🚨 BREAKING: Damning new reports expose key roles played by #charteredaccountants & #recruitmentagencies in the #LoanChargeScandal. There was industrial mis-selling for profit for huge commissions & fees, yet the Government refuses to tackle perpetrators.
https://t.co/fph69xgWyh
Please feel free to use this to explain the similarities to anyone you chat to about the Loan Charge especially to your MP, when trying to get them to sign the EDM and join the LC APPG
#LoanChargeScandal#PostOfficeScandal@LCAG_2019@loanchargeAPPG
LOAN CHARGE vs POST OFFICE SCANDAL
The Loan Charge and Post Office Scandals share several key similarities, although they are different in nature and context. Both are major UK injustices involving flawed systems, government failings, and devastating personal consequences for innocent people.
Here’s a breakdown of the similarities:
🔹 1. Wrongful Accusations of Ordinary People
Loan Charge: Tens of thousands of freelancers and contractors were retrospectively hit with huge tax bills for using loan-based remuneration schemes that were legal and disclosed at the time. Many claim they were misled or had little choice.
Horizon:
Sub-postmasters were accused of theft and fraud due to errors in the Horizon IT system, which falsely showed shortfalls.
🔹 2. Government and Institutional Cover-Up
Loan Charge: HMRC and the Treasury have defended the policy despite evidence it was unfair and that many taxpayers were misled or coerced.
Horizon: The Post Office denied faults in the Horizon system for years, even as evidence mounted that it was unreliable.
🔹 3. Devastating Human Cost
Loan Charge: Reported suicides, bankruptcies, broken families, and mentalhealth crises. A direct suicide risk report was made but not published until pressured.
Horizon: Similar personal tragedies – many sub-postmasters went to prison, lost homes, businesses, reputations, and suffered severe trauma.
🔹 4. Denial of Fair Legal Process
Loan Charge: Taxpayers were denied the right to appeal through normal tax tribunals; instead, they faced accelerated payment demands.
Horizon: Sub-postmasters were prosecuted using flawed data; courts were misled, and many were denied a proper defence.
🔹 5. Retrospective Injustice
Loan Charge: Applied retrospectively, initially going back as far as 1999.
Horizon: People were held accountable for system errors going back decades, with little recourse.
🔹 6. Lack of Accountability
Loan Charge: Despite Parliamentary pressure, no one in HMRC or the Treasury has resigned or been held to account.
Horizon: Only after years of campaigning and a public inquiry have some Post Office executives begun to face consequences.
🔹 7. Grassroots Campaigns Led to Public Awareness
Loan Charge: The Loan Charge Action Group (LCAG) and cross-party MPs Loan Charge APPG fought to expose the injustice.
Horizon: The Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance and investigative journalism (e.g., by nick wallis) were key in raising awareness.
Summary
Factor Loan Charge Scandal Horizon Scandal
Victims Contractors, freelancers, Small Business, Subpostmasters
Systemic Failure HMRC retrospective tax policy Faulty IT system (Horizon)
Institutional Denial Treasury/HMRC Post Office
Personal Harm Suicides, financial ruin, wrongful imprisonment
Legal Injustice No tax tribunal access Flawed prosecutions
Grassroots Pressure LCAG and APPG on Loan Charge JFSA and public inquiry
This shows how state institutions can cause widespread harm when they refuse to admit mistakes — and how justice often requires public pressure and persistence. There is a real risk of more Suicides if victims are forced to pay up
Hey @andyverity - just watching you being interviewed on @BBCNews about the #PostOfficeInquiry and frankly you could have been talking about the #LoanChargeScandal - multiple suicides, individuals ‘wronged by a government body’ - lots of other parallels too.
Every day brings shocking new revelations about scope of #LoanChargeScandal, the time for a public inquiry is now.
- How many lives lost?
- How many familes broken?
- How many people's #mentalhealth destroyed?
- How many bankruptcies?
- How many lies and cover ups?
Ray McCann has declined to reply to us before he publishes his report. His review is into individuals’ settlement terms, so the revelation of the 2015 settlement deal is directly relevant. He knew about it in 2019. It wasn’t disclosed during the #MorseReview or in 2025. Why not?
We once again thank Ray McCann for meeting with the APPG to discuss the #McCannReview into #LoanCharge settlement terms. We do however have concerns relating to what we heard, including things that demonstrate it isn’t independent of HMRC & the Treasury.
https://t.co/xnp4tBYQMR
Hi @michelledonelan - the #LabourParty has committed to a proper independent review of the #LoanChargeScandal - your party should too. The Amyas Morse one has been proven to be flawed - steered, edited and approved by none other than #HMRC
It is good news indeed that @UKLabour has committed to an independent review @jreynoldsMP . The civil servants in @HMRCpressoffice@HMRCgovuk@hmtreasury acting as judge, jury and executioner, and vindictively so has to stop. PO writ large
Apparently, the only people interested in the loan charge are the "die hard LC crowd".
I wonder how many people fall within that definition.
Please RT if you are interested.
Hi @michelledonelan - your Chippenham constituents need you to understand what a villain this man is. He misled thousands of ordinary workers, walked off with their money and left them to face life-changing tax bills that HE was responsible for paying #LoanChargeScandal
‘Self-confessed liar’ Doug Barrowman’s links with tax avoidance schemes revealed and the estimated £300mn he made from them as clients were bankrupted by HMRC and two killed themselves https://t.co/xcf7v87nRk scroll down for tax avoidance story. He denies doing anything wrong.
If you're affected by or fighting #LoanCharge give this post a like & retweet so people can identify your Twitter profile then revisit this post, I'll post it again as well, then follow everybody who has liked it. We need to build a network. Stronger together
#LoanChargeScandal
A powerful segment on @BBCRadio4 on the #LoanChargeScandal, explaining the unfairness that #HMRC failed to deduct tax from agencies/umbrella companies & invented the #LoanCharge to instead go after workers who had been assured of compliance. There have been 10 #LoanChargeSuicides
These are strong criticisms made against HMRC.
Such conduct (if carried out by taxpayers or their advisers) would not be tolerated by HMRC (and rightly so).
It behoves HMRC either to:
1) disprove the allegations or
2) make some very profuse apologies to Parliament.
The #LoanCharge is on your watch @HuddlestonNigel - it’s in your gift to sort this out so for pity’s sake do something man and stop believing what #HMRC tells you - have we learned nothing from the #PostOffceScandal
This is the appalling reality of how #HMRC treat people. ⬇️
Presumably the overpaid principle-less ghouls in @HMRCpressoffice will want to send a reply to this tweet, claiming they “offer support”, “go after promoters” etc 🙄💩
#HMRCLies#LoanChargeScandal#ReformHMRC