The Left Has Been Running the West Into the Ground for 40 Years. Here's the Receipt.
I wrote that Milei and Bukele exposed the empire of lies. A lot of you asked: whose empire? Who exactly built the system they're dismantling?
Let's name it.
When I say "the left," I don't mean a party. I mean an ideology that took over the institutions of the West and stopped needing elections to rule. Some of its members call themselves socialist. Some call themselves centrist. Some, like Macron, say they're "neither left nor right." Merkel was officially center-right. It doesn't matter. Look at what they do, not the label on the jersey.
Here is what I call the left. Barack Obama and the Democratic establishment. Emmanuel Macron and the technocracy that runs France from the Inspection des Finances. The European Commission, which produces 10,000 pages of regulation and zero industrial champions. The international bureaucracies: the UN agencies, the WHO, the IMF of the austerity-for-thee era. The philanthropic billionaires who fund all of it, Bill Gates, one of the largest private funders of the WHO, and George Soros, whose Open Society Foundations have poured billions into progressive NGOs, activist networks and media projects around the world. And the professional class that lives off the machine: the NGOs, the think tanks, the consulting firms, the "experts."
Different faces, one worldview. Here it is in one sentence: ordinary people can't be trusted, so a credentialed class must manage them.
Everything flows from that.
Start with September 11, 2001.
That day, the West got the clearest warning in its history. Nineteen men, an ideology that openly declared war on our civilization, and 3,000 dead in the most powerful city on earth.
The correct response was obvious. Name the enemy. Defend your borders. Defend your culture without apology.
What did the left do in the two decades that followed? It decided the real danger was "Islamophobia." It spent twenty years explaining that the problem was us: our history, our foreign policy, our "lack of inclusion." It opened the doors wider. In Libya in 2011, the Obama administration and its European allies helped topple Gaddafi with no plan for the day after, turning the country into an open highway to Europe. In 2015, Merkel declared "we can do this," and over a million people entered Germany in a year with no vetting worth the name. In France, after Charlie Hebdo, after the Bataclan, after Nice, after Samuel Paty, the official response was candles, hashtags, and a lecture about "amalgame."
9/11 should have been the moment the West woke up. The left made sure it went back to sleep.
The economic scam.
For forty years, the left sold us the same idea: the state can spend without limit, debt doesn't matter, and every problem is solved with a new program, a new agency, a new tax.
France is the laboratory. Public spending around 57% of GDP, the highest in the developed world. A debt over 3,000 billion euros. The highest taxes in Europe. And for what? Hospitals in crisis, schools collapsing in the PISA rankings, a police force that can't secure a train station.
That's not a failure of the system. That is the system. The money doesn't disappear. It flows to the people who administer it. Every euro of "public action" employs a committee, a consultant, an NGO, a report. The poor never get richer. The managers of poverty do.
Milei proved it in Argentina. The moment you cut the machine, inflation collapses. They told us it was impossible because their salaries depended on it being impossible.
COVID: the full-scale stress test.
If you want to see this class in action, look at 2020.
In March, the French government told us masks were useless for the general public. A few months later, they were mandatory outdoors. We signed our own permission slips to leave our homes, like prisoners filling out forms for their guards. Schools closed. Small businesses died while Amazon had its best year ever. Children lost years of education and socialization. Health passes split society into two classes of citizens.
In the United States, it came out that the CDC's school reopening guidance had been shaped with input from the teachers' unions. Not from pediatricians. From unions.
And who was advising? A "Scientific Council" whose members appeared on TV every night and never paid a price for being wrong. Models predicting millions of deaths that never matched reality. Not one of them ever came back to say "we got it wrong, here's what we learned."
These weren't experts. They were experts by title. A diploma, a prestigious institution, a position on a committee. Never a business built, never a product shipped, never a consequence suffered for a bad decision.
Consulting firms: the metastasis.
And when the experts by title don't know what to do, they call the experts by invoice.
In 2021, the French state spent more than one billion euros on consulting firms. McKinsey was brought in to help organize the vaccination campaign. The pension reform, the housing benefit reform, the vaccination strategy: all passed through consulting decks. A French Senate inquiry called the phenomenon "tentacular," and the Paris financial prosecutor opened an investigation into McKinsey's tax situation.
Think about what that means. A country with millions of civil servants, the most prestigious administrative schools in the world, and it outsources its thinking to 28-year-old analysts with a PowerPoint template.
Steve Jobs saw this decades ago. He said consulting gives you a broad but paper-thin view of companies, like "a picture of a banana." You never own the result. You recommend, you invoice, you leave. If it works, you take credit. If it fails, it's the client's fault.
Nassim Taleb gave it a name: no skin in the game. And that is the core disease of the entire system. The people who make the decisions never pay for the consequences. The politician who opened the borders lives in a gated neighborhood. The economist who defended endless debt has a tenured job. The consultant who designed the reform is already on the next mission. The philanthropist who funded the NGO pays no price when the policy blows up.
The ones who pay are always the same: the worker, the shop owner, the farmer, the kid in a school where nobody teaches anymore.
So what's the common thread?
9/11, uncontrolled immigration, endless debt, catastrophic COVID management, consulting firms running the state. These look like separate problems. They're not. They're five symptoms of the same disease: a class that governs without accountability, protected by titles instead of results, funded by money it didn't earn, and convinced it knows better than the people it rules.
Every idea they push follows the same logic. More state, less individual responsibility. More managers, fewer builders. More guilt, less pride. And a civilization that stops building, stops defending itself and stops believing in itself has only one possible destination.
The good news.
Milei and Bukele proved the machine can be stopped. Not in fifty years. In two. Inflation can be crushed. Gangs can be crushed. Experts can be ignored. And the sky doesn't fall. The sky clears.
The left's greatest power was never its ideas. It was the belief that there was no alternative.
That belief is dead.
Now it's our turn.
The Midterm is Not the Endterm
It is too soon to calibrate the direction of the post midterm Democratic and Republican Parties.
But if the first 72 hours are any indication—and despite the soon to be Speaker’s denials—the Left is already bragging about subpoenas, and it is intoxicated by the notion of investigations and impeachments.
Heady Democrats have entirely forgotten the politically suicidal fashion of the 2021-4 five civil and criminal courtroom circuses, the Mar-a-Lago raid, and the blue state deballoting efforts.
All that and more fueled the Trump recovery.
Wild talk of multi-trillion-dollar new agendas grows, like socializing the health care system, a renewed Green New Deal, student loan forgiveness, and illegal alien amnesties, along with new punitive income and estate regulations and taxes.
This socialist dream is reminiscent of the 2021 giddy splurging that gave the country a 9.1% inflation rate by midterm year 2022.
Along with the Afghanistan disaster (the Left’s correction for a Middle East ‘forever war”) the inflation would ensure Biden a 40% popularity.
The idea that the Left, which cannot do much real lawmaking without a veto-proof Congress, will try to reach deals with the White House, adopt a 1995 Clinton-like realist agenda, simply claim credit for the growing Trump economy, or moderate its rhetoric is highly unlikely.
Instead, we hear crazy talk of confiscations, new billionaire and millionaire punitive taxes, imprisonments, changing the Constitution—all in full suicidal 1972 McGovern style.
Republicans are blame-gaming each other, which can be constructive if over issues and reforms rather than social media ad hominem. But they need to message far better, about both the administration’s successes and the dangers of a socialist future.
There will be likely be no planned presidential succession, or gentlemanly agreement on a front runner. That’s likely good news. More likely as of now a triangular race between front-runners De Santis, Rubio, and Vance emerges—all of whom are far preferable to any ticket with a Newsom, Harris, AOC, Mamdani, or el-Sayed.
If the Republicans can stay reasonably united, they can ensure permanent presidential vetoes of crazy leftwing legislation, fight back on the Democratic committee inquisitions, and see the economy in the final two years become an asset in recovering their popularity.
Absent in all conversations is that there is increasing evidence that the economy is actually expanding and has the potential to boom in 2027, or at least the data indicate such potential.
The jobs report came out yesterday with a stunning 165,000 jobs created in October (accompanied by the usual journalists’ adverb “unexpectantly”), dropping unemployment to 4.1%.
Revised 3rd GDP stats now show a robust 3.4% growth—likely ensuring at least 3%+ growth for the year.
Third Quarter consumer spending soared 3.8%.
Private domestic investment surged with 19.4% growth.
Just reported last week: median family income in 2025 hit a new record ($87,460)—the highest in 60 years adjusted for inflation. And poverty dipped to its lowest rate (ever 10.2%).
In October manufacturing activity grew faster than at any time in the past five years.
Yes, prices are too high, and final 2026 inflation, given gas hikes, is scheduled to increase by one point (3.7%) from last year’s (2.7%). But it is still lower than the pan-European average (ca. 4+%)—and much lower than the Biden average over four years of 5.1%.
Gas prices are already falling. On November 6 prices fell to a $4.06 average—as global oil transit is mostly back to prewar levels and refineries scramble to handle the increased deliveries.
U.S. companies are dominating all the top 10 rankings in market capitalization/usage in key area such as software, AI, digital media, space, satellite launches, and bio/genetic engineering.
Note that today gas prices are not that much higher than 4 years ago at the 2022 midterm time ($4.06 vs. ca. $3.80), and haven’t once spiked to $5 a gallon as they did in 2022, just four months before the Biden midterms.
Yet oddly, the red wave sputtered in 2022 when the U.S. was in far worse economic shape than this week when the blue wave became a tsunami.
Messaging, media, and communication count, so note:
Four years ago GDP growth was lower than today—even though the pandemic was about over and there was a dramatic return to work and spending.
The inflation rate was almost three times higher in 2022 than now.
Median family income was $14,000 lower than now. The poverty rate was higher in 2022.
The Dow was 20,000 points lower. Foreign investment will likely end the year 30-40% higher than in 2022.
Real wage growth (nominal wages minus inflation) while not great in 2026 is likely to end the year far better than in 2022 (when real wage growth fell 2-3%).
So why would “affordability” have been decisive in the 2026 midterms when it was not in 2022?
The 21% aggregate inflation rate Trump inherited force-multiplied the average 3.15% Trump inflation rate of 2025-6— yet in a way the aggregate first-term Trump inflation rate (7.7% just a third of the Biden total) did not exaggerate all that much the 9.1% inflation rate in 2022.
Messaging, however, matters. The administration did not explain adequately that a 21% rise in prices cannot be lowered without radical deflation or recession, but only ameliorated by medium family income growth and lowering the inflation rate from the Biden 2021-5 averages, both of which occurred in 2025-6, but were forgotten.
Media coverage of the Biden 2022 weak economy were muted, while Trump’s 2-year inflation rate was exaggerated during 2026.
The Iran war became the culprit as a war of choice that made the inherited Biden 21% high prices and the inability to lower were them solely Trump’s fault. Again, there was inadequate explanation of either the economic reality or why the gamble to denuclearize Iran was defensible–with the caveat that stopping the bombing at day 38 and talking with theocrats for seven months was an unfortunate mistake.
The domestic and foreign policy activism of the lame-duck Clinton (1998-2000} and Obama (2014-2016) presidencies increased after their loss of Congress. Indeed, their popularity climbed from a once nadir of below forty to sixty percent approval or above.
There is no reason why the Trump administration cannot have a successful last two years. The economy is growing.
The crime rate is at historic lows.
The border is closed shut. The radical pro-Western political transformation of South and Central America has remade the entire Western Hemisphere.
European NATO is rearming.
Oil and gas production is at highest levels of any nation in history.
The bloated federal work force has been trimmed by over 270,000 jobs.
There is no longer a 40,000-50,000 shortfall in military recruitment. The forced reforms in higher education were long overdue.
The verdict on Iran is still out.
If it is denuclearized, the crippling sanctions continued, the Strait kept open, the provincial opposition armed—and our military gone home— the regime will face an increasingly restive population
2026 was an unequivocal defeat, but 2028 need not be.
If the administration and Congress stay disciplined and united, and can message better, while the Left goes utterly berserk, drunk on their midterm successes, socialism/Islamism, and Trump Derangement Syndrome 2.0, the tide will soon radically turn— as the economy already has.
If you really care about this country, this is one of the areas where your attention should be right now. @DataRepublican is exactly right. The greatest obstacle they face to a complete power grab is the Sec of War, Pete Hegseth. He has rebuilt a military that will stand by the constitution & is comitted to the oath every member takes. Hegseth does not back down or fear his enemies because he what he fears is God. They need him out of the way so badly - which should tell you just how important it is to stop them. Read the thread. The truth always matters but it is more important now than ever.
@DavidZorkocy I’ve met Scott several times and heard him speak. He’s a great American doing useful work for our country.
Tucker Carlson is a useless cunt.
Hope that helps clarify things.
What just happened?
The Nasdaq 100 just posted its largest daily drop since the 2020 Pandemic, with the S&P 500 erasing -$3 trillion today.
Just 24 hours ago, the Dow surged +1,600 points after the Democrats "swept" the Midterms.
So, what changed? Let us explain.
(a thread)
🚨 BRUTAL: The stock market just suffered its WORST crash since April 2025.
The Dow plunged over 1,800 points and tech got completely obliterated.
Over $3 TRILLION in wealth vanished in a single day.
The economic fallout is real. Wake up, America! 🇺🇸
I often say we live in a deeply left-wing society. A society where the exceptional individual cannot exist, and where everything is organized to make sure he never does.
It starts at school. Minds are formatted to believe everyone is the same. That standing out is suspicious. That succeeding more than others is necessarily unfair.
We ended up confusing two things that have nothing in common: equality of opportunity and equality of outcome. The first is an ideal. The second is leveling everyone down.
The result: anything that sticks out gets shaved off.
And then there was an anomaly in the system.
Elon Musk.
He is in a completely different league from every other tech entrepreneur. And not on just one dimension.
His ability to go all in. In 2008, he put his last millions into SpaceX and Tesla while both were on the edge of bankruptcy. No plan B.
His skin in the game. He doesn't bet other people's money. He bets his own, his reputation, and today his personal safety.
His connection to reality. He doesn't run his companies from a comfortable ivory tower, between two committees and three reporting cycles. Marc Andreessen said it: he isn't aware of any other current CEO who operates the way Musk does. To find an equivalent, you have to go back to the great industrialists of the late 19th century. Every week, Musk identifies the biggest problem at each company, goes straight to the engineer on the front line, and fixes it. 52 weeks a year.
History has always treated this kind of anomaly the same way. Those who broke the established model were almost always rejected, mocked, persecuted.
Socrates, sentenced to drink hemlock for teaching young people to question.
Giordano Bruno, burned alive in Rome in 1600 for imagining an infinite universe.
Galileo, tried by the Inquisition, forced to recant, kept under house arrest until his death.
Gutenberg, who changed the world with the printing press, stripped of his workshop by his creditor.
Lavoisier, father of modern chemistry, guillotined in 1794.
Semmelweis, who understood that simply washing hands could stop women dying in childbirth. Ridiculed by his peers, died in an asylum.
Boltzmann, who defended the existence of atoms against the entire scientific establishment. Died in 1906, just before Jean Perrin proved him right.
Wegener, whose continental drift was mocked for decades. Died in Greenland in 1930, vindicated thirty years later.
Nikola Tesla, who electrified the world, died broke in a New York hotel room.
Alan Turing, who broke Enigma and laid the foundations of computing, convicted in 1952 and chemically castrated. Dead at 41.
Barry Marshall, who had to swallow a culture of bacteria himself to prove ulcers came from an infection. Nobel Prize 2005.
Dan Shechtman, discoverer of quasicrystals, asked to leave his research group. Linus Pauling mocked him, saying there were no quasicrystals, only quasi-scientists. Nobel Prize 2011.
Katalin Karikó, who worked on messenger RNA, demoted by her university and denied funding for years.
Her work made the Covid vaccines possible. Nobel Prize 2023.
The pattern never changes. First they ignore them. Then they mock them. Then they fight them. And they celebrate them once they're dead.
I don't know what form it will take, but I'm almost certain we're heading toward one of two scenarios.
First scenario: the Democrats manage to destroy Musk. We slide into a 1984 where innovating becomes extremely hard. And ironically, it could end very badly, including for the people supporting that project today. A system that crushes its anomalies always ends up collapsing on itself.
Second scenario: he manages to impose his vision of abundance. And for the first time in human history, the person who brought a new paradigm will be alive to see it. And to build it.
Galileo never saw the scientific revolution. Semmelweis never saw antisepsis save millions of lives. Tesla never saw the world run on the alternating current he had imagined.
Musk could see his.
Personally, I think humanity is ready. Neuralink, Optimus, SpaceX. Augmented human intelligence, automated physical labor, space finally opened up. The combination of these three building blocks can do it.
The only question is whether, this time, we let the anomaly see it through.
Are we really going to be dumb enough to hold back the one guy who can take us to abundance, just so we can stay comfortable in our mediocrity?
China might be the last domino to fall if the West collapses. And almost nobody in Beijing seems to see it coming.
Let's run the simulation.
Assume China really is running psyops against the West. Divide, demoralize, push self-hatred, hollow out nation-states from the inside. Assume it works.
Year 1. The US breaks down. Terminal polarization, runaway debt, paralyzed institutions. Europe follows. It never had a spine of its own, it was leaning on Washington.
Year 3. The vacuum gets filled. Not by China. By the supranational layer: international bodies, NGOs, mega-foundations, unelected technocrats. No Western state left strong enough to say no. Agenda 2030 stops being a document and becomes an operating system. Digital ID, programmable money, personal carbon credits, governance by regulation.
Year 5. The West is fully absorbed. One billion people, half of global GDP, aligned under a single doctrine. And that doctrine needs an enemy to justify its expansion.
Year 7. Look at the map. Who is the last major sovereign nation-state refusing global governance? Who has a 5,000-year-old civilization, a party that shares power with no one, an unapologetic national identity? China.
That's when Beijing discovers the problem. The United States was a rational adversary. A rival you could read, negotiate with, trade with. A global technocratic system has no national interest to bargain with. It has a mission. ESG standards imposed on every supplier, climate sanctions on Chinese industry, conditions attached to every deal, pressure on every minority, every province, every border. China ends up alone against an ideological machine that controls global finance, standards and institutions, with no Western counterweight left to play against it.
In pure game theory, it's simple. In a multipolar world of strong nation-states, China has an adversary, but one that plays by the same rules: sovereignty, national interest, balance of power. In a world where globalism has captured the West, China no longer has an adversary. It has a predator playing a different game.
If Beijing is feeding the decay of the West, it's feeding the worst cancer there is. The kind that eats its host, then looks for the next one.
The ultimate paradox: China has an objective interest in a sovereign West winning. A strong rival beats a vacuum that fills itself.