The best pet care amenity for your property.
๐๏ธ Convenient & Small footprint (~2200sqft)
โฑ Quick stops or all day play for dogs
๐ถ Expert care
Like any normal person, I spent Saturday night tracking every dollar I spent on my dog's healthcare for 8.5 years. Here's what pet insurance actually cost me.
As the founder of a dog daycare company, I talk to pet parents about healthcare costs every day. But I wanted to put real numbers behind the conversation so I analyzed every vet invoice, insurance claim, and premium payment for my Mini Dachshund, Poppy, from 2017 to date.
The short answer: pet insurance cost me $1,958 MORE than if I'd just paid out of pocket.
The breakdown:
Without insurance, I would have paid $16,821 in vet bills. With insurance, I paid $16,821 in vet bills + $11,709 in premiums and got back $9,751 in reimbursements.
True net cost: $18,779.
But that one number doesn't tell the full story.
The first 5 years were a total loss. I paid $4,577 in premiums and got back $41. Yikes, this was a hard one to swallow. I also believe in her earlier years I didn't submit claims as diligently.
Poppy was young and healthy.. just routine care, vaccines, the occasional ear infection. Insurance was basically a donation.
Then year 6 hit. Grape poisoning emergency ($1,586 - insurance covered 83%). This happened in Ann Arbor & vet costs were lower than in Los Angeles. Phew.
A complicated dental extraction ($1,716 - covered 90%).
A cardiology workup for a new heart murmur ($1,175 - covered 90%).
Suddenly, the math started working.
In the last 3 years alone, insurance returned $3,935 more than I paid in premiums.
A few things surprised me:
My "90% reimbursement" plan actually returned ~67% on average. The $500 annual deductible eats into every policy year before a single dollar comes back. In low-claim years, the effective rate dropped as low as 12%.
Premiums grew 158% over Poppy's lifetime - from $69/month as a puppy to $179/month at age 8. That's roughly 12% per year.
Preventive care caps haven't kept up. My plan caps exam reimbursement at $50 and heartworm prevention at $25 - amounts that barely covered those costs five years ago, let alone today. We pay $199/yr for unlimited exams at a membership vet clinic that has locations in LA / Bay Area so it works out well for us.
So was it worth it?
For pure ROI? No. I paid more with insurance than without.
For peace of mind? Absolutely. Dachshunds are prone to IVDD (spinal disease), and a single surgery can run $6,000โ$10,000. Poppy has documented disc calcification and an emerging heart condition. One major event would flip the math entirely.
Pet insurance isn't an investment, it's a hedge. And the data shows exactly what you're paying for: protection against the tail risk, not savings on the routine stuff.
If you're a pet parent weighing this decision, I hope these numbers help. The pet insurance industry could use a lot more transparency about what these plans actually deliver.
Happy to share the full dataset with anyone who wants to dig in.
Free dog daycare to dogs and families in need. If youโve evacuated or are a frontline worker (thank you). Please be safe and come by @dogdropco for care.
@adamwasch We close early on Christmas Eve so our employees can get home to their families if they celebrate. Closed on Christmas Day. Closed on Jan 1st. All other days, open and business as usual. One of the perks of us not being in boarding :) We aren't a seasonal business
Other dog daycares didn't meet our standards, so we built own own.
Weโve created a space where your pup can thriveโsocially, physically, and mentally. From spacious play areas to climate-controlled environments, every detail is designed with your dogโs safety in mind.