This week on X: “Software is dead” (again).
Poor software, they have killed it at least 10 times in the last couple years. Hopefully it dies a peaceful death, at last.
It will not crash because of this? Hardware companies couldn’t care less, nor hyperscalers that are not in the business of making models. This only hurts frontier labs.
Anthropic is panicking over the release of Kimi K3. In fact, the entire U.S. AI frontier lab ecosystem is panicking right now.
When investors figure out that U.S. frontier labs have no viable long-term revenue model from paying retail customers (because China's models are both better and cheaper), the AI investment bubble will crash.
@IrkedIndeed Not sure how to relate to the art painting domain since it is a domain where I have no taste on. But lets say soccer, if you tell me: “Hey there is a match of soccer robots, they look the same as humans, but they are robots”. I would not care less to watch, I want it to be human.
@IrkedIndeed This is also a thought that took me a bit to realize, but now I’m on the camp of your RT (Ryan). There is a bit of supply and demand also, if anyone can be a Monet, nobody is a Monet. The value is in the scarcity, the struggle, the life and experiences of the human behind it IMO.
@IrkedIndeed Hum, do you think so? Even Sam Altman realized that is not the case, hence the complete failure and shutdown of Sora. I think, effectively, if no creative human effort is put in a piece of art, humans(in general) give basically zero value to it. See: https://t.co/xTFU1MUax2
@IrkedIndeed I beg to differ. If you put a famous person in disguise in the street, the same talent, nobody will care. That person can mimic exactly the original talent. People care about THE person, the difficulties it has been through, and the path to greatness. Not a local mimic.
There will be no AI jobpocalypse.
The story that AI will lead to massive unemployment is stoking unnecessary fear. AI — like any other technology — does affect jobs, but telling overblown stories of large-scale unemployment is irresponsible and damaging. Let’s put a stop to it.
I’ve expressed skepticism about the jobpocalypse in previous posts. I’m glad to see that the popular press is now pushing back on this narrative. The image below features some recent headlines.
Software engineering is the sector most affected by AI tools, as coding agents race ahead. Yet hiring of software engineers remains strong! So while there are examples of AI taking away jobs, the trends strongly suggest the net job creation is vastly greater than the job destruction — just like earlier waves of technology. Further, despite all the exciting progress in AI, the U.S. unemployment rate remains a healthy 4.3%.
Why is the AI jobpocalypse narrative so popular? For one thing, frontier AI labs have a strong incentive to tell stories that make AI technology sound more powerful. At their most extreme, they promote science-fiction scenarios of AI “taking over” and causing human extinction. If a technology can replace many employees, surely that technology must be very valuable!
Also, a lot of SaaS software companies charge around $100-$1000 per user/year. But if an AI company can replace an employee who makes $100,000 — or make them 50% more productive — then charging even $10,000 starts to look reasonable. By anchoring not to typical SaaS prices but to salaries of employees, AI companies can charge a lot more.
Additionally, businesses have a strong incentive to talk about layoffs as if they were caused by AI. After all, talking about how they’re using AI to be far more productive with fewer staff makes them look smart. This is a better message than admitting they overhired during the pandemic when capital was abundant due to low interest rates and a massive government financial stimulus.
To be clear, I recognize that AI is causing a lot of people’s work to change. This is hard. This is stressful. (And to some, it can be fun.) I empathize with everyone affected. At the same time, this is very different from predicting a collapse of the job market.
Societies are capable of telling themselves stories for years that have little basis in reality and lead to poor society-wide decision making. For example, fears over nuclear plant safety led to under-investment in nuclear power. Fears of the “population bomb” in the 1960s led countries to implement harsh policies to reduce their populations. And worries about dietary fat led governments to promote unhealthy high-sugar diets for decades.
Now that mainstream media is openly skeptical about the jobpocalypse, I hope these stories will start to lose their teeth (much like fears of AI-driven human extinction have).
Contrary to the predictions of an AI jobpocalypse, I predict the opposite: There will be an AI jobapalooza! AI will lead to a lot more good AI engineering jobs, and I’m also optimistic about the future of the overall job market. What AI engineers do will be different from traditional software engineering, and many of these jobs will be in businesses other than traditional large employers of developers. In non-AI roles, too, the skills needed will change because of AI. That makes this a good time to encourage more people to become proficient in AI, and make sure they’re ready for the different but plentiful jobs of the future!
[Original text in The Batch newsletter.]
Narrative violations abound:
- Demand for software engineers is rising
- Software devs are rising as a share of new jobs
- AI exposed industries are seeing above-trend wage growth
- Open PM jobs haven't been higher since 2022
More from a16z's David George on the "AI job apocalypse" myth: https://t.co/7sbadmEElG
I would subscribe X if there was a service to automatically remove any hype accounts from my timeline. It is sooo annoying in the AI era.
“It’s so over”
“XYZ’s are cooked”
“This changes EVERYTHING!!”
This is like NFT / Web3 era hype, but they came to programming in general.