@F_Sid_Dougan@SteveStuWill The problem with the study @SteveStuWill posted is that it only shows that elite schools don’t help their worst admit, the PGI level in your book is likely higher
@KathleenCoreyMD@jflier@NEJM Her feelings are valid, her opinion is low quality and her defense of Arday egregiously misleading. Any competent editor following events could spot this. The editor failed here.
@KathleenCoreyMD@jflier@NEJM Journals have finite space. It is possible to exercise poor judgement when deciding what to publish. It is ok label a decision to publish as poor judgement.
@Tyler_A_Harper For those of us teaching at scale (with many international students), we all understand that tuition funds having high quality researchers, and high quality research fuels rankings. If we failed the 45% that deserve it, we’d need to cut the faculty in half too. We’re stuck.