@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 PCA has also improved YoY. Using ur math he should be a sure bet for 50/50 next year. If PCA is ahead of Chourio now, and players just continually improving no matter what, how will he ever catch PCA
@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 Obviously this is general but in my opinion, The younger an international prospect reaches professional baseball, the more their MLB performance should be weighted toward “what they are” rather than “what they might become.” (5)
@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 At the same age, I would expect the guy with double the professiona experience to be better.
Intl players, especially higher pedigree prospects, have shown an ability to produce immediately in the big leagues. I attribute that to the fact that their development starts earlier
@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 There’s no evidence to say he will! My point is PCA is doing what you say Chourio will do. I will give Chourio credit when he does it, not when his Age 22 season projects he will.
@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 It’s so difficult to project the future. PCA may be the next JRod who was supposed to be the next Trout! But when a player puts together the season that Pete has, it’s remarkable and, I just don’t agree with “Chourio will incrementally improve x% every year until he’s an MVP”
@andrewhzlhanson@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 I love Chourio, he’s a key piece of my dynasty fantasy baseball team because his production at his young age has been so consistent. But at similar points in their careers, Pete IS hyper elite abd Jackson MAY BECOME hyper elite.
@berniefucks@G_Webs_Since_93 Yeah but that assumes a linear career progression. Jackson Chourio has 60 more professional games than PCA at all levels. PCA tore his labrum at 20.
Jackson Chourio is a phenomenal player that will be great for years to come, but PCA is hyper elite and on a different planet rn
@m_schettig@JuicedBets@PeteBlackburn If it takes you 10 minutes to run a mile to the store, it will probably take you longer than 10 minutes to run right back
@natmcdermott2 You do misunderstand war. Think of it as a pie rather than a counting stat. Pete’s share of the Wins Above Replacement likely increased due to the replacement level decreasing (i.e. the player you are comparing him to is worse)
@MiniMegal@OHouls@Aaron59912965 Because 1 player going 0/5 with 5 Ks is at absolute max, 13% of your at bats being Ks. A position player can never LOSE a team a game, however offensively they certainly can win a game.
Also I think this shows how little people understand the everyday output of an average CF.
@FCozzi8@bleacherbum099 I appreciate that you actually have put a lot of thought into this so I respect it. I guess the one point I will nibble on is Happ. We’re getting right to the point where I think he should hit the bench but he is a proven MLB hitter and Cubs need him, he’s owed time to figure out