@garylfrancione@SwipeWright@RealLastStand@genspect@stellaomalley3 like cutting? if so, yes to both in ordinary cases. although i can imagine versions of both where i think they are non-pathological (thin parallel to bodybuilder; cutter parallel to sexual masochist).
reality's last stand is hosting a debate between @stellaomalley3 and i, about genspect's current campaign to repathologize trans identification. there is a reader poll you can vote in before you read, and at least with colin's audience, genspect's position is the one to beat!
"The history of psychiatry imposes obligations on everyone in this debate. We need to tread carefully, avoid overdiagnosis, and refrain from assuming that an intervention is justified simply because professionals endorse it or patients urgently seek it."
@stellaomalley3's contribution to our exchange over @genspect's REPATH campaign is now up at reality's last stand ⭐
This is my response to @aytchellesse’s essay on @SwipeWright’s page.
It is such a thrill to FINALLY take part in nuanced debate where we disagree and yet we can handle it
https://t.co/zPwW9uquqP
Guest post on the philosophy blog @DailyNousEditor attempts to convince us that the philosophy of sex and gender is a perfectly healthy subfield; ends up convincingly demonstrating the opposite.
"If medicine is to remain grounded in evidence, it must cultivate the psychological sophistication to question its own certainties. The true test of evidence based practice is not how we respond to evidence that confirms what we already believe, but how we respond when it does not." Sallie Baxendale in @JConIdeas.👇
Very pleased to see that Kate Harris, my wonderful co-founder of @AllianceLGB, has finally come out of the shadows on X. 🎉🎉🎉
Please follow her: @Kathari17674744
She is impatient, often rude, but one of the most brilliant, inspiring people I have ever known.
She unleashed — with a little help from me — a global revolution to reclaim gay rights from the gender identity mob.
published in a top-5 philosophy journal earlier this year, the publication likely career-making for its junior co-author:
"Everyone wants their gender identity to be respected, and cisgender people typically have their gender identities respected as a matter of course."
unstated & unargued presuppositions: everyone has a gender identity; when 'cisgender' people say they are men/women they are making a claim about gender identity not a claim about sex.
one of the referees (normally anonymous but in this case acknowledged): talia bettcher.
right—all of which makes it even more baffling that this could appear in the top-ranked normative theory journal in philosophy, and the only one i know of where papers go to a vote by the associate editors rather than merely having to make it past reviewers.
re: trans embodiment, katie zhou is a junior trans philosopher who i consider genuinely good, and she has a couple of recent papers that push against gender identity alone and argue for a return to embodiment. i'll find the link and put it in the next tweet in case you're interested to read.
i looked up the authors and the junior one says in their bio that they want to help with trans liberation. i have no idea if they are themselves trans, but if they were that would explain a lot. did you find it weird that they distinguished three types of respect without acknowledging that not all identity claims deserve equal respect and without then explaining why gender identity is a kind that does? i mean they arrived at transwomen in women's prisons on remarkably thin grounds. (cool that you're reading it, it is great for me to be able to discuss it!)