California DMV Pulls Waymo From Freeways. When Should They Do That?
Robocars will make dangerous mistakes, and will do so forever. So how do we decide when they should be pulled from the roads?
https://t.co/BQLtU0yMIA
@MKBHD But ask them the big question -- is it remotely supervised by a safety monitor behind a screen? So far they haven't said. Every company starts that way, the rest have all ceased. Has Tesla?
@mark_prati@TaiigerBlue@SawyerMerritt Correct. You supervise because you feel they are not yet safe enough without it. Same for cars. With cars it's more--your goal is to gather data on the safety. You only stop supervising after you have proven with data that you didn't need to.
@mark_prati@TaiigerBlue@SawyerMerritt No regulations here. The key milestone has always been, does the vehicle need a human to do its job safely. The human/parent doesn't do the task, but it is decided they are still needed, full time, to intervene rarely. Until, one day, they are not.
@OverlyTrev I saw you CN. It was false. The story in question explicitly says in multiple locations that it is not talking about remote driving or remote assist, and you knew that. You submit a CN about Tesla's testimony on remote driving. Extremely dishonest and I'm not sure why.
@chadhegerty@SlkArt Yes, obviously Musk has not stated this. Neither did most of the other companies, that all did it -- until after the fact, when they admitted it. The article explains the difference between the remote assist support team, a completely different thing from remote monitors
@mark_prati@TaiigerBlue@SawyerMerritt A great example. A vehicle or a child need supervision if you feel they are not sufficiently safe in everyday activity without it. Eventually they graduate to a higher level of ability where you do not deem such supervision necessary
@TeslaFB13@OverlyTrev Obviously not everybody interpreted his speech the same way. Unquestionably it's just a fact that a certain audience associated it with Naziiism. This is true even if they were wrong. I have written they were wrong, that it wasn't what they thought it was. They still think it
@chadhegerty@SlkArt I have said that because something is industry standard practice, because it is the only sane thing to do, that everybody does and then stops, that tesla is very probably like everybody else and trying to be safe, because Musk has said that.
@Bearbones24@SawyerMerritt Right. Though not the same monitor. You can switch in and out, take breaks as needed. Just count miles moving. That tells you how many monitors needed
@Bearbones24@SawyerMerritt Uber does pay drivers for that off time with flag drop and other ways. They have to. Supervision is only while moving, just a salary.
@CyberGwon@ryanwang@SawyerMerritt My milestone list in 2021. Tesla didn't follow this but pretty close. https://t.co/xuEwMt7P9t A shorter articulation in 2025: https://t.co/xuEwMt7P9t - No goalposts moved. Please retract.
@CyberGwon@ryanwang@SawyerMerritt Show me where, for the past 15 years, my goal post has been anything but a vehicle safer than human, in a viable service area, door to door, without needing constant human attention? I may have refined it but I never moved it. It's the right goalpost.