We've always aimed to deliver premium Shopify solutions that are not just a solution to a problem, but a launchpad for brands to grow off of ๐
Kudos Emma & Noah for trusting us ๐๐ป
Check the app out in the first comment. DACH parents might be interested ๐
As a continuation to my Shopify app reviews thread, we've implemented review requests from within the app, so we don't have to redirect merchants to the app listing.
Pretty sad to find out that we're getting chased pretty hard for making our app mobile friendly for BFS, but the Shopify review request modal is not opening for merchants on mobile...
For anyone interested, we got 2 of the reviews published a week/10day-ish after they were left. I don't know if it was because of this post or now. I would either way urge everyone to share what they experience.
It probably won't hurt if they do it in a more composed manner than me, but I was pretty agitated when writing this.
@eytanseidman@blairbeckwith@jzazove I don't know if there's anything I can do to help going forward, but I'm happy to provide feedback to help refine this. At the end of the day, I think I speak for everyone putting real effort into Shopify in saying that a fair, level playing field is what we need to strive for.
Thanks!
Alright, here's my 2 cents about this. It's not going to be short, but if you are a @ShopifyDevs, I'd love you to comment. I hate to moan about this, but I feel we need to do something to save what's obviously happening and before I know what, I'll just try and make myself heard.
I'm going to share our app store experience in the past month or two. The preamble:
We have a paid app that's BFS and has close to 40 reviews, has been around for almost 2 years, actively worked on in only 2026. Last month we launched 2 new free apps targeted at smaller merchants.
We've been doing paid advertising for these over many channels, which drove many smaller stores to install them (close to 200 for both apps at this point). We've probably handled close to 40 support tickets at this point, 6-7 of which have confirmed over the support chat (some of them even sent an image) that they've left us a review. All of these stores are confirmed over GQL to not be Trial stores, but Basic ones. Only 1 of these reviews landed.
We contact support to just find out what's happening. I get a "human" (that's what the button says), which throws all the AI affirmation bullshit responses like "You are completely right, but...", "I understand your frustation, but ...." 10-line messages, which generally say nothing. Among the many bs responses I got back was "reviews held by the trust system can become visible on their own over time as trust is established". I asked how we establish trust and I got told it can be many things - the review, the app, the merchant or whatnot.
Go figure - we can't tell you why the review is being held, we can't tell you what to do to fix that issue. So, please, help me understand how to justify pouring money and effort into building something, feeling like we're actively being sabotaged by the platform we built for.
Now, I understand all of that monitoring is probably there to battle people farming non legitimate reviews, but @malisauskasLT is reporting people farming app reviews breaking 90% of the rules for requesting reviews. Their apps get delisted for a week only to return with the same practices, but refined days, so it's harder to catch them. So, excuse my French, but what the *actual* fuck? Like, should we actually start paying for reviews and swallow the fact that we might get delisted for a week or so?
@Shopify@harleyf I love the platform guys, sincerely. I've spent the past few years building for it and preaching it. Attended half a dozen Shopify events in Canada and Europe in the past few years. But I feel I need to call this nonsense out, because things have been going downhill for longer than they should be.
Days before DotDev this year tens of thousands of legitimate reviews got erased (probably because of AI). That was not good.
We were told that the app listing review process will be sped up (probably with AI). This resulted in completely bloating the app store even more. It's a far worse experience for both merchants and app devs right now.
AI was implemented in partner support and it went from bad to worse. Previously, we were at least speaking with a human, although we were waiting a bit more. Now, we arguably speak with a human who copy-pastes LLM responses at best. It's not better than it was.
AI has been implemented in monitoring app reviews and now no one can tell us what we can do to get our legitimate app reviews out that we have support working around the clock for.
I love AI, but it's all about how we implement this. Somethings needs to be done to address this or the Shopify partner ecosystem we love will just become another victim of enshittification as it grows.
Sincerely,
me, who loves Shopify, but hates how things are going
@ShopifyDevs
Today we unpublished hundreds of apps from the App Store. They came from a small group of high-volume submitters and had no merchant installs.
The App Store exists to solve real problems for merchants. Mass submissions distract from the partners who are doing that work.
Weโll soon be announcing new restrictions that limit the number of apps that can be submitted at once and weโll keep raising the bar.
Alright, for some reason 2 of the reviews got published. I've checked and nothing changed from the stores. Props where they are deserved to @Shopify.
I just hope I don't have to come to X every time something like this happens. Either way, happy to help with whatever I can in improving this going forward.
Alright, here's my 2 cents about this. It's not going to be short, but if you are a @ShopifyDevs, I'd love you to comment. I hate to moan about this, but I feel we need to do something to save what's obviously happening and before I know what, I'll just try and make myself heard.
I'm going to share our app store experience in the past month or two. The preamble:
We have a paid app that's BFS and has close to 40 reviews, has been around for almost 2 years, actively worked on in only 2026. Last month we launched 2 new free apps targeted at smaller merchants.
We've been doing paid advertising for these over many channels, which drove many smaller stores to install them (close to 200 for both apps at this point). We've probably handled close to 40 support tickets at this point, 6-7 of which have confirmed over the support chat (some of them even sent an image) that they've left us a review. All of these stores are confirmed over GQL to not be Trial stores, but Basic ones. Only 1 of these reviews landed.
We contact support to just find out what's happening. I get a "human" (that's what the button says), which throws all the AI affirmation bullshit responses like "You are completely right, but...", "I understand your frustation, but ...." 10-line messages, which generally say nothing. Among the many bs responses I got back was "reviews held by the trust system can become visible on their own over time as trust is established". I asked how we establish trust and I got told it can be many things - the review, the app, the merchant or whatnot.
Go figure - we can't tell you why the review is being held, we can't tell you what to do to fix that issue. So, please, help me understand how to justify pouring money and effort into building something, feeling like we're actively being sabotaged by the platform we built for.
Now, I understand all of that monitoring is probably there to battle people farming non legitimate reviews, but @malisauskasLT is reporting people farming app reviews breaking 90% of the rules for requesting reviews. Their apps get delisted for a week only to return with the same practices, but refined days, so it's harder to catch them. So, excuse my French, but what the *actual* fuck? Like, should we actually start paying for reviews and swallow the fact that we might get delisted for a week or so?
@Shopify@harleyf I love the platform guys, sincerely. I've spent the past few years building for it and preaching it. Attended half a dozen Shopify events in Canada and Europe in the past few years. But I feel I need to call this nonsense out, because things have been going downhill for longer than they should be.
Days before DotDev this year tens of thousands of legitimate reviews got erased (probably because of AI). That was not good.
We were told that the app listing review process will be sped up (probably with AI). This resulted in completely bloating the app store even more. It's a far worse experience for both merchants and app devs right now.
AI was implemented in partner support and it went from bad to worse. Previously, we were at least speaking with a human, although we were waiting a bit more. Now, we arguably speak with a human who copy-pastes LLM responses at best. It's not better than it was.
AI has been implemented in monitoring app reviews and now no one can tell us what we can do to get our legitimate app reviews out that we have support working around the clock for.
I love AI, but it's all about how we implement this. Somethings needs to be done to address this or the Shopify partner ecosystem we love will just become another victim of enshittification as it grows.
Sincerely,
me, who loves Shopify, but hates how things are going
@ShopifyDevs
@eytanseidman@ShopifyDevs P.S. I think apps that were flagged for blatantly breaking the rules (twice) still have all their reviews and are alive and kicking is just pretty demotivational for others as well and I hope you understand how it makes us feel about rules ๐
I think a cool measure would be if a review is not being published for some legitimate reason that does not disclose reasons review farmers might utilize, then just notify the partner.
โStore X left review Y, but they are on Trial and the review will mot be published until they sign up for a paid plan.โ would actually make a huuuge difference in what we experience.
Just got home a few days ago from another great event we got to sponsor as SelfServe at Shopify meetup Dublin.
We are now ServeApps, but that happened between the sponsorship deal and the event. Things are moving fast!
I'm also posting the photo I look like shit on cause I rarely look better either way.
If you haven't checked out @dan_nistorx's event, you definitely should.
@ShopifyDevs Also, does someone know how I can get a dev store on the new admin, so I can actually reproduce & fix the issue? @liam_at_shopify@blairbeckwith - sorry to tag like this, but our upsells are unconfigurable at the moment for shops on the new admin
@ShopifyDevs, a @heymantle question. Has anyone successfully migrated away? We have a dozen merchants charged through the platform but I still canโt see a why to stop charging them from Mantle and rely on our engine online without asking them to resubscribe.
Guys if you operate a Shopify store, give small apps a chance.
I know that probably 2800 reviews feels safer than 30. And a big logo with a lot of marketing behind it feels like the responsible choice. But you get a lot more than you pay for if you work with a small app that has potential: ๐๐ป