But according to this guy and some of you, women living under patriarchy cannot reliably authorize certain sexual experiences because their desires are presumed to be products of domination, then we have arrived at an extraordinarily paternalistic conclusion feministly. Women formally possess sexual autonomy, but whenever their choices become sufficiently disturbing to outside observers, we reserve the right to explain those choices away as products of patriarchy and declare that they could not meaningfully have wanted them.
At that point, we need to have the much larger conversation everyone seems desperate to avoid: What actually makes sex healthy, ethical, or permissible? What kinds of sexual behavior should society discourage even when everyone involved consents? What obligations do people have toward one another beyond obtaining consent? How should we think about intoxication, power, humiliation, promiscuity, casual sex, emotional responsibility, and hookup culture itself?
@porelalma Imo the issue I find is that many Muslims just render all historical claims as permanently immune to reassessment. Like I don’t actually care that classical scholars didn’t dispute something because that’s not a good enough argument for us not to question it in light of evidence
Saying that slavery could’ve continued indefinitely doesn’t refute the fact that Quranic reforms were structurally moving the institution in a particular direction
false apologetics peeves me, the widespread nature of slavery across history suggests strong regulation etc unless the very possibility of true universal emancipation became technologically feasible is a good enough argument, I don't think u need to make up things
going to make a scrumptious sandwich. read my book. walk in the sun. spend time with my mom. trust in the knowledge that i am only a tiny nail in the house of the universe. tiny but useful
@BasedDostoevski@UncYoda And challenging inherited affiliation. It seems less concerned w labels and more w sincerity and one’s response to truth so it’s not obvious that salvation can be reduced to whether someone falls in or outside a historical category like “Muslim”
@BasedDostoevski@UncYoda Sorry to jump in but correct according to who? The Ashari creed? A specific madhab? Basic tawhid? Because even within Islam “correct beliefs” aren’t settled. The Quran repeatedly shifts the focus from identity to reality, critiquing those who say they believe but act unjustly
@chmpgnsoshalist@boysoverflours What does that have anything to do with what she said? You can pathologize two women that you don’t like all day but there are probably more women with present fathers who cheat because cheating is a widely distributed behaviour