We are now mapping the ongoing Coldcard attack with a live dashboard - link below
I am deploying tripwire UTXOs that have varying levels of added entropy on top of the broken default seeds. We have different levels for 5, 10, 15, ... dice rolls, and 1, 2, 3, ... passphrase words.
This is so we can approximate the frontier of the confiscations that are actively happening.
The control UTXO with no added entropy was swept in an hour.
I took real measurements on an MK3 to calibrate a "good bad entropy" emulator in software. The control confiscation has proven it to work.
I am going to continue to deploy tripwire UTXOs along the bit curve.
Huge thanks to @Rob1Ham@otaliptus@PortlandHODL and other redteamers for the help.
The T. Rex Arms Field Manual Vault just got upgraded with its "Download All" button. And it's not just 4,200 manuals, it is now 6,400. And it's not just PDF and ePub, now it includes MD files. And it's not just streaming from our site, it's on the torrent networks.
One of the keys to winning over the next decade is to lean into the physical. Physical (hard) assets, physical skills, physical relationships. Things that the digital can't recreate or compete with.
“Where there is a mutuum, ownership passes, whence mutuum means, as it were, ‘yours from mine’ (de meo tuum). Therefore if I have lent you money…immediately the money is yours…Therefore, if I receive a fee for this, I profit from what is yours, not mine. Therefore the usurer sells the debtor nothing that is his, but only time, which is God’s. Therefore, since he sells a thing belonging to another, he ought not to derive any profit from it.”⁶⁷
I really don’t think people have thought this through.
Simple example that can stand in for a host of them: Air traffic control. A famously demanding job for genius shape rotators that puts incredible stress on those who do it and requires careful monitoring to prevent disaster due to human burnout. You would -want- to automate it if you could. Only…
Suppose your new ATC bot glitches. We don’t know why, but complex machines break all the time, and it’s a fantasy to believe that can’t happen here. Something awful happens - a crash, a collision, whatever.
Alright, that’s sad - very sad for the families. 😞😒 But it happens. Now, say you’re the head of the review board charged with figuring out what went wrong and fixing the system so it can’t happen again.
Problem: You’re no longer a trained air traffic controller. The ones you had are all aged out and often in disgrace - they’ve gotten the ‘90s steelworker treatment. They’re not available; they’re disinclined to help you; their skills aren’t sharp anymore; they may be on opioids. You’re it - it’s your problem. At most, you spent your education learning to prompt.
How do you troubleshoot that software?
And, of course, this problem is multidimensional. If it is a software glitch and not something else, you don’t just need an aviation expert to review how the plane collided with (whatever); you need a good software hack who can figure out how to debug your system.
But: Nobody knows how to do -that- anymore, either - the LLMs got good enough at it that people just vibecode everything now - the software geeks got the same treatment as the air traffic guys.
Now you’ve got a bigger problem. Possibly you can’t fix the glitch. Possibly you already have and aren’t sure. You’ll have to wait and see.
Someone points out that this would be a good time to revamp the training programs and requirements for being involved in this system - require a bachelor’s degree in computing or math or whatever in order to be involved, or institute an in-house program, which might be better and societally cheaper.
Sounds good, but: Nobody of note has written a book or solved a mathematical proof in 20 years; the universities are a joke; the best profs are retired or aged out (and salty and bitter, as above); nobody has trained any new good ones because it’s a low prestige profession in which you have to teach remedial reading and arithmetic to cynical kids who prompted their way through school to get this far, who are only in it for the credential.
And, of course, maybe it wasn’t the ATC at all - maybe it was pilot error. Easy situation to get in if your pilots are graduates of ChatGPT University and have trouble reading manuals and doing math. Maybe the cockpit has software that tells idiot pilots if they’re making a mistake. What if -that- had a bug?
So you need some pilots who are smart and well-educated, and some people who know what they’re doing to supervise and regulate them…
Do we see the problem yet?
This system can only work if a lot of people opt out of it and carry the load for the rest.
And there’s a lot of that going around.
> what you need to understand and accept is that bitcoin & crypto isn't this solid thing here. it's more of a moonshot thing again. it's a very digital thing in a world where everything digital is getting a shakedown.
it's time for you to wake up and smell the roses
there is no reality in which things continue smooth from here. no, bitcoin obviously isn't/wasn't going to stay put in some $70k - 80k range.
this is one of the most volatile eras ever. not just for bitcoin, but for the world. geopolitically, technologically, socially, we're going through rapid and dramatic change, and things aren't about to get simpler.
no, cybersecurity isn't going to all get fixed because you can now use ai to generate machine-checked security proofs in lean. even if you figure out how to write secure code and democratize the skill, there will still be vulnerabilities. if not bugs in the implementation, bugs in the specification. bugs in the assumptions, bugs in the verification.
cybersecurity will continue to be a verifiable domain, that's not changing, which means machines can self-play in it, meaning they can improve in it like in chess, except its actually worse than in chess because here the rules also keep changing, because technology keeps changing, so the gamefield keeps changing, meaning bugs will continue to be problematic, and especially problematic in irreversible systems (where one mistake means you get fully wiped out forever).
it's a hard system to keep stable! lean isn't coming to save you.
you'll continue to hear stories about how cybersecurity is about to improve and all the world's bugs will be fixed, because that is a popular narrative that tends to do well on twitter. no one wants to hear the defeatist point of view. but that means that some of you, who aren't able to figure this stuff out on your own, won't hear the truth very often.
smart people know this, not everyone agrees about it of course, but the negative point of view isn't going to get promoted on x/twitter.
the algorithms that are improving your life are about to learn how to improve themselves. the algorithms that are fucking with your life are about to learn how to improve themselves.
the situation now in which technology is about to enter a supersonic self-improving loop (a much more aggressive form than the baseline self-improving loop that we've been riding on since the dawn of time) is extremely bubble prone.
the prospect of investing in something *self-improving*? people will leverage themselves to the tits.
they will also be scared, flip-flop between being endlessly optimistic to extremely skittish and want security/safety. markets will be volatile. geopolitics will be volatile. everyone has the ability to react faster now, and there will be much more to react to.
no, crypto and bitcoin isn't going to stay non-volatile to that backdrop. the risk asset of risk assets, not even gold stays untroubled during turbulent times. it's going to be volatile. we spent a decade maturing as an industry. yes, we think we are owed some overdue maturity. we've aged through our teenage years and we're supposed to get rid of the acne. sorry, we're aging backwards now, you're going to get more acne and more bedtime erections, not less. the world isn't fair.
what you need to understand and accept is that bitcoin & crypto isn't this solid thing here. it's more of a moonshot thing again. it's a very digital thing in a world where everything digital is getting a shakedown.
you're almost 40 years old and your digital profession can be done by free open source software made in china run with a handcrank. your wife isn't going to let you gamble with your entire financial future in magical coins when you can't even tell her what your career prospects look like anymore. your beard is patchy.
bitcoin & crypto can still do well in this environment, because when technology, markets and geopolitics become ultra-volatile in unison, you're bound to also get weird market dislocations. you have arms races, you have bubbles popping, you might get lots of money printing. most things that can happen will happen.
but you aren't, as an industry, going to be a universal safe haven against this. no one really feels safe with their crypto assets these days. you got a hardware wallet? cool. that doesn't exactly feel like the safest of all places anymore.
you got your funds on an exchange? cool. doesn't feel great either, does it?
oh, but you're not impacted because you choose to hold your exposure through etps/etfs? well, if that's what you have to resolve to, that's not great either.
if you can't be secure with your crypto, if you can't feel safe with it, even though you're a freaking nerd in this industry, how does that bode for the industry at large?
much of the fuel that has driven e.g. defi to where it is today is because the risk was seen as tolerable. during 2020-2022 i knew a lot of people who felt okay with locking in hundreds of thousands of dollars in stablecoins in yield protocols. i don't know people who enjoy doing that today. people are tired of being bug bounties for north korea. they honestly prefer reversible systems for their life earnings.
this doesn't mean it is over for bitcoin & crypto, but it means you're going to have to accept that you may have to think about it differently. it is a diversified bet in your overall portfolio. it is a part of your portfolio. it can't be your entire portfolio.
if this sounds so bearish it sounds like the bottom signal to fully re-enter the market, sure. i'd love to become the pico-bottom perma-joke of our industry. i'm not saying for you to grow out of crypto, i'm saying for you to think of this as the volatile bet it is, the bet that macroeconomic/geopolitic turbulence/dislocations & fiat printing will outrank the fact that we're back in our teenage years again.
embrace that it will be volatile.
what's happening in the markets now is normal.