Rep Khana @RoKhanna , I am a Spine Surgeon & read the Yale study. All 40 pages. Here's what the "$1 trillion in savings" actually is.
$378 billion comes from cutting drug prices 51%. You could pass that tomorrow without touching anyone's insurance. It has nothing to do with Medicare for All.
$296 billion comes from paying every hospital and doctor in America Medicare rates. That's not a saving. That's a pay cut, to the one line that's already down 33% since 2001. The model counts it as efficiency.
$286 billion is an assumed 8% cut in "fraud." Medicare's own improper payments last year: $57 billion. The government's program doesn't achieve what the model assumes a bigger version of it will.
That's $960 billion of the trillion. The rest is admin savings, which are real, and ER visits, which are modeled.
Now what the study leaves out, in the authors' own words: "provider responses to Medicare rates are not modeled." No doctors leaving. No wait times. No supply constraint. A "static, single-year accounting." They say so on the page.
And the 114,000 lives? 51,000 of them, 45% of the headline, come from reversing last year's subsidy and Medicaid cuts. Not from your bill.
Restore the subsidies and you'd get those without a single-payer system. Of what's left, half is based on a mortality number the authors say they couldn't find and had to interpolate.
It's a preprint. Not peer-reviewed. It says so at the top.
As a surgeon, I don't doubt the Yale team's intent. But a model that cuts the doctor's pay, assumes the doctor stays, assumes the patient shows up, and assumes the fraud disappears isn't evidence. It's a spreadsheet with the hard parts turned off.
Medicare already pays physicians 33% less than it did in 2001. Private practice fell from 680% of doctors to 18% on that rate. Your plan makes it the only rate. The trillion dollars is real. It's coming out of the people who treat you.
@Alison_Galvani #medicareforall
@BuzzPatterson Exactly, why???? We have security levels at military reservations, security training in Marsec Levels (plans) for maritime. Why would we allow a lack of security and unknown to rub elbows with us?
Its like taking a sudsy bath with candles with your socks on.
@uscfan981 Better, no. Both great in their perspectives. Montana is my pick as
"best," if I had to pick. Unusual to have two great QBs on one team. SF was blessed.
@ChaseOrgeron That's it, we knew this two games prior. Believe me, Leavitt will be gone. Two years needed to develop talent into a proven system. Have faith TigerNation.