Progressive and proud (not woke). A Dunglish typo star blocked by @PeterTatchell and @geertwilderspvv. Please follow @WorldBollard, @AllianceLGB & @Vrijlinks.
Studenten zwaarder gestraft voor wetenschapsfraude dan hoogleraren. Studenten worden geschorst of uit de studie gezet na plagiaat of niet-toegestaan gebruik van AI, en de hoogleraar zwijnt en gaat gewoon door.
Het zou natuurlijk andersom moeten zijn.
https://t.co/ZA8RSuBHdJ
Vier aanvoerders van de Gazavloot organisatie zijn al acht maanden gevangen in Tunesië. Maar nog steeds geen enkele Pallie-actie bij de Tunesische ambassade. Merkwaardig.
Dear @AnneKalvig72
When I heard you speak on November 3, you reached out to my heart and to the values I hold sacred. Being "cancelled" as a university professor and scholar of religion, because you recognize an overvalued belief system for what it is, feels profoundly unjust and bitter, not only because of your professional standing, but also because of your role as the primary breadwinner in a family with five children, and because of the career change that was effectively forced upon you, turning you into a gardener, caretaker, and cleaner. All the more powerful, then, was the humorous tone with which you delivered your message.
Several of your remarks resonated deeply with me: how, against your will, you have become a cautionary example to other women who hold similar views, and how your story intimidates them into remaining silent. Some people would say that you were not truly "cancelled" because you were able to tell your story at @AthenaForumEU in Brussels. But they do not understand the catch-22 of cancellation.
The damage done by cancel culture in academia is not limited to the high-profile cases that make the news. It extends to the hundreds of lesser-known academics who are quietly sidelined because of their ideas, ideas that may be factually valid but socially unacceptable. And it extends further still to the thousands who, upon witnessing the treatment of a single academic, choose to censor themselves and remain silent. As a result, theories that are factually incorrect but socially popular gain ground. Without genuine intellectual opposition and critical argument, science loses its capacity for self-correction.
Please do not think that I pay no price for my own parrhesia, although the price is not nearly as high as the one you have paid. I would simply appreciate it if more people who benefit from academic freedom were willing to share the cost.
To conclude: thank you for your courage in speaking the truth to power.
With all my heart,
Suzy
Thanks, @Glinner. I hope you don’t mind me going back over some of the history. It shows some of the difficulties we’ve faced: our attempts to understand and protect young people have been misrepresented as bigotry, and honest dialogue has been shut down since the beginning.
Sue @sueevansprotect blew the whistle in 2005. She was warning that young people with serious comorbid problems were being rushed into a medical pathway with very little psychological assessment. David Taylor, then medical director at the Tavistock, asked Jim McKeith to investigate GIDS. Taylor wrote a highly critical report in 2006. I was part of the senior management team, but its findings were never discussed there. The Trust buried it.
In 2019, I resigned as a governor because I realised history was in danger of repeating itself. The Trust was trying to bury David Bell’s report, which raised similar concerns to those Sue had raised in 2005.
That year I spoke alongside Stephanie Davies-Arai @cwknews and others at a House of Lords event organised by Posie Parker’s group, Standing for Women @StandingforXX and sponsored by Lord Moonie @Moonie_l Afterwards, we met in the pub to discuss what to do when there is a failure of medical authority. That was where the plan was hatched for Sue and Mrs A, the mother of an autistic child on the GIDS waiting list, to bring a judicial review. Sue put the case together with Paul Conrathe. Keira Bell @KBtheYoungOG was initially a witness in the case and later became a claimant.
While I was being interviewed by the Panorama team about GIDS in 2019, I told them about Taylor’s report. Hannah Barnes @hannahsbee was part of the team and later obtained the report through a Freedom of Information request. In September 2020, NHS England commissioned Hilary Cass @Hilary_Cass to lead an independent review of gender identity services for children and young people. The review account is @TheCassReview.
Newsnight reported on Taylor’s report on 1 October 2020. It showed that many of the concerns later raised in David Bell’s report had already been identified: a lack of critical clinical thinking, too little attention to the possible downsides of treatment, and little interest in follow-up or research. In other words, there was a lack of appropriate clinical curiosity. The High Court later ruled in the claimants’ favour, but the Court of Appeal overturned that ruling in 2021.
As I argued in my first paper, “Freedom to Think”, published in the Psychiatric Bulletin, clinicians need to be free to think, even when a patient may fear that thinking will introduce doubt and conflict. Thinking can be painful. It can bring anxiety and doubt in place of certainty. But it is crucial because it also protects us against misadventure. The wish to shut down discussion and thought is still represented in the Conversion Practices Bill. We are still fighting to bring to light what is happening in this clinical area and to stop a Bill that would have a chilling effect on clinicians’ ability to explore and thoroughly assess what is going on with these young people. @SexMattersOrg@Transgendertrd@genspect@CanSG_org #ConversionPracticesBill
In het VK waren verschillende momenten aan te wijzen dat signalen over grote problemen met kinder- en #jeugdtransgenderzorg terzijde zijn geschoven: whistleblower @sueevansprotect wier signalen leidden tot het kritische Taylor rapport (2006), het David Bell rapport (2019) en later @hannahsbee 's boek Time to think (2023). En natuurlijk de #CassReview (2024).
Het is aan de @Gezondheidsraad om aan te tonen dat deze misstanden (negeren van #comorbiditeiten, geen #heteroanamnese, geen aandacht voor populatieverandering) níét zouden gebeuren in Nederland.
@OlafDekkers@AnnelouDe@VWSTweedeKamer@ministerVWS
It is difficult to articulate the level of embarrassment I feel for the American people having to endure this man as their President. A nation that gave us Lincoln, FDR, Eisenhower, Obama and Reagan . . . . . .
and now Trump!
Calling women “non-transgender women” is not neutral precision. It reframes the sex class that the category was built to protect as the residual group.
Who wrote this nonsense?
Yes, sex is binary (your body is developed for providing eggs, or producing sperm which limits you possible role in reproduction), yes, on a group level women and men show overlapping Bell-curves for many traits - girls speak earlier, men are taller etc.
Everyone can make their own choices for their life, career, etc. based on their mental and physical possibilities and cultural constraints.
Patriarchal cultures limit women's choices.
You don’t have to respect what you own. So Xi doesn’t respect Putin, Putin doesn’t respect Trump. But China needs the US and its market for the foreseeable future.