Working on artificial intelligence, consumer protection, and civil procedure. Law professor currently visiting at @YaleLawSch, usually at @GeorgetownLaw
@IThinkIAgree How does the “prose, organization, ideas” breakdown apply to using AI in research, eg to find information or to analyze or manipulate data? It’s not clear to me that there’s a natural fit within those categories but this seems like a big category of AI use in scholarship.
This U.S. Attorney letter is justifiably getting a lot of attention, but there's an additional issue that I haven't seen raised: It is a civil preservation demand letter sent in what purports to be a criminal case.
Quick thread.
@LeeHepner Yeah; if the point is just that there are lots of desirable legal protections that SB 53 doesn't have, then that's totally right. I'm not sure I'd say SB 53 is on net bad, or wasn't worth it, or that existing laws provide adequate protection. But certainly SB 53 is very limited.
This seems overstated to me. First, these lawsuits could easily fail; just filing a lawsuit under an old law doesn't prove much. Second, even if broad old laws can get there on the substance, statutes can put in processes that are much faster and more reliable than litigation.
For all the hubbub over new AI safety laws, it’s really telling that this lawsuit invokes nuisance and unfairness laws that date to the mid-19th Century.
All of those tremendously expensive, laborious fights over California’s first-in-nation frontier AI safety law. To what end?
When these other AI public safety suits have been filed, one of my reactions each time has been "this feels like an argument that would be more effective coming from the California AG." And now the California AG has filed. A few thoughts on why this suit is different. /1
Between this, the Florida AG suit, and the LASST suit, there is now a small wave of lawsuits challenging frontier AI companies on the basis of broad public safety concerns. They involve different causes of action, and address real risks, but I think they share similar hurdles. 1/
...the litigation will take. There are lots of opportunities for delay. But especially with the arguments about existing investigations being thwarted, I could imagine the AG getting some form of preliminary relief in this case, especially around information or transparency. 8/
But in general, the courts move too slowly and are typically too focused on individual, ex post injuries to be the path that I would bet on for public safety regulation of the AI industry. /end
Between this, the Florida AG suit, and the LASST suit, there is now a small wave of lawsuits challenging frontier AI companies on the basis of broad public safety concerns. They involve different causes of action, and address real risks, but I think they share similar hurdles. 1/
I could be wrong about all of this, of course. There are some very good lawyers and organizations working on these suits. And in general, it's good to have a regulatory movement have a court strategy as part of it. So I'll be watching these suits and others like it. 13/