@ChrisjamesCincy@stephenfhayes Amazing, you noticed that I barely ever post.
Thank you for reminding me why.
Why it's typically not worth even trying to respond to someone who says something that seems obviously disconnected from reality.
A gentle "Where do you get that idea?" leads to "ur a troll." sigh.
@ChrisjamesCincy@stephenfhayes My best guess for one is "open borders"--that you're basing it on him opposing Trump's tactics. But he's also criticized Biden's "disastrous"ย immigration policy.
My guess for now is that when you see "criticizing Trump on ___" you read "supporting Trump's opponents".
@ChrisjamesCincy@stephenfhayes Come on, dude. Your list seems almost entirely disconnected from what I know of Hayes.
You say he's advocated for years for those positions. I can't find a single instance.
Put up--or embrace the irony of calling someone *else* a troll.
@ChrisjamesCincy@stephenfhayes Eh? Stephen Hayes of the Dispatch?
Can you give one link to one example where he advocated for what you think is a liberal policy in any of those areas?
@ChrisjamesCincy@stephenfhayes I'm curious, what "liberal" policies would you name that Hayes has "spent years advocating for"?
I assume you *won't* list something traditionally conservative like generally opposing tariffs.
@megbasham@jennfrey If an 1800s Christian mag with abolitionist articles got $$$ from a secular group to do more, would you say the same?
Your point is generally fair.
But seems majorly overstated here.
Colin: We started this in 2017. They liked it, so paid us to do more of what we already were.
@ConLawWarrior@TimothySandefur@ConLawWarrior I just read the fuller opinion.
I think the majority got it right , and Jackson misread why they were discounting the Black Codes example. They gave enough principle.
But what she said in those highlighted parts still seems exactly right, as far as it goes.
@ConLawWarrior@TimothySandefur Maybe a principle is: When the legislatures were blatantly violating some parts of the Constitution (equal protection), we don't need to give them any benefit of the doubt on whether they were trying not to violate others (the 2nd Am).
@whignewtons Consider: At the hypothetical extreme of "Noem didn't even send an email or have a single conversation" for the required consultation, is there really no review of that?
If it required notice-and-comment before determination, and that didn't happen, would there be no review?
@whignewtons i.e. required process vs substance.
Now, Courts shouldn't do barred subst review masquerading as allowed process review. And maybe they did here?
I haven't read the case yet. But if they held there's *never* review of process leading to determinations... that's sketchy.
@tally8076@kyledcheney Based on my memory and then some quick searching right now to confirm:
Article 3 chords have had their jurisdiction severely limited for *removal* orders. But not for habeas corpus challenge of *detention* orders.
@whignewtons Shouldn't we say voters shielded us all from *finding out* how much SCOTUS shielded Trump?
DOJ reindicted, but we never found out how it would have stood up to challenge under the SCOTUS ruling.
But also yes, SCOTUS absolutely shielded Biden, and that's underappreciated.
@MarkAllenbaugh@Quilly_Dilly@SCOTUSblog It's fine from my laptop, but shows the warning about expired domains from my phone.
There might be a problem with a fixed DNS record still getting propagated, so different people see different things. If so hopefully that will resolve itself as caches get updated.
@HoffProf@adam_shniderman I can't wait to read it and find out if there's a second shrub!
Only slightly higher.
So you get a two layer effect, with a little path running down the middle!