Why do major outlets keep framing brain decoding research as a dystopia in waiting? (NYT this week, MIT Tech Review last month)
Maybe it’s the “mind reading” label, or maybe fear just drives engagement, but bookending these pieces with hints that AI will soon read out your deepest secrets, detect your lies, or serve you brain-optimized ads does a disservice to the richer, more optimistic conversation I think the work deserves
fMRI in particular is far too noisy and fragile to ever be useful for lie detection or nonconsensual decoding (moving your head a few mm ruins the scan, decoding only works with a cooperative person, MRI is expensive & a huge immovable machine)
What we are near are brain foundation models and other neuroAI advances getting good enough to help patients in new ways like reducing symptoms, detecting lesions, tracking clinically meaningful outcomes
Where’s the discussion of treating psychiatric disorders with real-time fMRI neurofeedback? Or using brain foundation models to predict disease progression and treatment response, or to speed up drug discovery?
These ideas have real research going on right now, not in an unknown dystopian future, and yet with the current media coverage on the research the average person wouldn't know, and may instead be scared rather than optimistic
Note: neuroethics & discussion on mental privacy are important! but coverage should spend at least as much time on what this research can do for good as on what could go wrong
You know, in this age where results are everywhere to be found, I feel a deep sense of luxury in the process. God, it feels luxurious to cut out the pieces for each frame of my paper animation. To feel the friction of paper against the scissor blades, to feel the gentle bruise on
…some unsolicited response to “Phase Lock”’s claim. Human-AI merging via alignment is valid, but we should not assume AI scaling laws directly apply to BCI. Brain is not simply a data source to be decoded, as LLMs do.
https://t.co/ow5A8pt4HZ
Agent Skills, OpenClaw and World Models, come join us to build the next frontier of intelligence, along with @xai@moonlake@inworld, @belindmo, etc., next Saturday on 3/14!
RSVP: https://t.co/dimu5mWFLn