When you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras.
The question of the past 5 days is whether near-simultaneous system outages across infra, transportation, communications, etc. are horses or zebras.
Enough people on many sides of these issues (defense hawks, anti-AI, doomers, anti-tech, IT people, etc.) can find their own common threads across MSFT, FAA, United, Chase, NSA, AAPL and turn them into a theory. Depending on your perspective it explains things or seems like a (wild) conspiracy.
If you're looking for horses, the common thread is approaching the classic system lockdown of pre-Thanksgiving through end of January. It would be very straight forward to explain all of these as just gearing up for that travel/retail/operational load and lockdown.
The AI line through this is two-party.
First, that many vendors (and OSS projects) have been using AI to find potential vulns and patch them. It is reasonable to assume the volume of patches has increased as the find rate has and the knowledge that once found in-house they were found outside. The volume of these fixes is likely stressing systems and so compatibility or breadth testing might not be a higher priority than getting fixes out there even if they break stuff.
Second, the client/customer side of this should be (but might be) also using AI to test their infrastructure. They are likely finding many configuration holes in networking and permissioning. Changing these is always non-zero risk even in the best of times and trying to push those through before next week is a must do knowing again that adversaries are also looking and downtime during the holiday is a true disaster. In addition, the patches from vendors are being applied in essentially real time. There's no other choice as the patches coming out now lack the time and pacing to obscure what they are fixing making them information rich for bad actors.
Neither of these preclude being closer to zebra hoofbeats—meaning adversarial attacks. The zebra scale can be anything from a single coordinated actor to literally a bunch of people all with the same tools pointed at different targets. The latter is possible because these tools all make it to all the curious/bad actors at the same time. That was the Friday FBI warning (https://t.co/Sxhz58rUc7). It is not much of a reach to think independent actors all started testing this out. Apple, Microsoft, Chase are obvious kinds of targets for stuff like this. But realize those are also exactly the entities moving quickly to get to a patched and locked down state.
The most common thread is that all the systems are big and complex with the fragility primarily driving not by "bugs" in layers of the code but by configurations and permissioning that are extremely difficult to test and get right, and also very rarely reproducible by any vendor in the mix. This can broadly be called a challenge with legacy or just big systems.
Overlay the new reality that AI is in fact driving which is an increased pace of identifying, fixing, and deploying code changes. We are collectively going to go through many more system downtimes than previously experienced until the technology stack (IT people and infra) get better at this new speed. This is exactly what the industry went through going through Y2K and just after with Windows XP. The past two decades, SaaS and mobile included moved at a well-rehearsed and comfortable pace. I discussed that here -> https://t.co/dugl4MRYWw
The FAA one stands out as not fitting this patten nearly as much. This one deserves more investigation because it involves new hardware. That's a known risk across all vendors but especially this type of hardware and even vendor(s).
The diversity, timing, and apparent type of complex issue point to much more classic hoofbeats. It is easy to see the timing and assume coordination but the timing can also be because of availability of tools and the holiday.
PS: CNN reporting that echo-sigma .com sales are +800%. As a prepper product of the cold-war it is fair to say that unless you've been preparing a backpack with a tube tent, multi-tool, and 3 days of life boat rations will not be of much help. Covid taught us that.
Enough debating what AI is or might become. It’s time to build on what it is today.
An AI Action Plan: 10 concrete work items for Labs, enterprises, developers, and government—security, agents, access, liability, copyright, & more.
Let’s get engineering. https://t.co/FzYHYhfyrn
People (many on Wall Street) have been treating gpus (or the tokens they consume/produce) like minerals or oil since the start of AI. Combine that with existential doomers detailing the end of civilization and you have a recipe for the government claiming it’s only responsible for it to control is like they do for oil/mineral rights or nuclear weapons.
When I was an intern the company I worked for (now Lockheed Martin) won a huge contract to modernize the FAA. Enormous.
Modernizing the ATC system has literally been a 50 year ongoing project.
Governor, @RonDeSantis you're half right. Obamacare didn't protect the insurance conglomerates. Most of them lost money and left. What it protected was the business model: a narrow network and a doctor rate so low that doctors walk.
I'm a surgeon. Here's what that looks like from my side of the desk.
Before 2010 I could buy an individual plan online for $200 a month and pick from six or seven insurers. I could go anywhere in the country. And my deductible was less than $1,500.
Yes, that was a healthy person's price, and yes, the pre-existing condition problem was real. But here's what replaced it.
The average Obamacare enrollee today can see 40% of the doctors in their area. One in four practicing physicians is in no exchange network at all. In Chicago it's 60%. Exchange patients are twice as likely as people with employer coverage to skip care because they can't find a doctor who takes their plan.
That's not insurance. That's a card.
And insurer profits did explode, just not where you'd think. UnitedHealth went from $5 billion a year to over $22 billion. The money didn't come from the exchanges. It came from the government paying private insurers to run Medicare and Medicaid, with every denied claim as margin. Obamacare didn't protect the conglomerates from competition. It made them the government's contractor.
And the competition? In 2018, half the counties in America had exactly one insurer on the exchange. It recovered, and now it's sliding again: single-insurer counties nearly doubled this year alone.
Meanwhile the law handed hospital systems every reason to buy up independent practices. They did. Private practice went from 80% of doctors to 18%. Facility fees followed. Hospital prices are up 281% since 2000. The doctor line went backwards.
So no, the insurers didn't win with exchanges. The hospital systems won. The administrators won. The patient got a plan their doctor doesn't take, a premium that went up 9% this year, and a deductible that doubled.
And now the answer from the other side is to take the rate that drove the doctors out and make it the only rate in America.
Obamacare proved that coverage is not access. Medicare for All would prove it nationwide. @KFF #obamacare #medicareforall
There would be a massive market opportunity unlocked if there were good local models that could run on a mobile device.
There are vast amounts of data on our phones that is too private and too large to give to a frontier model—especially in today’s cybersecurity environment.
The benefits may not accrue to the model developer but it would be a big win for society.
There would be a massive market opportunity unlocked if there were good local models that could run on a mobile device.
There are vast amounts of data on our phones that is too private and too large to give to a frontier model—especially in today’s cybersecurity environment.
The benefits may not accrue to the model developer but it would be a big win for society.
University debate: "Beef is the most wasteful food on earth."
Vegan: "It takes 25 kilos of feed to make one kilo of beef. Any other machine that lost 96% of what went into it would be scrapped."
Farmer: "25 kilos of what?"
Vegan: "Feed."
Farmer: "Grass. How much of it can you eat?"
Vegan: "None. That isn't the point."
Farmer: "It's the whole sum. A gold mine shifts a tonne of rock for five grams of gold. Nobody stands at the gate complaining about the waste of rock."
Vegan: "Rock isn't food. That land could feed people directly."
Farmer: "Two thirds of Britain's farmland is grass. Most of it is too steep, too wet or too thin to be anything else. You're welcome to try it with a spoon."
Vegan: "They're fattened on grain at the end."
Farmer: "Mine finish on silage and what the brewery throws out. The barley made your pint first."
Vegan: "Even so, 25 to one is indefensible."
Farmer: "A wheat plant is roots, stalk, chaff and grain. You eat the grain. That's about half of it wasted before the miller starts. I don't see a motion about bread."
Moderator: "Closing lines, please."
Vegan: "A hungry world can't afford a food that takes 25 in to get one out."
Farmer: "25 kilos of something you can't eat, off land you can't plough, for one kilo of the best food there is. I'd call that the only free lunch in farming."
Without question, this has to be the greatest speech ever given on an original episode of “STAR TREK” by anyone, other than CAPTAIN KIRK — Actor ELISHA COOK JR. as SAMUEL T. COGLEY, Attorney-at-Law, from the TOS season one episode “COURT MATIAL!”
@ramez They can no better define AGI, transformative AI, or singularity, than they can alignment. These are all know it when you see it.
In that case I think being able to declare so as a private company would be advantageous versus a public company.
This sell-off has been driven by a perfect storm created by: 1) The Blue Tidal Wave win and fears about an anti-AI/anti-datacenter DC, 2) losing the global leader of the AI Revolution Jensen in his black eye moment, 3) China driven regulatory concerns across the rest of semis/memory stocks (e.g. AMD short report yesterday), 4) multiple market clearing events which have just led to more selling, 5)Anthropic IPO being a massive success but marginally reducing liquidity from other tech names, 6) significant fund P&L pain diminishing buying power, and 7) sticky inflation and hawkish Fed speak with concerns around more hikes and constricting financial conditions….The $4 trillion AI buildout is still happening and our tech thesis into 2027 remains.
If you have $1 in net worth, you have more net wealth than the poorest 28% of U.S. families combined. This ranks near the 9th percentile of wealth
Oh, and Elon matches the combined net worth of the bottom 37%, not 53%
Bernie needs fact checks!