"Do you believe what happened in Gaza is a genocide?" Mehdi Hasan presses former Israeli official Avi Melamed and gets an unexpected counter-argument involving a secret 2021 Gaza blueprint and October 7 battle instructions.
Mehdi Hasan: So, uh, I said from Israel's perspective, the war in Gaza was a failure. For a lot of people around the world, for most Palestinians, it wasn't just a war, it was a genocide. Uh, it is a genocide. Last month at the UN General Assembly, Netanyahu dedicated an entire speech to not only rejecting the claim that Israel is committing a genocide, uh, but attacking anyone who says that, saying it's a blood libel, it's antisemitic, it's outrageous. Do you believe what happened in Gaza is a genocide?
Avi Melamed: No. What happened in Gaza is tragic. Many innocent lives were lost in Gaza Strip, and I mourn the loss of every innocent person on this planet... When you are talking about genocide, there are three boxes that you have to check. You have to have a formal ideology that calls to kill people for their gender or belief or whatever. You have to have a blueprint of how you're going to do that, and you have to have the execution... When you look at those three boxes and you try to find out who exactly checks all the boxes, the answer is, surprisingly maybe for many people, is that Hamas is checking all the boxes, not Israel.
Mehdi Hasan: They would say that's not the case; they updated their charter. I'm just saying, I'm not arguing about Hamas, but that's what they would say.
Avi Melamed: The second thing is that—here is something, you know, I mentioned earlier the issue of the blueprint... In the end of September 2021, Hamas held a conference in Gaza Strip, in a nice hotel, by the way... It ended up with some 20-articles paper, basically specifically making very clear that most of the people—the Jews in Israel will not survive... So this is the blueprint that nobody is talking about in the Western discussion.
Mehdi Hasan: Unfortunately—sorry, finish.
Avi Melamed: And then there is the last one box that has to be checked, and this is the execution. October 7, of course, was the execution... And I was reading that document, and it's very clear that this document is basically the guiding instructions for the execution of that master plan.
@KCrowley99@patbhamilton@Jonathan_K_Cook Including "the cookie monster" and "Adolf Hitler" in fact including anyone who pays the IAGS $30, that's the criteria for being a genocide scholar there and yes, you're right, NGOs like amnesty int and the UN are all notoriously anti Israel.
@SaulStaniforth@ZackPolanski It may have escaped your noticed but there is only one democratic state in the entire middle East and that's Jewish state Isreal. Islam doesn't do democracy, a majority Muslim "Palestine" state would be like Gaza, run by Islamofascist terrorists who execute people in the streets.
@patbhamilton@Jonathan_K_Cook That doesn't mean it will turn out to be true in the case of Israel.
And it is different in the case of Israel, as the genocide label is pushed greatly by badly motivated people, wishing to smear and demonise her.
@Jonathan_K_Cook It is an international court that determines whether a genocide has taken place and non have, and I doubt they ever will as the evidence contradicts this claim.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx I feel like a visitor at a zoo, watching a monkey screech and throw his own shit around, amusing at first but I have to confess, you are getting a bit boring now.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx If you're going to reply, tomorrow AM I guess when you're given your phone back, try and argue specifically against the points I've made, do it without abuse, memes, YT links, screenshots or gifs, if you can.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx There was no occupation in Gaza, and yet Oct 7th happened, Judea & Samaria land is disputed & their is no apartheid in Israel, 2 million Palestinian arabs live there.
But once again I find myself replying to a screenshot or meme because you are incapable of expressing yourself.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx More abuse, more quotes from other people, you are totally bereft of any thoughts or arguments of your own, the epitome of a low IQ individual.
You'd be better off spouting your meaningless abuse on YouTube comment section, adult discussion is not for you.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx Oh look, another meme, quoting other people again 🙄 🥱
The lady from Jaffa should blame the 5 Arab armies that started a war and lost, or her family could have stayed like the 2 million Arabs currently living in Israel.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx LOL, you have no argument do you? You are incapable of constructing one, you haven't refuted anything I've said, because you can't, you just come out with abuse, silly memes and quoting other people, that is your maximum level of Intellect.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx Dozens of countries were formed after the fall of the ottoman empire, including, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Iraq.. but its only the creation of the Jewish state you object to and Arab Palestinians could have had a state of their own in 1948 but they went to war instead, and lost.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx Oh, and if you're going to reply, try doing some independent thought of your own, rather than just post YouTube links and memes of other people's.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx Most Jews are Zionists.
Half the world's Jews live in Israel. There are dozens of Islamic states but antizonists want *only* the democractic Jewish state to be dismantled and replaced with yet another theocratic Islamic one, why? because they're antisemites.
@no1loonylefty@Obseyxx I don't know, nor do I give a shit who that guy is. Run of the mill Israel hating 'academic' would be my guess, they're 10 a penny.
I shall now eagerly await another 24hrs, when your allowed you to use your phone again, for another one of your stunning replies and hilarious gifs.