When did people start believing machines are suddenly superior to free weights for building muscle?
I keep seeing people argue that machines are better because they provide more stability and create less fatigue.
Sounds good in theory, but the research generally shows similar hypertrophy between machines and free weights.
I’m not against machines. I’ve used both for decades and believe both have a place in a well-designed program.
Stop limiting the tools in your toolbox.
For hypertrophy, I think exercise preference, proper execution, and progressive overload matter more than whether you’re using machines or free weights.
For athletic performance, it’s a different discussion. I believe free weights are essential for developing coordinated force production, strength, and stability. That doesn’t mean machines don’t have a place.
Not every theoretical advantage translates into better results.
Curious what others think. Are we overcomplicating exercise selection and putting too much emphasis on things like stability and fatigue?
I think it’s a much more nuanced. Multi sport can help with general physical abilities that carry over to other sports, avoid burnout and possible overuse injuries etc. On the flip side if your in season all the time and can’t spend the time in the weight room or working on more sport specific skills that can be a hindrance. Most if not all the carry over you get from multiple sports can be developed in other ways through proper training. The arguement about a lot of greats doing multi sport falls flat as correlation is not the same a causation. Elite athletes often are great at multiple sports because they are elite athletes. Let the athletes decide what’s best for them and just make sure if multiple sports can spend enough time in the weight room still and if 1 sport spend extra time on areas that they maybe lacking from in a developmental sense that the other sports could have helped provide.
This is true. However there is certain special strengths that are more sport specific. Example a wrestler should probably spend time working on grip strength while a basketball player doesn’t really need to do that. So yes overall much will look the same but some accessories will change depending on demands of the sport.
There are a few trends that bug me in the bodybuilding/hypertrophy community.
Claims that machines are superior due to stability is one of them. Studies have consistently shown similar results.
When stability becomes the limiting factor verses the primary target muscle then they have a point. But unless training on unstable surfaces like a bosu ball or new to weight training a free weight being less stable doesn’t equate to it being less beneficial for growth. One study of the top of my head compared smith machine bench press to barbell bench. The only real difference was higher activation in the medial delts but similar hypertrophy in chest and anterior delts.
Both have a place in a well designed program and imo free weight movements in general are much more fun to train. Use both.
@StrengthDebates 2-3 drinks 2-3x a week doesn’t seem to effect maintaining at all for me and I’m fairly lean. Getting in bodybuilding contest shape when I competed always 0 for minimum of 20 weeks.
@WhitneyGrenaway Continue as is and consider more total body movement or sit down and to limit to only upper. I have my youth wrestlers do both versions on occasion.
@LifeMathMoney@labs_vanguard There are numerous studies on machines vs free weights and the evidence suggests they are equal for hypertrophy. Do what you like. I prefer a less limited tool box and to follow the evidence and my 28years experience.
The majority (not all) of fitness influencers I see claiming to be science based cherry pick like crazy, overreach with the evidence they agree with and outright deny any evidence that doesn’t align with their beliefs.
Tom Brady explains his mental edge and why practice (not gameday) creates separation.
"There was a part of me that was a psychopath out there. I was extremely hypercompetitive every day. I didn't feel like let's get to Sunday and now it's the time...Every day is the time to give your best, even in practice."
Every day your standards are either reinforced or lowered by how you treat practice.
You don’t flip a switch into excellence. You rehearse it daily.
📹: Impaulsive Podcast
@DeanTTraining EMG testing shows same activation in chest. Point 2 is not how CNS and motor units work. Use whichever one you prefer if hypertrophy is your main goal.
@SamaHoole Do you have any evidence to support your claim. Dehydration blunts fat oxidation and metabolic rate. I can’t think of any reason to dry fast vs just fast for anything other then a religious purpose.
Young Athletes must develop Absolute Strength in order to become faster and more explosive.
Any increase in strength will directly lead to an increase in velocity for athletes with low training age (Bompa, 2005).
Build them Strong! 💪🏻📈