Granted, I likely misspoke and poorly represented Davies arguments. He does challenge the idea that physical laws should be accepted as unexplained facts, but he searches for the explanations in nature while the God hypothesis would go further. He has been relatively friendly to the God hypothesis in various debates, and I don’t think I articulated very well just where that support ended.
However, the idea that Gods existence was contingent on pre-existent laws that allowed him to exist does not hold. You assume that all things requires a physical mechanism, but that’s what’s being disputed: God never came to be, He always was. There is no presupposing physical laws when discussing the source of all things physical or otherwise itself.
Matter is governed by physical laws, if there were to be a creator God then that God would naturally have to exist outside the restrictions within the physical laws that he set up. You don’t run into the same problem at all. That’s not a novel idea either, you’re just uninformed regarded these debates.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit Then I’ll give you an example, Paul Davies recognizes the serious philosophical issues in any God-less attempt to describe why physical laws exist. He’s just one, but you say I have no evidence. You’re simply uniformed on the topic you pretend to know about.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit I didn’t say it was a leading scientific theory. The origin of matter itself is not explained by those theories, hence why even atheist scientists will suggest the God hypothesis is most coherent. That doesn’t mean they believe it.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit I’m not talking about standard non-believers, I’m talking about scientists who actually want to ask those questions. It sounds like one of us is indeed in an echo chamber, but it’s not me.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit I agree that me disagreeing doesn’t mean I’m objectively right. I am objectively right because that’s what the criteria says, not because I disagree with what you say.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit None of those things are hard evidence. There is much debate on the topic, and even non-believers will offer that the existence of a God is the most coherent argument for the existence of the world.
@n0tHiNg_8urGer@keem488444@Lazurosspit There’s actually DSM-5 criteria for these symptoms, and believing in an all-powerful being isn’t one of them. If there were objective hard truths to suggest that he was indeed imaginary, then perhaps that would change the equation.
@geofflawnmower@keem488444@Lazurosspit I would argue the opposite. Christianity offers a worldview in which the meaning of such concepts can be objectively rooted in scripture, rather than subjectively placing meaning on them based on the current thoughts and feelings.
@keem488444@Lazurosspit That’s an over simplification. Psychosis is a medical phenomenon that has specific diagnostic criteria. Someone believing in God, or being generally religious, would not qualify because those behaviours are normal human behaviour as evidenced by all of history.
@keem488444@Lazurosspit Quite frankly it doesn’t matter if it’s psychosis to you. It’s definitionally not psychosis. If you just use words because you feel like it and not because you know what they mean, then words will just lose meaning.
@keem488444@Lazurosspit I’m just challenging your definition of religious psychosis. You can’t just call it a psychosis because you disagree, psychosis has an objective definition and following a religion is not part of it.