Today’s announcement that the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group will be disbanded is overdue and welcome news. It’s a testament to years of organizing by New Yorkers who refused to let the city ignore what the SRG was doing in the streets. People kept making this demand, and they pushed the administration to act on it.
There still needs to be accountability for everyone the SRG brutalized. The officers who hurt people should face consequences, and so should the NYPD commanders who kept calling them in knowing how they operated. At protests I organized, I saw how much more aggressive officers across the scene became when the SRG showed up. I’ve seen NYPD officers assigned to observe protests in a legal capacity get physical with protesters. I’ve seen officers from the Internal Affairs Bureau, the very unit that investigates police misconduct, get physical with protesters too. The NYPD still has to answer for that conduct.
I saw how much more brazen the NYPD got under Eric Adams. When you have a former cop in City Hall who’s quick to defend the department, officers know they can get away with more. The NYPD takes its cues from the people in power. That’s exactly why we can’t let up now. When the department brutalizes and arrests people for protesting, we need to make sure we do not look away and that the NYPD faces accountability for what it did.
I’ve organized protests where I told NYPD officers directly that they were violating the Payne v. de Blasio settlement. They told me they didn’t care. Lawyers on the scene were also telling officers they were violating the agreement, and legal observers were documenting what happened. The NYPD had agreed to a four-tier system that required it to try to de-escalate before stepping up its response. I watched officers do the opposite. Any organizer knows what it usually means when you hear that a protest “turned violent.” The NYPD made it that way.
The settlement gave us a way to challenge the NYPD when it violated protesters’ rights, and officers violated it anyway. The limits Mamdani announced today give us more specific rules to point to when we challenge police conduct. We’ll see whether the NYPD actually follows them when we’re back in the streets, especially when we’re protesting something the people in power would rather we stay quiet about.
I want reporters, lawyers, and legal observers paying attention from the moment the police show up. Document who gave the orders, what officers did, and when they broke the rules. Ask the NYPD what consequences followed, and keep asking after the headlines move on. We need to hold the department accountable in the media, in court, and in the streets.
This is only as much of a victory as we make it. The law responds to power, and we have to keep building ours to make sure the NYPD actually follows the rules announced today.
Disbanding the SRG is welcome news, and long overdue, but it can’t be a rebrand, and it isn’t accountability.
I watched this unit raid Columbia again and again because the university’s trustees and the Adams administration colluded to crush pro-Palestine protest at any cost. Together, they terrorized a whole community.
We must continue to seek accountability for the brutality and surveillance that were unleashed on our community, and for everyone who ordered them.
Inbox: @NYCLU Executive Director Donna Lieberman praises Mayor Mamdani for disbanding the NYPD's SRG — but adds: "We also remain concerned by the creation of a new patrol unit, however limited, that is tasked with protest policing. We will be monitoring this new unit closely."
To be clear they’re getting rid of one unit, the SRG, while adding two new units, FAST and PSD, who will have the exact same strategic prerogatives as the SRG, and since they’re not reducing the employment of the NYPD they’ll just be shuffling SRG members into those two new units
Part of why we can’t challenge Hakeem Jeffries is because there’s just so much money protecting him. So instead, we are going to work with him to get money out of politics
“… the Police Department’s First Amendment team, which does carry weapons.”
So we “disbanded SRG” and just invented out of thin air an NYPD “First Amendment Team”, who of course will be at protests *carrying weapons*.
what the fuck actually goes on
Buried the lede - the CURB Act, the most meaningful change that could currently happen to NYPD's protest policing, is going to be an open-field clash between Mamdani & Menin. The other changes are windowdressing that can and will be undone by a more conservative mayor
The NYPD’s “Savior” May Finally Be Leaving. Good Riddance!
Jessica S. Tisch, Mayor Zohran K. Mamdani, and a Reported January 2027 Exit
Well, well, well!
It appears the NYPD's celebrated “Savior,” Police Commissioner Jessica S. Tisch, may FINALLY be on her way out.
According to inside information I have received and vetted, Tisch and New York City Mayor Zohran K. Mamdani allegedly had a HUGE blowout, and Tisch is reportedly expected to leave the department in January 2027.
There has been no public announcement, but I take the information seriously.
My reaction? GOOD RIDDANCE!
For far too long, Tisch has benefited from a carefully manufactured public image portraying her as the indispensable executive capable of rescuing the NYPD from corruption, incompetence, and institutional dysfunction.
What a remarkable public-relations achievement.
Unfortunately, publicity is not leadership, press conferences are not reform, and declining crime statistics do not absolve an executive of responsibility for misconduct occurring within the organization she commands.
Under Tisch, the NYPD continues to confront serious allegations of sexual harassment, supervisory exploitation, retaliatory discipline, favoritism, selective enforcement, and misconduct extending into executive management.
And let me be perfectly clear: Tisch is not merely an unfortunate administrator struggling against a dysfunctional culture. In my judgment, she is part of that culture.
She knows exactly what I mean.
I have deliberately kept certain information concerning the department's executive hierarchy close to the vest. My decision not to disclose it publicly does not change my assessment of her leadership.
The notion that Tisch is somehow indispensable to the NYPD is absurd. No police commissioner is indispensable, particularly one whose administration warrants serious scrutiny over its handling of employee misconduct, supervisory abuse, and institutional accountability.
Now comes the possibility that Tisch could land at the New York State Police.
GOOD LUCK, NYSP!
If that happens, the State Police will be inheriting an executive whose NYPD leadership record deserves considerably more scrutiny than the glowing publicity surrounding her name.
Governor Kathy Hochul would do well to examine the substance of that record before confusing political influence and favorable headlines with executive competence.
And Mayor Mamdani?
If Tisch departs, he will finally have an opportunity to install leadership capable of confronting the NYPD's deeply entrenched culture without protecting the same executive interests responsible for perpetuating it.
Replacing Tisch will not automatically repair the department. But retaining leadership that is part of the problem certainly will not solve it.
The NYPD needs no savior. It needs a commissioner who understands that accountability begins at the top—and that the top is not exempt from accountability.
If January 2027 marks the end of Tisch's tenure, it cannot come soon enough.
Don't let the door hit you on the way out.
#JessicaTisch #ZohranMamdani #NYPD #NYSP #KathyHochul #PoliceAccountability #CivilRights #NYPDReform #SelectiveEnforcement #PoliceLeadership #InstitutionalCorruption #NYC #EricSanders #TheSandersFirmPC