A contrarian view on the impact of AI on jobs:
AI will drive the largest increase in productivity per worker the world has ever seen. And basic economics says that if the marginal productivity of a worker goes up, you'll want to hire more workers, and pay them more, to capture new and existing profit pools.
The common argument, that AI will do our jobs and leave fewer of them, implies we're living at the end of time, with no more problems left to be solved. But there will always be new problems, and companies are problem-solving machines. As long as traits like judgment, trust, empathy, creativity, and accountability matter, much of that new work will need people.
The economic pie is not finite, and every stage of progress has created more jobs to leverage it. In fact, I suspect we'll see an explosion in business formation, given it's never been a better time in the history of the world to be an entrepreneur.
History is a good guide here. Cars put most carriage makers, stable hands, and horseshoers out of work. But hundreds of companies entered the auto business in a single decade, followed by dealers, gas stations, repair shops, parts suppliers, and motels, each creating jobs that hadn't existed before. More recently, the internet upended bookstores, video and video game stores, and Yellow Pages publishers, among others. But it also collapsed the cost of starting a company. Solo and small online businesses proliferated, along with jobs like web developer and social media manager that didn't exist 30 years ago.
Existing jobs can grow, too. When ATMs emerged in the 1970s, bank tellers looked doomed. Instead, ATMs cut the cost of running a branch, banks opened far more of them, and teller jobs roughly doubled. Mobile banking has since shrunk teller roles, but total bank employment has held steady. The work changed.
In the 1960s, journalists wrote about the demise of the workforce because of the mainframe computer. Instead, it drove productivity and became a tool to leverage human potential. Later, spreadsheets automated bookkeeping, but analysis became so cheap that companies wanted far more of it, and accountant and analyst jobs grew.
It's natural to fall into "this time is different" thinking, and maybe this time will be. But history suggests otherwise.
So, what are the risks? The honest answer requires humility, because the future is uncertain.
The biggest risk to my argument is that AI is fundamentally different. Past technologies mostly replaced muscle and routine tasks, and people moved up to work that required thinking. AI goes after thinking itself. If it can do most cognitive work, the old pattern may not hold. I don't think we're there, and the human side of work is harder to automate than knowledge, but it's the argument I take most seriously.
Another risk is that productivity gains don't automatically flow to workers. Labor's share of US business output hit a record low of ~53% this year, vs. ~63% for most of the postwar era. More of the gains have gone to those who own stuff vs. those who do stuff. But a smaller slice of a much bigger pie can still leave workers better off, especially if they own some of the stuff too.
We'll also need a bridge to the jobs of tomorrow. Jobs with a right or wrong answer will likely get replaced, and jobs that require judgment will be augmented. We've done this before: in 1900, ~40% of US workers were in agriculture. Today it's ~2%, and that shift helped build the modern middle class.
I've always found it interesting that the bear case usually sounds smarter than the bull case. Part of it is that the bear can point to specific jobs that will be lost, while the bull has to point to jobs that don't exist yet. Losses are easy to see. Gains that haven't been invented are hard to imagine. As the saying goes, pessimists sound smart, optimists make money.
AI will eliminate many jobs, but I suspect it will create far more.
@realroseceline Anchoring bias cuts in both directions.
Price went up? Upside must be limited now.
Price went down? Fundamentals must have deteriorated.
Worse still, if it stayed sideways? Must do something now.
So, $NBIS raising another $4.5B, potentially $5.175B…
Let’s look at the historical pattern.
September 2025: Nebius announces the $17.4B Microsoft contract. Two days later, it announces a massive financing package to fund accelerated growth.
March 2026…Nebius announces a $27B Meta deal and the $2B Nvidia investment. The following day, it announces a $3.75B convertible offering, which was ultimately upsized to $4B.
Now August 2026: Nebius is back looking to raise another $4.5B, potentially $5.175B.
Could simply be funding the enormous capacity pipeline already in front of them.
But historically, Nebius has raised huge amounts of capital around the same time it has secured huge amounts of demand.
I wouldn’t automatically assume another hyperscaler contract is coming.
But given the pattern….lets see what happens. 👀
@fintegrate Read a quote many years ago that went something like this:
If the consensus thinks the stock is expensive and is unwilling to bid higher, is it really expensive then? It might very well be cheap because no one wants it.
Invert, always invert!
@surayaror@BursaMalaysia Norges Bank Investment Management has many golden nuggets on their YouTube channel. They manage the Norwegian Government Pension Fund.
Not classes but interviews. Filter for the most popular videos, those are easier to digest.
@DurableCreators Alternative asset manager $BN, which differentiates itself from peers with its operation-focus DNA. Additional tailwind from banks shying away due to Basel 3.1.