The appointment of Mustapha Ghorbal to referee the Haiti–Scotland match raises serious questions. How could FIFA have entrusted such an important match to a referee who had been suspended from the Algerian league following highly controversial decisions? While Haiti feels it was denied key calls, Scotland secured a historic victory—its first in the World Cup in decades. To preserve the credibility of global soccer, FIFA must ensure complete transparency in the selection and evaluation of referees. Fans have the right to demand explanations when refereeing decisions influence the course of history.