@RichardMRe Yes, but I could have used a congressional example just as well. The point is that judges can act lawlessly and unreviewably in the world as it exists now. We can catastrophize about them doing so (as the book does) as easily as your post does about a hypothetical Congress.
@OrinKerr@vicnourse As to that particular test, (a) I think our system fails it (though the paper doesn't depend on that view) & (b) even if it didn't, one would need to factor in the magnitude of the problem. A 49% chance of a catastrophe is way worse than a 51% chance of just a kinda bad outcome.
Planned Flyover: Several F/A 18s will fly over the Verrazzano Bridge to the Mario Cuomo Bridge today 10/5 at 11:30 AM. Multilingual & ASL Link: https://t.co/h5FKlCd3Eg.
@vicnourse We acknowledge that it is politically dangerous and accept that it is unlikely in the immediate future -- the paper is premised on both points. I'd invite readers to see what we say about these points in the paper.
@OrinKerr@vicnourse That's just a simple illustration of how superordinate cooperation works, not a model for a convention--I guess that's less obvious than we thought it was. There is much discussion of actual convention practice in the paper, some drawn from violently polarized societies.
@OrinKerr@nyttypos My basic view is that interviews with SCOTUS justices are almost always uninteresting, as this one will be, but that the only (slim) chance of this one being minimally interesting is if the reporter is someone Alito trusts.
@OrinKerr Whatever its other pros and cons, courts will need to adjust their intuitions about the First Amendment if the regulatory analogy is going to get off the ground.
@OrinKerr It should not be submitted to a German-language philosophy journal because you don't know what it says. You can put it on SSRN with full disclosure of your process, which would make it scholarship about AI, not about philosophy. That seems fine.
@jadler1969 No, because (a) time was obviously of the essence to a degree not present in many shadow docket rulings, and (b) they can in such cases write an opinion after the order issues. I do think 1-2 sentences or even just a citation ID’ing a legal basis would be preferable to nothing.
@jadler1969 Given the clearly expressed views of the OP, reposting it and calling it interesting without saying more gives the impression that you think it is interesting for the reasons OP thinks it interesting.