🚨AIIMS Coimbatore could be a reality soon. TN Govt is confident of getting an official announcement from centre post CM Vijay's request to PM Modi. They have already started looking for sites... #Kovai#AIIMS 🏗️🏥
For the kind attention of the public please!
All through the night, I performed a post publication peer review of this IIT Roorke paper that claimed that it identified chemical components in cow urine that could highly efectively kill Chikungunya virus in lab conditions.
https://t.co/dFJ6x2eIqQ
There are serious concerns in the paper that mandate post publication Editorial Review from the Journal and Publication Integrity Office, and need for validation of findings... that could mandate a retraction as per COPE Guidelines. A document with all concerns explained has been emailed to:
🟡Professor (Dr) Thomas F. Hofmann
Editor-in-Chief
ACS Agricultural Science & Technology
🟡Copy to: Publication Integrity Office
ACS Publications, American Chemical Society
🟡Copy to: Professor (Dr) Laura McConnell
Deputy Editor, ACS Agricultural Science & Technology
��Copy to:William King, The Managing Editor American Chemical Society
A lay summary of major concerns are provided below:
🔴Possible areas of data fabrication, manipulation, and internal contradictions in the study claiming antiviral activity of cow urine distillate (CUD).
🔴Identical efficacy values reported for different experimental conditions, suggesting possible data duplication or carryover.
🔴Methodological flaws, including testing at cytotoxic concentrations, invalidating antiviral claims.
🔴Manipulation of synergy thresholds, using non-standard cut-offs to falsely claim synergism.
🔴Inconsistent and contradictory GC–MS datasets, with discrepancies in metabolite identification and absent compounds.
🔴Identification of synthetic pharmaceuticals, such as medroxyprogesterone, as natural metabolites, indicating contamination or misreporting.
🔴Implausible detection of prostaglandin A1, which is unstable and unlikely to survive high-temperature distillation.
🔴Lack of direct evidence linking identified metabolites to antiviral effects, with concentrations in CUD unverified.
🔴Cytotoxicity confounding viral inhibition results, with host cell death possibly causing false positives.
🔴Weak in silico and biochemical data, with docking scores and enzyme inhibition results unreliable.
🔴Structural inaccuracies in molecular docking, such as improbable hydrogen bonds.
🔴Statistical and analytical misrepresentations, including inappropriate synergy thresholds and wide variability without proper significance testing.
🔴Undeclared conflicts of interest, as funding sources and author affiliations favor traditional and cow-derived products.
🔴Numerous inconsistencies across figures and tables, including contradictory retention times and unlabelled peaks, undermining data credibility.
Requesting for action from the Journal
@ACSPublications @AmerChemSociety @ACSReactions
➡️Initiate an editorial review under ACS and COPE guidelines.
➡️Obtain raw data: plaque counts, cell viability, GC–MS spectra, and metabolite quantification.Verify compound identifications and concentrations with independent analysis.
➡️Reassess the validity of the claimed antiviral mechanism based on verified data.
➡️Reevaluate synergy analyses using standard criteria.
➡️Consider issuing an Expression of Concern pending investigation.
➡️If unresolved, proceed with retraction to protect scientific integrity and public health.
@arunmohanother@ankit_a_g_k But the question is, would the average guy get the same salary when compared to tier 1 /2 cities or upcoming cities. As well as major companies, would they set up shop there compared to tier 1 cities.
This is the same rinse and repeat of low quality two studies funded by the manufacturer of the green jackfruit powder which was supported by the Kerala government. It is pathetic that the media keeps white washing these useless studies and its businessman when none of the actual clinical guidelines or diabetes societies endorse this dietary modulation. The media should stop becoming sycophants of the dietary supplements industry.
I used to have a Greta Thunberg phase. We are destroying the planet, what a disaster we are passing on to the next generation.
Now I'm like fuck it, fuck the next generation. Why should I save when Taylor Swift does 10 minute flights. Let's fuck this planet out while it lasts.
Thrissur voted for BJP because both UDF & LDF let the district down for two decades. No major projects or SEZs. Kerala's most entrepreneurial city was left to rot by successive govts. It was a protest vote. Thrissur is probably among the most secular places in the subcontinent.