Ukraine as the Fulcrum
If you care about preventing crime, you believe in the police enforcing the law by arresting criminals so that other potential perpetrators think twice about doing the same thing and so there can be justice for the victims. This is basic Society 101.
1/6
@DavidLimbaugh@JonahDispatch Lifelong Texas Conservative here. I voted straight Democrat in 2026 so MAGA would get burned to the ground. I’m pretty sure I was not alone.
@DavidLimbaugh@JonahDispatch Lifelong Texas Conservative here. I voted straight Democrat in 2026 so MAGA would get burned to the ground. I’m pretty sure I was not alone.
The Victoria Nuland cookie coup story is one of the most prevalent yet incoherent active measures ever.
The leaked Nuland call most often cited as evidence of an American coup plot in Ukraine demonstrates the total inverse of what is claimed by Russia's agents of influence.
The leaked recording DOES show that Nuland expressed a preference wrt who should win political power in Ukraine (once it was already clear that power would shift) but it also shows that this preference was informed by her desire to "fuck the EU" in a dispute between Russia and Europe over Ukrainian bi-lateral trade.
The protests happened because Yanukovych wouldn't sign the Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement to which Russia was opposed.
Nuland wanted to likewise "fuck the EU" by getting Yanukovych's eventual successor to go with a fifteen billion dollar bailout from Russia instead.
The entire context of the call was Nuland and Ambassador Geoffrey Pyatt strategizing about how to "land jelly side up" with the Russian bailout that Yanukovych failed to sell the Ukrainian public. If they were actually "plotting a coup" as Nuland's ostensible critics claim, they were plotting it on behalf of the Russian Federation.
And that makes sense given that Nuland's entire career was launched by having been Chief of Staff for Strobe Talbott while he was negotiating the Ukrainian nuclear disarmament deal that paved the way for Putin to later seize Crimea and parts of the Donbas region.
The Maidan revolution was not, in fact, a CIA coup orchestrated and executed by Nuland. She did not entice hundreds of thousands of protestors into the streets with a couple trays of cookies, as the narrative goes. To the contrary, Maidan was an organic right-wing uprising against the joint effort of Moscow and Washington to reverse the independence that Ukraine nominally gained as a result of leaving the USSR.
@DavidLimbaugh@JonahDispatch Lifelong Texas Conservative here. I voted straight Democrat in 2026 so MAGA would get burned to the ground. I’m pretty sure I was not alone.
Not sure who needs to hear this, but the following are NOT inciting a coup.
1. Handing out water and bread to protestors.
2. Discussing which candidate is better or worse for America.
3. Providing HOST NATION APPROVED financial aid and assistance from USAID
Of course, the following ARE actions to incite a coup:
1. Unannounced shut down of Ukraines energy in winter (repeatedly) over a decade.
2. Corrupt payments and buying off elected officials.
3. Sniper assassination of protestors.
4. Denying a nation to undertake sovereign decisions such as signing a free trade agreement with other nations.
5. A foreign nation controlling media
6. Economic coercion to demand Russian be taught as a primary language in school.
7. 2004 Russia direct funding to a political campaign (receipts exist).
8. 2003 Russia building a dam on Tuzla Island to deny water into Ukraine.
“Under my administration, there will be no pleading for meetings with Vladimir Putin. He will be treated as the gangster and thug that he is. And yes, I stand by that phrasing…”
- Senator Marco Rubio
@libertadorzn@sikorskiradek@elonmusk Will you be switching places with a Ukrainian stuck on the wrong side of a line you demand in the name of “peace at any cost?”
Or are you a coward? Or a sheep?
I want to begin with a word of thanks, and I mean it sincerely. Starlink has played an enormously important role in maintaining communications in Ukraine since the beginning of Russia’s full-scale invasion. And in February of this year, SpaceX, working with Ukraine, introduced measures to block the unauthorised use of Starlink by Russian forces. This helped counter Russian military operations, including the use of attack drones. We remember this, and we appreciate it.
But I would like to explain what the current controversy is actually about.
Musk argues that Ukraine wants to use commercial Starlink for offensive military operations. He emphasises that Starshield is a separate system controlled by the US government.
However, this explanation does not address the specific question Ukraine has raised: why are Starshield restrictions interfering with Ukrainian interceptor drones designed to protect civilians from Russian aerial attacks?
Russia uses jet-powered Shahed drones that travel at speeds well above 161 km/h. According to Ukrainian military reports, Starshield terminals lose connectivity once they exceed that speed in areas where the restrictions apply. This makes it more difficult to operate interceptor drones that need to catch up with Russian targets. On 12 November, President Zelenskyy explicitly stated that these restrictions allow more Russian strikes to reach their targets, resulting in the deaths of Ukrainian civilians.
So this is not simply about the ability to strike Russian military targets. It is about Ukraine’s ability to intercept a Russian drone heading towards a residential building, a hospital, or a power station. This is defence in the most basic, human sense of the word.
Now, who made the decision?
Musk maintains that Starshield is controlled by the US government and that decisions concerning its military use fall under the Pentagon’s authority. On 21 October, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said he was unaware of the administration having been informed in advance about the restrictions, and that access and speed limits were governed by the relevant commercial contracts. The Wall Street Journal, citing its sources, reported that Musk personally made the decision to impose the restrictions. Reuters, meanwhile, cited other officials who pointed to the White House. The Trump administration denied involvement, while SpaceX disputes reports of new changes to the restrictions in November.
I do not know which of these accounts is correct. But I see an obvious problem: Ukrainian military personnel are reporting restrictions that affect their defensive capabilities, while responsibility for those decisions remains unclear.
This uncertainty has also raised questions in the United States. On 13 November, US senators formally called on Musk and SpaceX to preserve technical records, correspondence, and documents that could establish who authorised the restrictions, when and on what grounds, and whether their consequences for Ukrainian air defence and the civilian population had been assessed.
There is another contradiction.
When asked directly in the interview whether Ukraine actually uses Starshield, Musk responded by saying that Zelenskyy was not telling the truth and that what he really wanted was to use commercial Starlink for offensive operations. Yet back in December 2024, Bloomberg reported on Pentagon contracts with SpaceX providing Starshield services for a total of 3,000 terminals in Ukraine. A US government agency confirmed that figure to Bloomberg. And in October of this year, Musk himself publicly explained that decisions concerning Starshield restrictions fell under the authority of the US government.
This does not prove that every Ukrainian terminal operates through Starshield, but it does establish that Ukraine had access to the system under these contracts. Therefore, accusing Zelenskyy of being untruthful requires a specific technical explanation, not simply a denial.
I also want to acknowledge Elon Musk’s personal role at the beginning of the full-scale invasion. On 26 February 2022, just two days after the invasion began, Mykhailo Fedorov appealed to him to provide Starlink connectivity to Ukraine. Musk responded immediately: the service was activated, and the first shipment of terminals arrived in Ukraine on 28 February. SpaceX had also been preparing to launch the service in Ukraine before the invasion.
This was critically important assistance at a moment when Russia was attempting to destroy Ukraine’s communications infrastructure. The speed of Musk’s response, his personal involvement, and his willingness to provide Ukraine with technology on which communications, defence, and human lives depended deserve genuine gratitude. I want to thank him once again for that.
A few words about history, because accuracy matters here too.
The Maidan was not a coup organised by the United States. It was a months-long popular protest movement that began after the Ukrainian government abandoned preparations to sign the Association Agreement with the European Union. The protests were marked by violence, and dozens of protesters were killed in February 2014. After Yanukovych left Kyiv, the Ukrainian parliament, the Verkhovna Rada, adopted a resolution on 22 February declaring that he had withdrawn from exercising his constitutional powers and calling early presidential elections.
The legal aspects of that decision, the role of external actors, and US diplomatic influence can all be debated. But none of this constitutes evidence that Washington organised a coup. Mr Musk presented no such evidence. Instead, this version of events is one of the central narratives Russia uses to justify its aggression against Ukraine. I find it deeply disappointing to hear it from Elon Musk.
And finally.
Musk speaks about the need to have empathy for those who die in war, including Russian soldiers. I understand this argument: every human life matters. But empathy should not erase the distinction between the responsibility of an aggressor state and the right of a country under attack to defend itself.
Moreover, the moral consequences of restricting communications cannot be judged solely by whether the technology helps carry out strikes. We must also consider how many lives it helps protect.
If a Ukrainian interceptor drone loses connectivity and can no longer catch a Russian attack drone, that does not mean the use of lethal force has been avoided. It means that other people are placed at greater risk — civilians in their homes, in their beds, in the middle of the night.
So my request is simple. Whoever makes these decisions must explain them openly, and responsibility for their consequences must be established. Restrictions on critical communications infrastructure, on which the protection of civilians depends, should not be introduced without proper justification, advance warning, and coordination with those directly affected.
@Watch_This_Now4@tbm48091@joshrogin You know what makes your statement even stupider:
Maidan: Dec2013-Mar2014
russia invades Crimea - Feb20,2014
Yanu flees to russia: Feb 21, 2014, Rada removes:386–0; installs Turchynov
Poroshenko elected in free election: Jun2014.
Zelenskyy elected in free election: !! May2019 !!
No, @elonmusk.
Stop mouthing Russian propaganda.
I was there and there was no coup in Kyiv in 2014.
And the US contribution to stopping the pro-Russian President Yanukovych’s massacre of Ukrainians on the Maidan was Victoria Nuland handing out cookies in the streets and saying ‘ Fuck the EU.’
No, @elonmusk.
Stop mouthing Russian propaganda.
I was there and there was no coup in Kyiv in 2014.
And the US contribution to stopping the pro-Russian President Yanukovych’s massacre of Ukrainians on the Maidan was Victoria Nuland handing out cookies in the streets and saying ‘ Fuck the EU.’
@Watch_This_Now4 Here is something that is not exaggerated. There is no justification whatsoever for russia to have at any time entered Ukrainian territory. ZERO.
Hence, russian orcs can, at anytime, turn east & go back to their sh*thole country. Ukraine will solve Ukrainian problems, not putin.
@Watch_This_Now4@tbm48091@joshrogin I’m asking to you to listen to her own words and put them into the context of the time. There was no coup. The tape and the facts on the ground do not support your false narrative.
It’s Ukraine, not “the Ukraine”, vatnik.
Trump: "Here's my friend."
Yes, that is the man of the hour, shaking hands with a killer and a war criminal, and grinning about it.
The midterms settled the question. Fewer than 4% of Americans have any time for Putin.
So who are the people cheering this on? Trump's administration. His family. A handful of friends who owe their jobs to him. That is the entire fan club, and Texas just flipped to make the point.
Trump doubles down anyway. He loves his war criminal more than he loves the country that elected him, and in the process he has torched 80 years of American credibility, the alliances that won the Cold War, and the trust of every democracy that ever stood with the United States. The rest of America knows exactly who it belongs with: the free societies of the West. Not a kleptocracy in West Asia run by a man wanted in The Hague.
He didn't just embarrass America. He made it smaller.
Stay connected, follow @Microinteracti1