@Spinoozaaa@sneako You’re begging the question. You assume disbelief is harmless, then use that assumption to conclude God’s punishment is cruel. "It doesn’t hurt anyone" doesn’t logically prove "it’s morally harmless." You need to establish that premise first.
@Spinoozaaa@sneako "Common sense" proves nothing here. Your conclusion only follows if you first assume that disbelief is harmless and deserves no consequence. That’s the very point you need to prove, not call "common sense."
@Spinoozaaa@sneako well, you call it "cruel," but on what basis? If God is the creator and Judge, why would you decide what he is entitled to judge? The real question is whether his judgment is unjust, not whether you personally like it.
@Spinoozaaa@sneako Well, almost every warning of hell is paired with glad tidings of Allah's mercy and Paradise. The Quran comes to you as you come to it. If you look only for threats, you’ll miss the hope. 🤷
@Jay_49erTikTok Or even before it was ever put into writing, it was publicly recited, and no one ever recited, “this book has no oil in it.” When it was later written without diacritical marks, no one read it that way, because the correct reading was already firmly established.🤷
@JaiNDoC_RL Even if that hadith were authentic, I do not see any issue with it; it goes without saying that one should not interfere in the private lives of families.
@mmacursed@mohammed_hijab You’re missing the point. Ibn Abbas explicitly cites Abdullah ibn Salam as the example, not randomly, but to define who is meant: those who recognized and accepted the truth.
So the verse is clearly about affirming witnesses, not disbelieving Jews or Christians.
@mmacursed@mohammed_hijab That is simply wrong. Ibn Abbas clearly states that it refers to people like Abdullah ibn Salam and his followers, those who recognized and accepted the truth. It is pointing to informed witnesses from the People of the Book who confirm it, not disbelieving Jews or Christians.
@mmacursed@mohammed_hijab Ibn Abbas is explicitly saying what I am arguing and supports my position. He explains that "those who read the Scripture" refers to knowledgeable and sincere People of the Book, such as Abdullah ibn Salam, who accepted Islam and recognized the truth.
@mmacursed@mohammed_hijab You are either ignorant or dishonest. Even the tafsir you referenced supports my position. If deceiving yourself helps you sleep at night, that is your choice, but do not misrepresent the Quran.
@K23295864@89marko89@Acts17David@mohammed_hijab@GodLogic_GL It does not even debunk Mohammed Hijab. He is correct: the Qur’an serves as the criterion for determining what is true in the Torah, since it states that some among the People of the Scripture altered, concealed, distorted, and misattributed parts of it.
@mmacursed@mohammed_hijab They all pretty much agree with me. They even bring up Abdullah ibn Salam, a Jew who literally accepted Islam. Your argument dismantles itself the moment the Qur’an is actually read. 😅