As a psychiatrist Iโm clueless as to what this means
How is opening or repurposing buildings in different places the answer?
Where do they think *community* mental health teams are based now? In hospitals?
And, through their actions around this case, these individuals have done so much damage to the necessary and important changes that DEI initiatives can deliver.
Jason Arday has resigned. Yet the Baroness and Professors who appointed him, and the Sirs, Dames, and Lords who rushed to defend him while accusing his critics of racism, remain in their positions with the drawbridge still up. The CEO of a company embroiled in a scandal often resigns even if they did not personally commit the wrongdoing, because they're accountable for the company's failures. But those who made and celebrated a decision that ultimately damaged the reputation of a fantastic university โ a jewel of both the UK and academia more broadly โ face no comparable accountability. They retain their positions, tenure and honours.
@policywishes Fine if everyone started from the same point, but they donโt. I do believe that some allowance has to be made to reflect the reality of talented people from less advantaged groups. Their contribution and success would otherwise be missed and weโd all be poorer for that.
@Oldboatie Massively. And I donโt really him - he seems a run of the mill chancer. But his enablers and supporters, who arenโt stupid and must have known they were defending the indefensible, should look at their positions. Particularly the Master of Jesus, who would have known all.
@Oldboatie That will pass and they will be judged on their outputs, performance at the next REF, etc. The real and lasting damage will be to legitimate and honest scholarship supported by DEI initiatives which are necessary and good.
@Oldboatie Of course. We all know what the standards are. I was an undergraduate at Jesus and I think there are questions to answer at the College level, too.
@Oldboatie I know. Even his claimed publications taken at face value would have struggled to get him appointed to a lecturer position in most universities.
I try not to RT this crew because I donโt want to give them more airtime, but the replies to this are just great-patients speaking up for themselves about the real value of diagnosis.
One last thing. I think that, having belatedly done the honourable thing, we should leave Arday alone for him to fade into obscurity.
We shouldn't allow the academics and managers who promoted him as a PR exercise, then threw him under the bus, to get away with it.
The FND field has ongoing discussions about proper diagnosis and risk of misdiagnosis. There are publications on it. Hard to know that when you arenโt a clinician or in the field which is fine, but letโs stop acting like clinicians donโt care about misdiagnosis. Itโs not true.