@Robotbeat@andrewtevans There certainly should have been follow on from DC-X. Imagine if NASA had selected McDAC and Delta Clipper instead of Venturestar for X-33.
@heskelbalas@Robotbeat@andrewtevans I don't think they had the math or theory, or metallurgy for it. At best they might have had something like a Newcomen atmospheric engine.
1) SpaceX is an aerospace company. Getting made at them for not solving health care affordability is like walking into Denny’s and yelling at the waitress because your washing machine is broken. Totally incoherent.
2) Space travel has actually led directly to a number of lifesaving health care innovations.
3) If our ancestors had waited until health care was perfect and nobody was poor and hungry before they started exploring, innovating, and discovering, we’d all still be living in mud huts and killing our dinner with spears right now.
I was strongly critical of Trump before their publication even existed. But how could I ever in good conscience support the Democrats, or fail to oppose them? They're bad on every policy issue from the womb to the grave. They're a persistent, longstanding menace to the Constitution, constantly trying to undermine & dismantle it. They're bad on every issue of norms, good governance, & honest politics. Corruption is baked into their ideology & the structure of their coalition. And they've only gotten worse over the past decade. Trump will sooner or later be gone, but the Democrats will still be with us. To pretend that they are the lesser threat requires draping everything about their party in a mendacious fog of euphemism. I decline to sell my integrity so cheaply. I will stay & fight for the only party that has any chance to do good. I will stand my ground.
@JackKuhr From an energy standpoint, orbit was always roughly equivalent to transoceanic flight on a per pound of payload basis. The difference between aviation and spaceflight is power, not energy. With full reusability, we finally actually care about propellant costs for rockets.
@Okie_Rancher@peterrhague How could it have? It used 1970s (in some cases, 1960s) technology, by specific design. The monumental achievement of the program was to take expensive engines designed to be reusable and throwing them away on each flight.
Ouch. This one really hurts.
More delay for the Leo constellation.
I imagine we'll hear even more national security launches shift to SpaceX some time in the future.
And of course, we'll have to wait even longer for Dream Chaser to finally have its free-flyer mission. I'm really begging for Sierra Space to get an alternate route to space.
@Okie_Rancher@peterrhague It was an idiotic comment. There was no administration in which SLS would have been that. It was, and remains, antique technology with zero hope for opening the frontier.
@bsilone@filippie509 This is so far beyond Shuttle, this only reveals the degree to which people don't understand what a failure the Shuttle was in terms of cost and cadence, relative to the promises for it.
Thomas Jefferson had a copy of the Quran because he wanted to understand the religion of the terrorists who attacked U.S. ships and told him that their holy book commanded them to do so.
Thomas Jefferson didn’t have a copy of the Quran because he revered this ideology.
So schauen Ergebnisse aus, wenn ein Visionär wie @elonmusk arbeitet.
Und Deutschland? Europa? Sie belächeln die Amerikaner, schimpfen über Musk und suhlen sich in einer längst vergangenen Zeit, als deutsche Ingenieurskunst noch vorzeigbar war und eine führende Rolle spielte. Besonders in Deutschland fehlen Mut, Visionen und der Glaube an uns selbst.
Elon Musk ist der Da Vinci unserer Zeit. Derweil in Deutschland? Nichts!
Wir haben Omas gegen Rechts, Genderdebatten ohne Sinn, Klimaziele, die jedwede Innovation vernichten und ständig diese „German Angst“.
Statt Innovation und Vision gilt in Deutschland „Hosen voll“.
It's obvious why this is the case. We can tell from the observable fact that women generally want to marry men who are a little older, a little taller, and a little more intelligent than they are.
If some element of superiority and implicit dominance isn't there, desire won't be either. What does that suggest about the sex lives of husbands who feminize themselves?
The sad part is that many couples have been taught to pursue "equality", not realizing that this is usually a recipe for mutual sabotage. It sounds good in the abstract, but it collides badly with human instinct wiring.
Maybe you think it shouldn't be this way. I might even agree with you on some level. But our genes and our instincts don't care. They don't care at all.
That first post testing starship failure is gonna hit bro.
Would be nice if it never happens, but with their planned flight rate it’s basically inevitable
In the wake of Friday's air traffic control meltdown, I've been thinking about ATC modernization. I'm convinced we can rip and replace the whole system for less money than we spend maintaining the current broken one—while meaningfully improving safety. Taxpayers could get a dividend, not a new bill.
But it would require doing politically uncomfortable things, like building the whole system on Starlink, eliminating almost all air traffic control jobs, and changing the day-to-day experience of pilots.
The current system is so insane - literally we have pilots talking to controllers on two-way radios. If two people press the "talk" button at the same time, they can't hear each other. And it only gets worse from there.
So here's an early-draft sketch of something better.
* Every airplane has dual-redundant Starlink antennae.
* Establish that the reliability of dual-link Satcomm beats the current system (I think it will, handily).
* Starlink implements better-than-GPS global positioning
* Every aircraft uploads position and trajectory data in realtime
* This simple system replaces every tens of thousands of radio and radar sites, each of which is fragile and expensive to maintain. We don't need old copper lines. Or new fiber ones.
* It also replaces all of the ground-based navigation and approach systems. ILS, RNAV, VORs and even airport ground surveillance — literally all of the legacy navigation claptrap can be ditched
* To fly in the national airspace, every airplane must have Starlink (or equivalent, if/when someone makes an equivalent)
* Perhaps, airborne weather data and radar returns are also uploaded in realtime. With critical mass, we can have a 3D synthetic view of realtime weather without needing today's weather ground stations. Improved weather predictive models can be built and deployed. This will be great for cost and for safety.
* Cloud ATC and pilots communicate over satcom-based text and/or structured digital communication. This functionality should be built into cockpits, but that won't happen quickly with Boeing/Airbus slowness so pilots can use iPhones/iPads/EFBs and effectively just text with ATC instead of talking on radios like they do today.
* Similarly any ground vehicle on an airport (fire trucks, fuel trucks etc) must have a satcom connection with realtime position reporting, with the ability to make requests digitally and respond to commands. This allows the system to manage runway incursions and ground collisions that are a real problem today.
* Non-emergency ATC is completely automated, no need for humans for routine traffic control.
* Right now, we have maybe a few thousand airplanes in the air across the country at any given time. But the skies are huge and can support far more traffic with far more efficient automated routing.
* The hard part is unexpected situations, emergency management. There is 24/7 human staffing for this, which would require maybe ~1% of the ATC staff we have today.
* This will save *so much money* we can give controllers five years of severance and pay for them to go back to school to learn another trade.
* SpaceX should be willing to develop and operate the whole system for free, because it will result in selling more Starlink service.
Start with en-route traffic and run the new system for a little while in parallel with the old and monitor for where human interventions are required. I think the new system will quickly prove it's better than the old, then can be turned off.
This is far from fully worked out, but I'm convinced a much, much better system is possible. It would need hardcore leadership and significant bipartisan political will. Maybe that's laughably impossible, but I don't want to be so pessimistic.
The short term is that this vehicle delivers an ungodly amount of bandwidth to orbit in terms of larger Starlink satellites. Including direct to cell capability. This will be disruptive to the connectivity market. Also in the short term this enables NASAs lunar plans for the next few years.
Medium term, this shifts a whole bunch of marginal space business plans into profitable territory. Stuff like space solar power, asteroid mining etc. - but this is determined by how much of this capacity SpaceX makes available to external customers and at what price.
@peterrhague I think Musk understands that politics is more of a threat to space exploration than radiation, meteors, equipment failure, and all other catastrophes combined.