A SpaceX competitor explains just how impossible it is to achieve what Elon has.
Rocket Lab CEO Peter Beck once said reusable rockets didn't make sense for small rockets like his Electron. He promised he'd eat his hat if he ever changed his mind.
In 2019, with SpaceX already landing rockets, he walked on stage and admitted he was wrong.
Then he explained why he'd doubted it. The rocket comes back at "eight and a half times the speed of sound," through plasma "about half the temperature of the sun," with loads like "three elephants" standing on "a 1.8 mm carbon fibre rocket."
"Getting through the wall is really, really hard."
SpaceX first landed an orbital-class rocket booster upright on December 21, 2015.
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions.
Benchmark General Partner Bill Gurley explains why IPOs are broken:
In a traditional IPO, bankers set the price, and the shares go to their biggest clients, mostly hedge funds and asset managers. On day one the stock jumps. Those funds sell into the pop, and retail buys at the higher price.
Gurley: "It doesn't provide access to all investors. It's just a select group of people that happen to be the biggest customers of the investment bank."
The pricing is "determined by humans just guessing."
Every dollar of that first-day jump is money the company could have raised itself. Instead it goes to the funds, in what he calls "massive one-day wealth transfers straight from the founders, employees and investors to the buy side."
"This year it's going to be over $34 billion in one-day giveaways."
That was 2020. Anthropic just priced above its range on a reported ~$500B of orders.
Buying the pop just makes you exit liquidity for insiders.
@bgurley
Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang doesn't think the two frontier labs need to generate trillions of dollars for the AI build out to work.
"They're going to be two of the most consequential technology companies ever built in history."
"But they don't have to be anywhere near a trillion dollars in revenues to be successful. I think we're putting way too much pressure on that."
@altcap
Steve Eisman made a fortune betting against the housing bubble in 2008. Now he's saying Anthropic is selling you the top.
"I think Anthropic might be going public now because the first half of the year looks really good because of token maxing and the lack of open weight models."
The timing means the IPO doesn't have to show third-quarter numbers, which "might show something of a slowdown because of the end of token maxing."
"I actually think by the fourth quarter, we'll definitely see a slowdown. And so I think they needed to go public now."
@edels0n@realsteveeisman
Jensen Huang could strike back by building a competitor to Nvidia.
First, Tae Kim says, Jensen "needs to go through this investigation process and go before Congress." That could keep him busy "the next few months or maybe even a year."
But retirement isn't on the table. As Jensen has "famously said, work is the way he has fun."
Tae Kim's prediction: "six to 12 months from now, he'll do something." Nvidia is "his life's work," so "I don't know if he'll compete with Nvidia, but we'll see."
@firstadopter@tbpn@johncoogan@jordihays
Jason Calacanis predicts that Anthropic will kill Microsoft.
Days before the IPO, Anthropic launched "a Zoom killer," then whiteboards and sheets, "an Excel killer."
Jason's read is that they're building "the ultimate bundle, every single piece of software that you need," and every SaaS company is in the way.
It's the same bundling playbook Microsoft used to win.
@Jason@theallinpod
Watch this before you buy Anthropic's IPO. Warren Buffett hasn't bought one since the 1950s, and says the average person shouldn't even think about it.
Here's what he said in a 2019 interview as Lyft went public:
"We haven't bought an initial public offering, or I haven't, Charlie hasn't, I think since 1955."
The last one was Ford: "I took a free ride on 100 shares and made 500 bucks, and it's the only time I've ever done that."
His advice on hot IPOs: "I think buying new offerings during hot periods in the market, I don't think is anything the average person should think about at all."
Asked whether Lyft could be another Amazon or Google he missed: "Oh, it always can be."
But "you can go around making dumb bets and win, you know. It's not something you want to take as a lifetime policy, though."
Public markets are getting the leftovers. Baillie Gifford's Peter Singlehurst says the real story of the Anthropic IPO is how much value got created before retail investors could touch it.
"Meta IPOed in 2012 at a valuation about one-tenth of the value that Anthropic is coming to the public markets at."
The growth now happens before the IPO. "We saw it with SpaceX as well where you're seeing trillions of dollars of value being created in private markets."
It means that if you only invest in public markets, you're missing most of the upside.
"To do growth equity investing properly in this era, you have to be doing it in both public but also in private markets."
Anthropic President Daniela Amodei says Anthropic IPO is all about funding more aggressive compute costs.
"Anthropic has always had a fraction of what our competitors have had in terms of compute and capital."
Even so, "we've pretty consistently had the most powerful, most performant models for the majority of the past several years."
But staying ahead is getting expensive. "The compute requirements for the future are very large… we will need more compute to be able to stay at the frontier as we get bigger."
Is there any upside left for retail in the Anthropic IPO? Baillie Gifford's Peter Singlehurst says yes, and he isn't selling.
"Public companies have become bigger than anybody thought they could become if you go back 15 years ago."
"There's still so much growth that's happening and we believe this is going to be an exceptional growth stock into the public market."
"We're long term."
David Friedberg says Anthropic's IPO could be a once-in-a-generation bet, regardless of price.
He hasn't studied the numbers. But here's what he's hearing from people who sat in on management conversations:
Anthropic is "building this recursive self-improvement engine," its model capabilities "are accelerating," and its compute cost "per unit of intelligence… is actually declining."
With investments "down to the chip layer," they think they have "this kind of runaway business," and that "this could be a winner-take-all scenario of the biggest market ever."
His bet: if you think there's even a chance that's true, it's worth putting "some percentage of your portfolio to this IPO, regardless of where the market bids it."
@friedberg@theallinpod
Ahead of their blockbuster IPO, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warns us not to overpay for his company.
Jamie Dimon asked him why Anthropic is going public now. Dario said the best advice he got was "never let your company be worth a single dollar more than it's really worth."
That belief guides how he runs Anthropic: "under promise and over deliver." Then he took a not-so-subtle shot at OpenAI: "we don't vague post about models ahead of time."
"We build the model, we make sure it's good, we release the model."
@DarioAmodei
"I was wrong." Chamath Palihapitiya predicts that Anthropic IPO will come in at $1.5 trillion.
His reason: Anthropic has far more cash than anyone thought. CFO Krishna Rao "entering June, already had $125 billion," while total net burn to get there "has been like $9 billion or $10 billion."
He'd assumed they needed to raise $200–250 billion and price "closer to a trillion."
Now he says they only need "$80 and $120 billion," and the price will land "between $1.3 trillion on the low end to $1.7 trillion on the high end."
"I kind of think it'll come in around $1.5 trillion, if I had to just kind of guess."
@chamath@theallinpod
Stratechery's Ben Thompson says Nvidia's board picked protecting itself over its own shareholders.
The board pushed out Jensen Huang, and the stock fell about 15% in five days. So why make a change that costs shareholders that much?
"The board can also be not aligned with the shareholders."
"The shareholders definitely want him to stay. The board does not, and they have to be concerned about liability for themselves."
"This is an outcome that the vast majority of Nvidia shareholders did not want."
@benthompson@sharptechpod@andrewsharp
Nvidia is fine without Jensen Huang.
BofA senior semiconductor analyst Vivek Arya: "Jensen is irreplaceable. He is unique, but I believe that what he also did was lay the foundation for a very strong company."
Next year's growth forecast went up "from 70% to 75%." Margins are holding, "which tells me that their pricing power is very strong."
And it's all happening with the stock trading at "a future price-to-earnings multiple of 10 times, which is generational."
He ends of by saying the stock is very compelling and the headlines are all just noise.
Axios Business Editor Dan Primack says Anthropic needs all the money it can get from its IPO.
Revenue isn't the problem. "It's their spend side."
The bull case is that the models get more efficient, so spending goes "way down, at least as a percentage."
"The efficiency is kind of the ballgame for them." That's what could turn these into "actually viable businesses, which right now, they are still unprofitable."
"Anthropic isn't just going public because it wants headlines. Anthropic is going public because it needs money."
@danprimack
The Grok Bot team shipped 11,000 pull requests last month, with error rates falling the more they ship.
SpaceXSI Principal Engineer Lauren Tan: "Last month, our team shipped a ridiculous 11,000 pull requests to production, which is a wild number."
They ship a new release every day, with 227 people contributing in October alone. And their revert rate, meaning how often code gets rolled back, has fallen to about 0.5%.
@poteto
Alex Finn loves Claude but says Anthropic won't be a $10 trillion company.
"I just can't envision how does this go from $1 trillion to $10 trillion?"
His problem is the moat. SpaceX has "a thousand different ways" to defend its lead. Anthropic only has the best model right now, and if ChatGPT or Grok ships a better one, "their entire moat just goes poof."
His bull case is to skip the consumer fight, which open source will "eat alive," and go for "grand slam breakthroughs. Solve cancer, solve diseases, solve abundance."
@Jason@ThisWeeknAI
AI will kill SaaS. But not for the reasons everyone thinks.
The usual argument is cost: companies will just build their own tools cheaper than SaaS. That misses the bigger force.
Rising cyber threats are the real pressure. Every extra vendor is another attack vector.
Brian Armstrong just said Coinbase is deliberately cutting its vendor list and rebuilding tools in-house because it “just gives you more control.”
As more companies prioritise control and reduce third-party exposure, the incentive to buy off-the-shelf SaaS weakens.
Security, not just price, is becoming the deciding factor.
@brian_armstrong@tbpn
"I was wrong." Chamath Palihapitiya predicts that Anthropic IPO will come in at $1.5 trillion.
His reason: Anthropic has far more cash than anyone thought. CFO Krishna Rao "entering June, already had $125 billion," while total net burn to get there "has been like $9 billion or $10 billion."
He'd assumed they needed to raise $200–250 billion and price "closer to a trillion."
Now he says they only need "$80 and $120 billion," and the price will land "between $1.3 trillion on the low end to $1.7 trillion on the high end."
"I kind of think it'll come in around $1.5 trillion, if I had to just kind of guess."
@chamath@theallinpod