If you believe it is wrong to sell prayer, but permissible to sell biblical instruction—words taught by the Spirit (1 Cor. 2:12–13)—what distinguishes the two?
@ElijahMarkT Of course, it also comes off that way because of the spotlights, big-eva conference-circuits, book deals, etc…so I don’t fault anyone for arriving at that judgment. (I’m just saying it shouldn’t be automatic by virtue of the fact that some copying happened.)
@ElijahMarkT But it primarily comes off that way because of cultural expectations. If we dug through writings of past centuries we would find countless examples of such copying from men we respect. They did this shamelessly—that is literally; they had no shame or reason for it.
To require citations outside of academic submissions moves attribution out of the realm of pathos into ethos and blunts the power of speech. I don’t think we realized how much the modern man is crippled by these things.
“He presented it as his own.” Except he didn’t. Anyone who assumes that based on vocalized first person deliberations or a lack of citation makes unwarranted assumptions.
“Anyone is at liberty to use material from this book with or without credit. In preparing this book the author has received help from many sources, some acknowledged and many unacknowledged. He believes the material herein set forth to be a true statement of Scripture teaching, and his desire is to further, not to restrict, its use.”
This notice (with small variants) appears in the works of Lorraine Boetner, Ernest C. Reisinger and others.
@burton1_jack I’m not saying he’s innocent of plagiarism by typical standards. I’m saying that plagiarism (where there is no explicit claim to originality) is not inherently lying or wrong.
It was evident what direction he was going (admission) a day or so ago when he pulled his videos.
@JakeHollister7 Feel free to provide evidence. As far as I know there wasn’t a time where he said “these are all my own original thoughts and I’m not getting them from other sources.” Perhaps for his academic submissions he pledged something like that, but I’m addressing the YT videos.
@JohnStuartWilso 1. If there is no explicit claim to originality, is it lying?
2. Sure, but this is a bit assumed, right?
3,4. Only if you think more *ought* to have been done, which is what I’m questioning
@AlexHam1111@Ausbloke93 Not really. I don’t believe anyone—pagans included—should have to be subject to plagiarism standards outside of academic institutions.