@robinhanson This thought experiment seems to be premised on the retributivist idea that the purpose of jail is to inflict an amount of punishment proportional to desert. If you instead think it’s about rehabilitation, the answer seems a clear ‘no’.
@MattLutzPhi (actually 4)
3. It’s a recent concept. [Not true and so what]
4. No one concept can do everything it’s supposed to do. [Shows that probability is a family of related concepts, which is already explicit in the distinction between subjective and objective probabilities]
@MattLutzPhi The problem is you gave 3 different reasons for thinking the concept is incoherent, all of which were totally implausible:
1. There’s no analysis. [Applies to almost everything]
2. We don’t know which ontological bucket to sort it into. [Not true and so what]
@MattLutzPhi I'm still confused about what you're looking for that would tell you "what probability is" and why that demand doesn't grossly overgeneralize. Also it's most likely (!) that 'probability' is polysemous and includes a family of related concepts, no one of which does all that
@MattLutzPhi@Mikeydumusumeci FWIW I think it's a respectable view to think that objective probabilities don't make sense (or that non-extremal probabilities don't exist if determinism is true), but it's wild to say that probability as a whole is an incoherent concept
@MattLutzPhi@Mikeydumusumeci I think it's uncontroversial that subjective (epistemic) probabilities are mental and objective (physical) probabilities are physical phenomena. Not that I see why it matters for the coherence of the concept, and since you're a physicalist (I presume) it's all ultimately physical
@Mikeydumusumeci@MattLutzPhi Seems to be not having an explanation of what makes probability facts true. You know, unlike for 'knows', 'causes', 'able', 'should', 'means', 'possible', 'table', 'dog' -- all perfectly respectable concepts with widely accepted analyses.
@MattLutzPhi I doubt that (probably! only the formalization is recent), but either way, so is, e.g., calculus and backpropagation. Probability is used throughout science, the law, decision making and has an axiomatization. There's not many more respectable concepts around.
@MattLutzPhi Is this a bit or do you really think because we have no good account of what probability is, it's an incoherent concept? Goodbye almost every concept
@birchlse These questions remind me of high school English essays. Half of them should be answered with an explanation of why the question is ill-posed.
@simondgoldstein@NevinClimenhaga I would think if anything Nevin's theism is more relevant. Maybe there are theological reasons why God wouldn't let AIs be conscious. (I might be making this up but I have some sense that some Christians want to say all morally important people are biological descendants of Adam)
@MBluenoser@majestyofreason He’s got a whole series of papers against various kinds of finitism employed in kalam arguments. Some are coauthored and some are solo. I don’t see any reason to think he has, or needs to, change any of his views on these.
@MBluenoser@majestyofreason there’s nothing related to the ontological argument or the kalam, which is the other major argument he has criticized in print (iirc). So again it seems like he doesn’t like the ontological argument, which is consistent with his view in the asymmetry paper. [2]
@MBluenoser@majestyofreason Yeah so it’s perfectly consistent to think that both arguments don’t work (original and reverse). I doubt he ever thought that the asymmetry was sufficient to make the reverse a good argument. I noticed in his document of resources relevant to his conversion [1]
@MBluenoser@majestyofreason Being a catholic doesn’t require accepting that the ontological argument is good. He can still accept everything in that paper consistently
@majestyofreason I guess the complaint is that this response makes the psychonomic harmony problem much broader than it seems to be described in sec 4, in a way that potentially compromises its independence from related problems [3]
@majestyofreason Insofar as the issue becomes "why are there mental states at all" or "why are the psychophysical correlations neat and tidy", it seems like we should expect that to be answered by whatever answers we give to the hard problem and to psychophysical harmony [2]