YouTube approved our channel for monetization. Twenty-nine days later, it demonetized the whole channel.
Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings. We never received our first payout.
Our appeal was rejected. Now we’re locked out of reapplying until January 29, while new episodes are on hold because I can’t keep funding them without income.
This is what a wrong monetization decision costs a creator. “Wait three months” does nothing to make it right.
Araragi makes anime stories. We stand behind their quality, their creative value and their compliance with YouTube’s monetization policies. We are not going to pretend this work is generic just because a feedback box says so.
Watch the attached video. Look at the stories being dismissed as “generic or repetitive content.”
Tsunade raising Naruto builds a mother–son relationship, then puts that family under the pressure of her responsibilities as Hokage. When Jiraiya dies, Naruto has to confront his own mother’s part in that loss.
In our Minato story, Naruto rescues Jiraiya. His teacher survives to face Nagato alongside him, changing the conflict and its outcome.
Ino seeing Naruto’s memories becomes a romance shaped by secrecy and damaged trust. Her knowing his secret creates consequences that persist after the confrontation. Their relationship then develops across episodes, into adult life and parenthood.
Goku absorbing ki is a power fantasy: a different ability changes his training and fights. Viewers come for a different experience from the family and relationship stories.
Those are substantive creative differences. Continuing an episode, returning to a character or working within a genre does not erase them.
I put my days and nights into this work: developing stories and scripts, revising them, directing performances, building scene-specific visuals, editing and sound. AI assists that process. The creative direction and responsibility are mine. YouTube’s own policies recognize creative AI assistance and recurring characters with distinct storylines.
Our viewers follow these relationships, debate the characters’ decisions and care about the endings. After the suspension update, people told us these stories were something they looked forward to and that they would wait for us. This is a real community being put on hold along with the channel.
We have already put scripts, revisions, production evidence and story comparisons into an appeal. We have a strong case. We know what we create, why our audience watches and the value these videos deliver.
@TeamYouTube: we want a proper human review of the actual work and the evidence already provided, by a team with authority to correct this decision.
Resolve this now. Correct the classification. Restore Araragi’s monetization and resolve the unpaid earnings.
Redirecting us into another appeal cycle, repeating the same label or telling us to wait until January is not a resolution. We should not be paying for YouTube getting this wrong with months of our time, our production budget and the momentum our community built.
YouTube acknowledges its automated monetization systems can get things wrong. Creators need a meaningful way to get a wrong decision corrected while their channels can still keep going.
Fellow creators: you don’t have to make anime stories for this to matter to your work. A decision like this can cut off your income while you’re left trying to keep everything alive. @DeepHumor
Creators shouldn’t need a viral post to get a fair review. But right now, I need your help getting this in front of people who can put it right.
Our community and fellow creators: repost this, share the video and speak about the work in your own words. Stand with Araragi and help us get this resolved now.
And at last we wouldn't be doing anything we do if we weren't getting community support and views on our videos as much as we do, our ino video did 1.3 million views with many other doing really good as well, I know my niche, my audience and content they'll like if it were generic or repetitive I would've known before YouTube decided to hit us with the demonetization as we would have gotten no views or support from community, its not arrogance these are facts which I would like YouTube team to acknowledge. So @TeamYouTube figure your stuff out us creators shouldn't be paying with our time and sacrifice our effort, money and momentum because of something you've gotten wrong and I definitely don't want my subscribers who do look forward to my videos which is pretty noticeable once you see the love they show in the comment section of our videos.
https://t.co/NYOZ16rnGq
@TeamYouTube Published scenes: Uchiha reforms and Sasuke’s family, 11:38. Sasuke and Naruto brought home, 9:01. Sakura at the hospital after the failed mission, 0:42.
https://t.co/NZBQv1bZub
https://t.co/0RWFtNHoLJ
https://t.co/QvFPpLCqYf
YouTube called Araragi “generic or repetitive.” Look at what happens to Sasuke: he grows up with his family, is brought back after deserting, or escapes and changes Sakura’s story. Three different videos. @TeamYouTube, review the actual stories and reinstate Araragi.
@hawkofkrypton@TeamYouTube@YouTube Thanks for sharing our case, Hawk. If you came over from the repost, here are the two published scenes side by side, with timestamps. This is the evidence we’re asking YouTube to review before reinstating Araragi.
https://t.co/xcUUgCJmZa
YouTube’s rules allow recurring characters when the stories change. Then it called Araragi “generic or repetitive.” One Naruto loses his teacher. The other gets him out alive. These are our actual scenes. @TeamYouTube, review them and reinstate Araragi.
@hawkofkrypton@TeamYouTube@YouTube I hope they take another look. Araragi also got a reapply date after its appeal, under “generic or repetitive.” If you’re highlighting other affected creators, could you share our 49-second case video and scene comparisons?
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@master_pivot Three identical replies, then support closed our chat. Today’s email repeated the verdict without addressing our scenes. Here are those scenes, with timestamps. @TeamYouTube, send this to a policy supervisor who can review it and reinstate Araragi.
https://t.co/xcUUgCJmZa
YouTube’s rules allow recurring characters when the stories change. Then it called Araragi “generic or repetitive.” One Naruto loses his teacher. The other gets him out alive. These are our actual scenes. @TeamYouTube, review them and reinstate Araragi.
Here are the two scenes side by side. If you’ve watched either story, tell people what changed for Naruto after this moment, in your own words. The people reviewing the channel may never have watched Naruto. Help them see why this matters.
https://t.co/xcUUgCJmZa
YouTube’s rules allow recurring characters when the stories change. Then it called Araragi “generic or repetitive.” One Naruto loses his teacher. The other gets him out alive. These are our actual scenes. @TeamYouTube, review them and reinstate Araragi.
YouTube approved our channel for monetization. Twenty-nine days later, it demonetized the whole channel.
Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings. We never received our first payout.
Our appeal was rejected. Now we’re locked out of reapplying until January 29, while new episodes are on hold because I can’t keep funding them without income.
This is what a wrong monetization decision costs a creator. “Wait three months” does nothing to make it right.
Araragi makes anime stories. We stand behind their quality, their creative value and their compliance with YouTube’s monetization policies. We are not going to pretend this work is generic just because a feedback box says so.
Watch the attached video. Look at the stories being dismissed as “generic or repetitive content.”
Tsunade raising Naruto builds a mother–son relationship, then puts that family under the pressure of her responsibilities as Hokage. When Jiraiya dies, Naruto has to confront his own mother’s part in that loss.
In our Minato story, Naruto rescues Jiraiya. His teacher survives to face Nagato alongside him, changing the conflict and its outcome.
Ino seeing Naruto’s memories becomes a romance shaped by secrecy and damaged trust. Her knowing his secret creates consequences that persist after the confrontation. Their relationship then develops across episodes, into adult life and parenthood.
Goku absorbing ki is a power fantasy: a different ability changes his training and fights. Viewers come for a different experience from the family and relationship stories.
Those are substantive creative differences. Continuing an episode, returning to a character or working within a genre does not erase them.
I put my days and nights into this work: developing stories and scripts, revising them, directing performances, building scene-specific visuals, editing and sound. AI assists that process. The creative direction and responsibility are mine. YouTube’s own policies recognize creative AI assistance and recurring characters with distinct storylines.
Our viewers follow these relationships, debate the characters’ decisions and care about the endings. After the suspension update, people told us these stories were something they looked forward to and that they would wait for us. This is a real community being put on hold along with the channel.
We have already put scripts, revisions, production evidence and story comparisons into an appeal. We have a strong case. We know what we create, why our audience watches and the value these videos deliver.
@TeamYouTube: we want a proper human review of the actual work and the evidence already provided, by a team with authority to correct this decision.
Resolve this now. Correct the classification. Restore Araragi’s monetization and resolve the unpaid earnings.
Redirecting us into another appeal cycle, repeating the same label or telling us to wait until January is not a resolution. We should not be paying for YouTube getting this wrong with months of our time, our production budget and the momentum our community built.
YouTube acknowledges its automated monetization systems can get things wrong. Creators need a meaningful way to get a wrong decision corrected while their channels can still keep going.
Fellow creators: you don’t have to make anime stories for this to matter to your work. A decision like this can cut off your income while you’re left trying to keep everything alive. @DeepHumor
Creators shouldn’t need a viral post to get a fair review. But right now, I need your help getting this in front of people who can put it right.
Our community and fellow creators: repost this, share the video and speak about the work in your own words. Stand with Araragi and help us get this resolved now.
And at last we wouldn't be doing anything we do if we weren't getting community support and views on our videos as much as we do, our ino video did 1.3 million views with many other doing really good as well, I know my niche, my audience and content they'll like if it were generic or repetitive I would've known before YouTube decided to hit us with the demonetization as we would have gotten no views or support from community, its not arrogance these are facts which I would like YouTube team to acknowledge. So @TeamYouTube figure your stuff out us creators shouldn't be paying with our time and sacrifice our effort, money and momentum because of something you've gotten wrong and I definitely don't want my subscribers who do look forward to my videos which is pretty noticeable once you see the love they show in the comment section of our videos.
https://t.co/NYOZ16rnGq
@TeamYouTube Watch the published scenes: Jiraiya’s loss in the Tsunade story (27:50), his rescue in the public-parentage story (47:11), and the wider case.
https://t.co/trnom7CcTv
https://t.co/eSrtgMnsUa
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
YouTube demonetized our entire anime-story channel for “generic or repetitive content.”
Same characters. Different consequences.
One Naruto story has him face Jiraiya’s death. Another has him save Jiraiya and change what follows.
@TeamYouTube, reinstate Araragi.
YouTube’s rules allow recurring characters when the stories change. Then it called Araragi “generic or repetitive.” One Naruto loses his teacher. The other gets him out alive. These are our actual scenes. @TeamYouTube, review them and reinstate Araragi.
@ugeeyoutube@TeamYouTube 110 days without a resolution is brutal. YouTube told us “generic or repetitive” again today. In one story Tsunade adopts Naruto. In another, a failed kidnapping saves Sasuke’s family. @TeamYouTube, review those scenes and reinstate Araragi.
https://t.co/lEGSqetN2X
YouTube emailed today and repeated the “generic or repetitive” decision. The reply didn’t address our published story comparisons. We sent the scenes again and requested a YPP policy supervisor’s review to reinstate Araragi.
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
YouTube emailed today and repeated the “generic or repetitive” decision. The reply didn’t address our published story comparisons. We sent the scenes again and requested a YPP policy supervisor’s review to reinstate Araragi.
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
YouTube demonetized our entire anime-story channel for “generic or repetitive content.”
Same characters. Different consequences.
One Naruto story has him face Jiraiya’s death. Another has him save Jiraiya and change what follows.
@TeamYouTube, reinstate Araragi.
@dwhate Your Mark Rober story raised the stakes for animated channels. Araragi lost monetization as “generic or repetitive,” and our appeal was denied. Would you consider a follow-up? Here are the case video and published scenes.
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
If you got monetization restored after a rejected YPP appeal, what got your case reopened? Araragi lost YPP as “generic or repetitive.” We’re asking YouTube to review the actual scenes and reinstate the channel.
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
YouTube demonetized our entire anime-story channel for “generic or repetitive content.”
Same characters. Different consequences.
One Naruto story has him face Jiraiya’s death. Another has him save Jiraiya and change what follows.
@TeamYouTube, reinstate Araragi.
Your Tiny Grandma reporting took the creative process seriously. Araragi uses AI tools and lost monetization as “generic or repetitive.” Would you look at our 49-second case and four published timelines showing how the stories differ?
https://t.co/jB8Gi68vpQ
https://t.co/LiboNU4cR8
YouTube demonetized our entire anime-story channel for “generic or repetitive content.”
Same characters. Different consequences.
One Naruto story has him face Jiraiya’s death. Another has him save Jiraiya and change what follows.
@TeamYouTube, reinstate Araragi.
@Feincodm I make full Naruto alternate timelines on Araragi. YouTube removed monetization as “generic or repetitive.” Here are the case video and published scenes showing what changes between stories. We’re asking for reinstatement.
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@Feincodm Give Tobirama five minutes to mark Naruto’s clones and that battlefield becomes a horror movie. You block one Rasengan and the next one is already behind you.
@NicholasLightTV You’ve spoken up about enforcement affecting anime creators. Araragi lost YPP as “generic or repetitive.” Would you watch the 49-second case and share it if the published scenes warrant another review?
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@InTheBardoonx Thanks for sharing our earlier reply. Araragi is still live. We lost monetization as “generic or repetitive.” If you’re tracking YPP suspensions too, here’s our 49-second case video and the published scenes.
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
YouTube’s policy allows a recurring cast when each video has a “distinct storyline, focus, or concept.” One Araragi story has Tsunade raise Naruto. Another changes village politics and averts the Uchiha massacre. That’s the evidence we want reviewed.
https://t.co/hk556rphXn
@iamkhrisgemini Your point about developing stories gets to the heart of our case. Araragi lost monetization as “generic or repetitive.” We put four published timelines side by side to show what changes. Would you take a look?
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@Dunkbuscus36508@TeamYouTube Thanks for offering to get the word out. If you’re sharing the case, here’s the short video and the four-story comparison. It means a lot that you’ve actually watched the stories and can speak to what’s different.
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@GLOBALCENTER14@MaiTai_Music@GrimfelOfficial@AethrMusik Josef, did you reapply, or did YouTube reopen the case on its own? Araragi’s appeal and a later review upheld a “generic or repetitive” decision. Here’s our short case video and scene evidence if you’re open to comparing notes.
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.
@Vrahno@_m3galophobia_@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@TeamYouTube Thanks for speaking up for other creators, Vrahno. Araragi lost monetization as “generic or repetitive.” We put four published timelines side by side and made a 49-second case video. Would you share them?
https://t.co/R6RT5fAnHu
https://t.co/waq9bDiRc5
"Wait 90 days" is easy to say when it isn't your livelihood.
I'm Araragi. YouTube approved my channel, then demonetized it 29 days later for "generic or repetitive content." My appeal was rejected. I never received my first payout. Thousands of dollars in estimated earnings remain unpaid.
Look at the stories below. These premises change Naruto's childhood, village history, relationships and future. YouTube's own policy allows recurring characters with distinct storylines. These differences deserve to be considered in a proper review.
@TeamYouTube, reopen this case and review the actual narratives now. If I have to leave to make a living elsewhere, there may be no channel left to return to on January 29. I put my days and nights into these stories. My audience and I shouldn't lose all of this over a decision our evidence challenges.
If you've watched Araragi, please speak up about what makes the stories worth watching. If you can get this evidence in front of someone who can help, please do.