Be careful which Bitcoin you accept. As of this message, we’re at block 982,649:
$ bitcoin-cli getblockcount
982649
Since late this summer, a lot of people have been trying to slip through a fork from the government mining cartels, which the community has dubbed “spamcoin”.
"I struggle to make sense of any of it" is the only accurate statement you've made. Everything else simply confirms that you are indeed confused.
BIP-110 achieved rough consensus and was activated on the nodes of everyone who declared that a chain containing non-signaling blocks from block 961632 onward would be invalid. It would not be Bitcoin, regardless of its length or accumulated PoW.
The SHA-chain, if you wish to call it anything other than what was discarded by Bitcoin, achieved at most rough acquiescence 😅 to becoming enslaved, leaving the decision to centralized miners. And it is not miners who enforce the rules of the Bitcoin network.
It is worth noting that had those few miners implemented BIP-110, all non-BIP-110 nodes, would have accepted the BIP-110 chain as valid without changing their implementation. Therefore, these node operators cannot be counted as opponents of BIP-110. Yet they could have expressed their opposition through URSF. And given that they delegated their decision to centralized miners, it is reasonable not to call them Bitcoiners. Centralization is not among the principles of Bitcoin's ethos.
Take the protocol seriously, along with the logical consequences of the rules by which it operates. Then the picture will become clearer and start to make sense. Otherwise, you're simply getting lost in the imprecision of language.
What does "I supported it" even mean?
Everyone who installed BIP-110 was, at that very moment, declaring that a chain containing non-signaling blocks from block 961632 onward would be invalid. It would not be Bitcoin, regardless of its length or accumulated PoW.
Those who had a valid BIP-110 chain but switched to Core in response to the miners' decision effectively rewrote the history of the very chain they had previously recognized as valid.
Do we take the protocol seriously, or do we treat it as yet another non-binding vote where the majority imposes its will on the minority and centralized entities have the final say?
@MajorianBTC And how much of this thing you call "consensus" is supposedly necessary?
Correction: This is coming from someone who strongly supported BIP-110 but doesn't understand how a decentralized network like Bitcoin works.
https://t.co/JnSx4A9xbn
Rough consensus is a technical term for how decisions are made in decentralized communities. It originates from the IETF
Consensus is a word that means many different things; it can mean rough consensus or it can mean something more concrete such as the actual block validity rules
Also, this isn't about me or Knots. It's about making Bitcoin work. I welcome competition, and don't _want_ to be in the position this puts me in (making me a target personally).
But the alternative is Bitcoin's certain death, which would be terrible for not only myself, but also mankind in general, including my children and future grandchildren.
This is not a battle we can give up or compromise on. We MUST win.
Wondering why Spamcoin ($BTC) tanked below $63,000?
Look at who’s selling.
Glassnode: listed BTC miners have sold nearly half their coins since January.
Riot sold 20,264 BTC through September.
MARA sold 13,597 since October.
The money is going into AI data centers.
The companies paid to secure the chain are dumping it to build something else. Its hashrate was already down 26% from the October peak when I checked last week.
When your own miners are cashing out, what are you holding?
#BTC is #Spamcoin
#XBT is #Bitcoin
⚡ Got a Spamchain Lightning invoice📲? Pay it with Bitcoin Lightning (BLAKE2b), from Kilowallet or any browser:
🌐https://t.co/w2MjZ5RfSy
🧅https://t.co/cXz16qo0LH
🔐 Non-custodial: your payment is held until the invoice is paid.
"So instead of the algorithms sort of honestly representing what's in the data, we can go directly to the [AI] companies, with clear TeChNiCaL AnD AdVoCaCy SoLuTioNS. For the first time there is a path to CoRrEcTiNg the digital world."
Such an ego-- anyone who actually understands what you have been doing to shareholders was sick of you a long time ago. Always lovely to see a billionaire taking advantage of naive retail investors. You're wasting your vast talents, and it's sad to see. Financial engineering is not how you "upgrade the world."
I'm guilty of this myself, and I agree 100%. Bitcoin is meant to help us restrain the very human weaknesses that have shaped the fiat system and enslaved so much of humanity. We shouldn't let those same weaknesses shape the system we're trying to build. Let the growth in value be a reflection of our success, not the objective itself.
@keyandchain21 Let's not try to cause any speculative bubbles if possible
Let's try to accumulate quietly and slowly while building real value
Eventually the price will have no choice but to go up, if our economy is robust enough
The emergence of a power law in a network such as Bitcoin is a fairly intuitive phenomenon if you think about it. We can model the value of the network as increasing with every additional possible connection between users (each representing a potential transfer of value between people). The number of these connections, in turn, grows according to a power law with an exponent of 2 as new users join the network.
When we combine this with feedback loops involving hashrate, fiat inflation, etc., an empirically derived power law describing the growth of the network's value expressed in fiat makes for a very compelling mathematical model.
All of this, however, rests on one fundamental assumption: that the network remains healthy.
Given the ongoing fiat-style paper spamcoin game, and the fact that those who understand what Bitcoin is and are capable of developing the network further in accordance with its ethos are now on the BLAKE2b chain, a deviation from the power law is not only plausible but to be expected.
There is no reason to expect the value of a network to keep growing when its underlying value proposition has been undermined.
But users wouldn't even have needed to adopt the new client. That's precisely the point. BIP-110 was a soft fork. Their existing Bitcoin Core nodes would have accepted the BIP-110 chain as Bitcoin without any modification. They therefore cannot be counted as active opponents of BIP-110. The miners simply continued mining on the chain for which no competing rough consensus had been established at the protocol level. Their actions did not determine which chain was Bitcoin.
Look, I'm not denying that it was the people running BIP-110 who changed the consensus rules on their nodes. Nor am I denying that they were a minority.
What I disagree with is the assessment that their numbers were negligible, or that, in light of Bitcoin Core v30, their proposal was unjustified or harmful.
There was a substantial group of people fighting to bring the protocol back in line with the idea Satoshi brought to life. The functioning and actively developing BLAKE2b chain, with its far more decentralized mining ecosystem, is evidence of that.
I used to believe that PoW was always the ultimate mechanism for determining which chain is Bitcoin. It turned out not to be the case. I wish reality were simpler and more predictable, but reality doesn't care what I wish for. It turned out to be more nuanced than I had assumed. You can either critically reconsider your assumptions and explore those nuances, as I did, or remain in denial.
At the same time, I'm not claiming to possess the ultimate truth. I've been proven wrong many times. But until someone presents arguments that refute what I've laid out here, I'll stand by the conclusions I've reached through my own reasoning.
Calling it a shitcoin or an affinity scam is not such an argument.
"Mental gymnastics." You can call it that until you start taking the protocol seriously and accepting the logical consequences of how it operates. What you're expressing is merely an opinion that is not reflected in the rules you enforce at the protocol level.
Let's test your reasoning with a simple counterfactual. Had miners decided to adopt BIP-110, would you still consider the resulting chain Bitcoin?
If so, on what grounds can you claim that users rejected BIP-110 rather than simply leaving the decision to miners?