More polemical claims:
(5) Assigning credit to humans for proving precisely-stated open conjectures doesn't make much sense now. It's very hard to measure the human contribution to this, if it exists; at the rate the models are progressing, the marginal value of this contribution is likely comparable to that of "wait a few weeks."
(6) There are lots of mathematical tasks the models are not good at yet (theory-building, open-ended exploration, exposition, etc.). While I expect the models will get much better at these tasks, if we want to reward personal human achievement, we should for now focus on these things.
(7) There are other tasks for which there are intrinsic obstructions to the models replacing human activity (achieving personal understanding, satisfying one's personal curiosity, institution-building, the aspects of the profession with a social-relational-component). If you believe (as I do) that human mathematical understanding has intrinsic value we need to be incentivizing these activities.
@elielwtk@jerrrrrrryyyyy lean bug very unlikely— and bugs in the multiple other kernels it passed are also unlikely. it may help to know kevin buzzard is a leading expert on formalization and neurotically stringent about these things
JUST IN: Mathematicians divided over “cuckulus” — an emerging field of mathematics where they ask AI to solve unsolved problems while they just sit back & watch.
I don't know whether I'm more surprised that (a) AI claims to have proved the Riemann Hypothesis or (b) that it claims to have produced a coherent proof that, written out in human-readable format, is 250,000+ pages long.
@turbomander it’s because common color words are primarily decided by berlin and kay theory, not by splitting the visible light spectrum. interestingly, russian splits blue into two common words: light blue (голубой) and dark blue (синий). kinda like red and pink
.@GregAbbott_TX Every time I hear your name, I pick this up, I hold it for a while. Greg, I hear it crack sometimes. What do you think I’m going to do when it breaks someday