynxzi 18,000+ lines of code. We've been planning the change for a long time. We also needed the server routing changes before we made a change.