As Ugandans we are in great danger. This is the biggest double standard in Uganda's tax system.
YOU: If you import a container, you MUST use a licensed clearing agent. You MUST wait for URA to verify. You MUST wait months. If your invoice is $1 off, URA uplifts your value, seizes your goods, charges you 50% penalty.
SOME CHINESE COMPANIES: They clear THEMSELVES.
It's called AEO - Authorized Economic Operator.
And here are the FACTS:
1. WHO AUTHORISED IT?
@URAUganda, under Commissioner General John Musinguzi, and Commissioner for Customs.
In May 2021, Uganda signed an AEO Mutual Recognition Arrangement (MRA) with China at the 5th AEO Global Conference in Dubai.
On 1st June 2023, Uganda and China LAUNCHED the implementation in Kampala. Uganda became the FIRST country in Africa to implement this deal with China.
2. WHAT DOES IT MEAN?
URA's own website says it clearly:
An AEO is "a company highly trusted by the revenue body - that even with less surveillance, such a company is expected to assess itself and willfully pay taxes."
They are allowed to:
1. Self-assess their own taxes
2. Self-declare their own values
3. Self-manage their bonded warehouses
4. Go through the BLUE LANE - no physical examination, only post-import audit later
5. Clear in 8 HOURS instead of 4-5 days
URA itself said: "AEOs are able to self-regulate, self-assess and work seamlessly with URA."
3. WHO GOT IT?
Uganda now has 118 AEOs. 60 are importers/exporters, 18 are self-managed bondholders.
The most famous example: Huawei Uganda.
URA gave Huawei AEO status and bragged: "Huawei's clearance reduced from 4-5 days to only 8 hours." Huawei itself said it is now among only 5 Huawei subsidiaries in the world to get this status.
And China has over 5,000 AEOs. Under the MRA, URA now RECOGNISES Chinese AEOs. That means a Chinese AEO in China can ship, and a Ugandan AEO linked to them clears fast here.
4. WHY IS THIS DANGEROUS?
Self-clearing means: Declare, Under-declare, Mis-declare.
If you declare yourself, who checks you?
URA Commissioner Kagumire HIMSELF admitted the problem before the MRA: "Relying solely on taxpayer-provided information has led to potential revenue losses due to inaccurate reporting. Where we were supposed to collect 100%, we could collect 50% or less."
So URA KNEW that self-declaration loses 50% of revenue. And then they gave self-declaration powers to the biggest importers?
And Ugandans already saw the result:
In 2018, URA published a list of 148 companies doing VAT fraud with fictitious invoices. 93 were foreign-owned, 90 had Chinese directors. URA said they stole UGX 200 Billion between 2015-2017.
In 2016, URA found Chinese company stamps in Uganda used to forge invoices to under-declare motorcycles from $2,500 to $380.
So the question is simple:
Why does a Ugandan trader in Kikuubo get treated like a thief, while a Chinese AEO gets treated like a trusted partner?
Why does a Ugandan have to pay a clearing agent, wait 6 months, and get his container opened 3 times, while an AEO clears in 8 hours without being opened?
Why does URA say "we don't trust Ugandan invoices" but trusts a Chinese self-declaration?
@URAUganda, @JohnMusinguzi, we are not against trade facilitation. We are against TWO LAWS.
If self-clearing is good, give it to Ugandan traders too. Give AEO to KACITA traders who have complied for 20 years.
If self-clearing is risky, don't give it to ANYONE.
But don't give a fast lane to foreigners and a punishment lane to Ugandans in their own country.
Some of you don't even realize how bad the situation is. What you see @AgoraCFR posting are only a few Lucky cases that get to the media. So many Ugandans are being abducted on a daily that the media can't even keep up with the updates.
So when you see the reasons the U.S gives for advising their citizens not to travel to Uganda, treat those reasons with the importance they deserve because it reflects a fully researched reality.
They lack the intellectual capacity to engage or challenge anyone constructively. Their only tools are abduction, torture, and unlawful imprisonment;all in an attempt to silence those they perceive as rivals.
FREE EGESA
FREE EGESA
FREE EGESA
๐๐Slowly by slowly, you'll realize why litigation is useless practice to specialize in as a young lawyer.
Now imagine, spending time honing your legal knowledge only to appear before such a judge.
Funny thing is he is the Chairperson of the JSC, the very Institution mandated to hold disciplinary action against errant judicial officers.
It's a tough market for lawyers because ultimately you can never be good of a lawyer in a country with no respect for the law.
The now-deceased Tooro kingdom leader visited some high-end hospitals in Kampala after feeling persistent backpain. X-rays, MRI scans later, they told him they saw nothing.
Being a person of means, he flew to a hospital in Nairobi where he was diagnosed with cancer. A year later he was dead. What did the doctors in Nairobi see that the Kampala ones couldnโt?
Well, Nairobi has a Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scan or a few. Kampala and the whole of Uganda donโt. A PET scan costs about $3m (Shs 11.7bn) or approximately 17 Land Cruisers.
If there was a meeting of government officials, you would run out of space to park them. That is how many we have in Uganda but a PET Scan is not something we have been able to buy and install yet.
https://t.co/kZ4PB2kkpO